Re: SANFL Junior codes
Posted: Mon Aug 26, 2019 12:19 pm
Was anyone actually there???
Broken Down Hack wrote:Players being assisted off ground with trainer during finals games cannot come back on no matter the Injury.
Just wondering I watched the girls GF down Richmond last Sunday and a girl had to hope at least 50 meters
to the bench with no assistance from trainers, was later told
if helped off she could no come back on, she looked like she twisted an ankle, she came back on after a bit
Of rest,
I understand player safety but all year players come off with bumps and bruises assisted by trainers and go back on why
Is it different for finals
Thoughts
MW wrote:Broken Down Hack wrote:Players being assisted off ground with trainer during finals games cannot come back on no matter the Injury.
Just wondering I watched the girls GF down Richmond last Sunday and a girl had to hope at least 50 meters
to the bench with no assistance from trainers, was later told
if helped off she could no come back on, she looked like she twisted an ankle, she came back on after a bit
Of rest,
I understand player safety but all year players come off with bumps and bruises assisted by trainers and go back on why
Is it different for finals
Thoughts
Which game was this one in @Broken Down Hack ?
woodublieve12 wrote:Was anyone actually there???
Moe wrote:woodublieve12 wrote:Was anyone actually there???
1 blue card for Unley spectator before half time.
1 blue card for Plympton coach late in 3rd quarter. Loudly questioning a holding the ball decision, which was not given, no swearing involved, but you simply cannot do it.
1 blue card for Plympton assistant coach (or close by), for audibly questioning first blue card.
Let's not hang people out to dry too quickly.
The bottom line is this: Too many clubs are putting Junior Premierships ahead of developing good juniors, and good people. Some parents are disgraceful, and are destroying it for everyone else.
I am no angel. I am the only person who has ever received a blue card at our club. I audibly yelled out "Thats a sling tackle" in under 10s years ago. I shouldn't have, took my punishment. Side note, it was a sling tackle.
Moe wrote:Some parents are disgraceful, and are destroying it for everyone else.
Dutchy wrote:Absolutely, if he hasn't been booted out of the club already there is something wrong.
A second blue card to a coach should stop the game and don't recommence until he has driven off in his car.
Moe wrote:woodublieve12 wrote:Was anyone actually there???
1 blue card for Unley spectator before half time.
1 blue card for Plympton coach late in 3rd quarter. Loudly questioning a holding the ball decision, which was not given, no swearing involved, but you simply cannot do it.
1 blue card for Plympton assistant coach (or close by), for audibly questioning first blue card.
Let's not hang people out to dry too quickly.
The bottom line is this: Too many clubs are putting Junior Premierships ahead of developing good juniors, and good people. Some parents are disgraceful, and are destroying it for everyone else.
I am no angel. I am the only person who has ever received a blue card at our club. I audibly yelled out "Thats a sling tackle" in under 10s years ago. I shouldn't have, took my punishment. Side note, it was a sling tackle.
The Hound wrote:Moe wrote:woodublieve12 wrote:Was anyone actually there???
1 blue card for Unley spectator before half time.
1 blue card for Plympton coach late in 3rd quarter. Loudly questioning a holding the ball decision, which was not given, no swearing involved, but you simply cannot do it.
1 blue card for Plympton assistant coach (or close by), for audibly questioning first blue card.
Let's not hang people out to dry too quickly.
The bottom line is this: Too many clubs are putting Junior Premierships ahead of developing good juniors, and good people. Some parents are disgraceful, and are destroying it for everyone else.
I am no angel. I am the only person who has ever received a blue card at our club. I audibly yelled out "Thats a sling tackle" in under 10s years ago. I shouldn't have, took my punishment. Side note, it was a sling tackle.
Anyone would of thought Mitcham Under 14's won the Grand Final yesterday (yes they won the Elimination Final against my lads team but deserved to win). The way the parents and coaching / support staff on the bench carried on throughout the game i thought it was Mitcham seniors playing on a Sat arvo
Like another poster i like to set up away from the parents and applaud good play and players from both sides.
Moe wrote:Dutchy wrote:Absolutely, if he hasn't been booted out of the club already there is something wrong.
A second blue card to a coach should stop the game and don't recommence until he has driven off in his car.
People in glass houses.
Your under 14 coach and runner should take a very good, hard look at themselves, or your junior coordinator should.
MW wrote:Broken Down Hack wrote:Players being assisted off ground with trainer during finals games cannot come back on no matter the Injury.
Just wondering I watched the girls GF down Richmond last Sunday and a girl had to hope at least 50 meters
to the bench with no assistance from trainers, was later told
if helped off she could no come back on, she looked like she twisted an ankle, she came back on after a bit
Of rest,
I understand player safety but all year players come off with bumps and bruises assisted by trainers and go back on why
Is it different for finals
Thoughts
Which game was this one in @Broken Down Hack ?
Moe wrote:Dutchy wrote:Broken Down Hack wrote:So the results are In....
The SANFL JUNIORS dropped Flagstaff Hill and Athelstone
down from Div 3 to Div 4 in the U/14 grade.
Results
Flagstaff Hill def Morphettville Pk (4th) by ... 85 pts
Athelstone def Angle Vale (3rd) by 126 pts
Pencil in those two teams for the Grand Final
Well played SANFL JUNIORS
I really hope you are not involved with the kids with that attitude, we got smashed in Div 3 by 96, 46 & 49 points in 1st 3 rounds, so how do you expect us to not be considered to drop down a div?
If you consider 46 & 49 points smashings, then you haven't been involved in junior sport long enough. You conviniently leave out your 3 point loss, forget to mention you were still scoring ok enough as well.
Please tell me why every player is a permit player, allowing you to swap any player you want in and out of your teams from Saturday/Sunday sides at will. Obviously depends who you are playing in SFL on Saturday who comes out/in.
If, as your club says, you joined Sanfl junior's because you had 30 kids missing out on a game each week, you need to have a minimum of 7 players playing 2 games per weekend, and having under 15 players from your Saturday teams play again on Sunday. I thought you had plenty of kids spare.
You have made a mockery of the rules, and now a mockery of the division.
Lost a few games?
Boo hoo.
And I've been involved in junior sport for 25 years.
This is THE biggest joke I've ever been unfortunate enough to witness.
Dutchy wrote:So what would have you done if you ran the league?
In our u16.5 comp Broadview came down from Div 1 and have been undefeated since and will make the GF. They beat us by 90 points but no complaints here as no system is going to be perfect and 95% of people Ive spoken with agree that they have a good balance to ensure competitive games.
A Mordialloc junior football team that played an over-age player under several false names has been booted out of the finals.
The AFL South East Commission confirmed this morning that the Mordialloc Redbacks had been fined $1400, and their under-13 coach and team manager were suspended over the episode.
AFL South East chief executive John Anderson said the club admitted it deliberately played an under-14 player in the team.
He said a whistleblower had alerted Frankston and District Junior Football League officials late in the season.
Anderson said the over-age player had appeared in four games under different names.
He said the team finished fourth on the ladder, but was stripped of match points earned in the four matches and missed the finals.
“It was one of those whistleblower situations,’’ Anderson said.
“We got some information around the back door and investigated it. After we were put on to it, it went to a disciplinary hearing and the club basically owned up to it.
“From our point of view it’s very disappointing that a club would go to that length to deceive the competition.
“I was staggered because it’s a very rare occurrence. I honestly don’t know how the club would expect to get away with it, given that people will know the boy and his age. It’s one of those where you take a risk … but when you take a risk like that it’s not going to come off.’’
Anderson said he felt for the “innocent kids who through no fault of their own missed the opportunity to experience finals football’’.
The league said the team manager was suspended for two years after “accepting the majority of responsibility for being the architect of the breach’’.
The coach was suspended for one year, and the Redbacks were fined $400 for playing an ineligible player and $1000 for bringing the game into disrepute.
One parent contacted Leader last night saying his son was in “misery’’ over the situation.
“He’s gutted that his team is labelled as cheats and he is even being bullied at school,’’ the parents, who asked to not be identified, said.
The Redbacks have been contacted for comment.
jo172 wrote:https://www.heraldsun.com.au/leader/localfooty/mordialloc-redbacks-under13-team-kicked-out-of-finals-for-playing-overage-player/news-story/0a093446ae1b36ae25b126f2e0bebc6cA Mordialloc junior football team that played an over-age player under several false names has been booted out of the finals.
The AFL South East Commission confirmed this morning that the Mordialloc Redbacks had been fined $1400, and their under-13 coach and team manager were suspended over the episode.
AFL South East chief executive John Anderson said the club admitted it deliberately played an under-14 player in the team.
He said a whistleblower had alerted Frankston and District Junior Football League officials late in the season.
Anderson said the over-age player had appeared in four games under different names.
He said the team finished fourth on the ladder, but was stripped of match points earned in the four matches and missed the finals.
“It was one of those whistleblower situations,’’ Anderson said.
“We got some information around the back door and investigated it. After we were put on to it, it went to a disciplinary hearing and the club basically owned up to it.
“From our point of view it’s very disappointing that a club would go to that length to deceive the competition.
“I was staggered because it’s a very rare occurrence. I honestly don’t know how the club would expect to get away with it, given that people will know the boy and his age. It’s one of those where you take a risk … but when you take a risk like that it’s not going to come off.’’
Anderson said he felt for the “innocent kids who through no fault of their own missed the opportunity to experience finals football’’.
The league said the team manager was suspended for two years after “accepting the majority of responsibility for being the architect of the breach’’.
The coach was suspended for one year, and the Redbacks were fined $400 for playing an ineligible player and $1000 for bringing the game into disrepute.
One parent contacted Leader last night saying his son was in “misery’’ over the situation.
“He’s gutted that his team is labelled as cheats and he is even being bullied at school,’’ the parents, who asked to not be identified, said.
The Redbacks have been contacted for comment.
Dutchy wrote:So what would have you done if you ran the league?
In our u16.5 comp Broadview came down from Div 1 and have been undefeated since and will make the GF. They beat us by 90 points but no complaints here as no system is going to be perfect and 95% of people Ive spoken with agree that they have a good balance to ensure competitive games.