SAAFL Div 5 & 5R (2009)

[Dragons]

Have we already had a crack at team of year on here? I can't remember.

Anyway, feel free to post it again, coz I can't be bothered working today and want something to look at.

Coach would be the victorious coach on the weekend.

barber should be the coach of the division, he's taken a div 6 side from 2008 to div 4 in 2010. no disrepsect to silvy but pulteney have gone back to where they came from.

was he the coach in 2007 when they needed to win the last game to stay up in div 6? they have done a great job since 07 from almost getting relegated to being in div 4

No he wasn't coach back in 2007. And he may not be now if we didnt win that rnd 18 game and stay up. Funny (and good) how things work out...

Enough about Barbs though, his head will explode if it gets any bigger!

[zedman]

FF - Anderson Jones King
HF - Smith Perrie Horsell
C - Harper Taylor Duggan
HB - Parish Croucher Rumbelow
FB - Hawksworth Stobbe Cooper
1R - James Warburton Silvy
INT - Malcolm King Deer Gibbs Newman Spry
Coach - Barber

i have rushed this together and tried to give all the clubs some action but i dont know every player from every club..its a very hard job and i will have made some glaring errors i am sure!

24 chosen for team of the year..that gave me some breathing space

[heater31]

Old intercol rivals head 2 head in the GF... This Saturday is going to be a ripper!!
Why the Westminster/Pulteney intercol has since been changed has got me f*cked!?
WOS by 3 points, Wigg BOG

& let's no forget the mighty B grade..
Plympton Chihuahuas to follow their senior side & choke it up,
WOS by 27 points, Stevens BOG

go dragons!

IIRC it was Westminster to instigated the change in the first place.

Anyway have you recovered sufficiently enough from your buck show swerv?

[hawkseye]

FF - Anderson Jones King
HF - Smith Perrie Horsell
C - Harper Taylor Duggan
HB - Parish Croucher Rumbelow
FB - Hawksworth Stobbe Cooper
1R - James Warburton Silvy
INT - Malcolm King Deer Gibbs Newman Spry
Coach - Barber

i have rushed this together and tried to give all the clubs some action but i dont know every player from every club..its a very hard job and i will have made some glaring errors i am sure!

24 chosen for team of the year..that gave me some breathing space

Bassett? Qualifies for finals but not team of the year oh hidden one?

[LaughingKookaburra]

I said in my previous comments that I beleive div 5 this year is far stronger than previous years. When SANFL U19's goes under alot of those 18/19 year olds are playing in the higher divisions than last year and spots get taken, so players leave and go to lower ranked clubs. It's a flow on effect from div 1 down to div 7. Other comments label the top tems in div 4 the best in a long time and Brahma Lodge are probably the best side going around div 6 since Elizabeth in 2005, the depth in div 6 this year shows the top 7 sides to be more even than previous years.Also in 2005 div 5 was red hot with I think 8 teams in contention.
I beleive there is no favortism with playing previous finals at St.Marys. Here is a stat for you, Pultney have never lost a match at St.Marys Park....

didnt rate us when we were in div 6?

How many times did you kick 70.30??

we never got the pleasure of playing a team with 15 players!!

Ok we beat them by 50 goals when they had 21 players,does that make us better?? Nope it doesnt, I think my stats well and truly back up my point. They averaged winning every game by 18 goals. You did'nt even win the minor premiership.....Anyway that I stand by my point. We all have opinions, I have mine and stats seem to back that up. I'm basing it on an individual year, not over years aswell.

[sprinttospace]

FF - Anderson Jones King
HF - Smith Perrie Horsell
C - Harper Taylor Duggan
HB - Parish Croucher Rumbelow
FB - Hawksworth Stobbe Cooper
1R - James Warburton Silvy
INT - Malcolm King Deer Gibbs Newman Spry
Coach - Barber

i have rushed this together and tried to give all the clubs some action but i dont know every player from every club..its a very hard job and i will have made some glaring errors i am sure!

24 chosen for team of the year..that gave me some breathing space

looks pretty good zedman. spry is a great leader and game breaker for us so good to see he is in even if it is a list of 24.

[sprinttospace]

bassett's last game i believe was at st marys ... so he at least has some form down there

he certainly does not get a spot in the team of the year for lacing his boots up 4 times

[woodublieve12]

FF - Anderson Jones King
HF - Smith Perrie Horsell
C - Harper Taylor Duggan
HB - Parish Croucher Rumbelow
FB - Hawksworth Stobbe Cooper
1R - James Warburton Silvy
INT - Malcolm King Deer Gibbs Newman Spry
Coach - Barber

i have rushed this together and tried to give all the clubs some action but i dont know every player from every club..its a very hard job and i will have made some glaring errors i am sure!

24 chosen for team of the year..that gave me some breathing space

looks pretty good zedman. spry is a great leader and game breaker for us so good to see he is in even if it is a list of 24.

what about Harland from plympton.... Probably the best ruck men in the comp.... Gun...

[LaughingKookaburra]

He's not better than Adam O'Hara, think that was proven on the weekend.

[woodublieve12]

He's not better than Adam O'Hara, think that was proven on the weekend.

he won most the taps on the weekend.. it was are on ballers who couldn't win a clearance.... around the ground he is awesome...

[zedman]

demonseye: im not putting him when he played so little amount of games..4 is nothing

sprint: spry is always one who needs to be watched

woodubelieve: harland was close yes..but james was better imo..maybe a bench spot to harland perhaps

[woodublieve12]

demonseye: im not putting him when he played so little amount of games..4 is nothing

sprint: spry is always one who needs to be watched

woodubelieve: harland was close yes..but james was better imo..maybe a bench spot to harland perhaps

is the coach from WOS???

[woodublieve12]

Old intercol rivals head 2 head in the GF... This Saturday is going to be a ripper!!
Why the Westminster/Pulteney intercol has since been changed has got me f*cked!?
WOS by 3 points, Wigg BOG

& let's no forget the mighty B grade..
Plympton Chihuahuas to follow their senior side & choke it up,
WOS by 27 points, Stevens BOG

go dragons!

[Lightning McQueen]

demonseye: im not putting him when he played so little amount of games..4 is nothing

sprint: spry is always one who needs to be watched

woodubelieve: harland was close yes..but james was better imo..maybe a bench spot to harland perhaps

is the coach from WOS???

Yes, quite rightly so, that is a pretty fair analysis zedman.

[zedman]

thanks LM..most clubs could probably name 1-2 players who missed out..but its a tough job

[Footy Chick]

FF - Anderson Jones King
HF - Smith Perrie Horsell
C - Harper Taylor Duggan
HB - Parish Croucher Rumbelow
FB - Hawksworth Stobbe Cooper
1R - James Warburton Silvy
INT - Malcolm King Deer Gibbs Newman Spry
Coach - Barber

i have rushed this together and tried to give all the clubs some action but i dont know every player from every club..its a very hard job and i will have made some glaring errors i am sure!

24 chosen for team of the year..that gave me some breathing space

Duggy would probably die on a wing at the moment

Not bad otherwise

[Lightning McQueen]

thanks LM..most clubs could probably name 1-2 players who missed out..but its a tough job

Without a doubt, defenders are the hardest ones, we had two defenders that had outstanding seasons, John Crew and Dave Hanley. It was good to see Hawksworth get a guernsey.

[One Eyed]

I would have Malcolm in the starting 18 as he played the 1st half of the season at CHB and still has kicked 60+ Josh Hooper would be unlucky not to get a gig and no Dan Harris ?? I am a tad biased as you can imagine. Ohara has been awesome too

[zedman]

tried to give all clubs a look in and limit clubs to 3 reps max..hooper, ohara and i would add ferris all could be considered unlucky but i would take harland and james in front of ohara..have those 3 had better years than warby newman and malcolm?

as i said..evey club would have players they consider should be in but i had to limit it to 3 to be fair to all


FC: probably play duggy up fwd and changing on the ball in a real game

[One Eyed]

Easily Zed. I have only seen Josh beaten once and Dan Harris would be if not the best midfielder in the comp very close.