Re: Ch9 AFL Division 6 - 2015
Posted: Tue Dec 09, 2014 9:18 am
no_remorse28 wrote:Am I the only one getting a headache from all this umpire talk?
Far too early in the morning to be digesting stuff like this.
no_remorse28 wrote:Am I the only one getting a headache from all this umpire talk?
Footy Chick wrote:no_remorse28 wrote:Am I the only one getting a headache from all this umpire talk?
Far too early in the morning to be digesting stuff like this.
morell wrote:Yeah fair enough,
Principally, my key points are:
1. The standard of umpiring in the SAAFL is not good enough - for a myriad of reasons - and should be improved
2. They are nowhere near accountable enough for poor decisions and performances
3. We have developed a culture of over protectionism of umpires - which causes a myriad of problems and limits our ability to address #1.
4. Umpires discussing teams and their reputations with a predetermined course of action is an abject disgrace - but a long held suspicion.
Bombers4EVA wrote:morell wrote:Yeah fair enough,
Principally, my key points are:
1. The standard of umpiring in the SAAFL is not good enough - for a myriad of reasons - and should be improved
2. They are nowhere near accountable enough for poor decisions and performances
3. We have developed a culture of over protectionism of umpires - which causes a myriad of problems and limits our ability to address #1.
4. Umpires discussing teams and their reputations with a predetermined course of action is an abject disgrace - but a long held suspicion.
Mate you obviously haven't been to man of my games that I have umpired. I umpired nearly all of the games this season gone and not one player from the opposition complained about any decisions I made or didn't make.
Hmph! Didnt know that. Sounds awesome FC! Good stuff.Footy Chick wrote:FWIW - we do now have a full time umpires manager.
You may or may not know him, some guy that did a little bit umpiring called Richard Williams
Your clubs will now have a first point of call with someone that actually knows the rules like the back of his hand. Not to many that would know more than him.
morell wrote:Yeah fair enough,
Principally, my key points are:
1. The standard of umpiring in the SAAFL is not good enough - for a myriad of reasons - and should be improved
2. They are nowhere near accountable enough for poor decisions and performances
3. We have developed a culture of over protectionism of umpires - which causes a myriad of problems and limits our ability to address #1.
4. Umpires discussing teams and their reputations with a predetermined course of action is an abject disgrace - but a long held suspicion.
morell wrote:Yeah fair enough,
Principally, my key points are:
1. The standard of umpiring in the SAAFL is not good enough - for a myriad of reasons - and should be improved
2. They are nowhere near accountable enough for poor decisions and performances
3. We have developed a culture of over protectionism of umpires - which causes a myriad of problems and limits our ability to address #1.
4. Umpires discussing teams and their reputations with a predetermined course of action is an abject disgrace - but a long held suspicion.
Q. wrote:I think the umpires at this level still have a very good interpretation of the laws. For me, the issues arise when they make a decision 50m off the play without a good view, and that only comes about from a lack of fitness. But you've just got to get on with the game as a player, as it's not like we're all specimens of supreme fitness ourselves.