SA Footy

The Bedge wrote:

gadj1976 wrote:

The Bedge wrote:Maybe the AdFL can just go similar to the old AFL McIntyre 8 system when we return but extend to 10 sides.

1v10
2v9
3v8
4v7
5v6

That may be the dumbest thing I've seen on here. And that's saying something.

lol I was being facetious.. even if I was half serious, trying to actually make a 10 team finals series work within 4 weeks would be impossible.

Sorry Bedge, I didn't realise - there was no smiley face ;-)

So if the season does get pushed back 2 weeks, that would mean grand finals are played on the AFL grand final Saturday too. Surely the league wouldn’t want that?

Fools Gold wrote:So if the season does get pushed back 2 weeks, that would mean grand finals are played on the AFL grand final Saturday too. Surely the league wouldn’t want that?

I wouldn't even try to guess what they will do just yet, I'm sure they devised Plan's B through to E and nothing can be set in concrete with the changes that can occur in an instance from SA Health.

Lightning McQueen wrote:

Fools Gold wrote:So if the season does get pushed back 2 weeks, that would mean grand finals are played on the AFL grand final Saturday too. Surely the league wouldn’t want that?

I wouldn't even try to guess what they will do just yet, I'm sure they devised Plan's B through to E and nothing can be set in concrete with the changes that can occur in an instance from SA Health.

I can confirm there are plans all the way to Z

Lightning McQueen wrote:

Fools Gold wrote:So if the season does get pushed back 2 weeks, that would mean grand finals are played on the AFL grand final Saturday too. Surely the league wouldn’t want that?

I wouldn't even try to guess what they will do just yet, I'm sure they devised Plan's B through to E and nothing can be set in concrete with the changes that can occur in an instance from SA Health.

It wouldnt at surprise me if footy isnt allowed to be played for 2-3 weeks. At that stage why not just play out the minor rd, have the top 2 go up and play off in the GF and then the bottom 2 go down!

the smokey wrote:

Lightning McQueen wrote:

Fools Gold wrote:So if the season does get pushed back 2 weeks, that would mean grand finals are played on the AFL grand final Saturday too. Surely the league wouldn’t want that?

I wouldn't even try to guess what they will do just yet, I'm sure they devised Plan's B through to E and nothing can be set in concrete with the changes that can occur in an instance from SA Health.

It wouldnt at surprise me if footy isnt allowed to be played for 2-3 weeks. At that stage why not just play out the minor rd, have the top 2 go up and play off in the GF and then the bottom 2 go down!

I'm sure a few in div wouldn't be for that.

the smokey wrote:

Lightning McQueen wrote:

Fools Gold wrote:So if the season does get pushed back 2 weeks, that would mean grand finals are played on the AFL grand final Saturday too. Surely the league wouldn’t want that?

I wouldn't even try to guess what they will do just yet, I'm sure they devised Plan's B through to E and nothing can be set in concrete with the changes that can occur in an instance from SA Health.

It wouldnt at surprise me if footy isnt allowed to be played for 2-3 weeks. At that stage why not just play out the minor rd, have the top 2 go up and play off in the GF and then the bottom 2 go down!

Going by what Marshall has just announced I think you'll be all be back training Thursday and playing on Saturday

heater31 wrote:

the smokey wrote:

Lightning McQueen wrote:

Fools Gold wrote:So if the season does get pushed back 2 weeks, that would mean grand finals are played on the AFL grand final Saturday too. Surely the league wouldn’t want that?

I wouldn't even try to guess what they will do just yet, I'm sure they devised Plan's B through to E and nothing can be set in concrete with the changes that can occur in an instance from SA Health.

It wouldnt at surprise me if footy isnt allowed to be played for 2-3 weeks. At that stage why not just play out the minor rd, have the top 2 go up and play off in the GF and then the bottom 2 go down!

Going by what Marshall has just announced I think you'll be all be back training Thursday and playing on Saturday

That could hurt teams out our way (Golden Grove, TTG, Modbury, Houghton, Pooraka, Ingle Farm, Para Hills etc) if players are in quarantine still. I think we'll have another week off (games) for a return the week after. After that time, surely they'd have to look at a top 3 finals series?

gadj1976 wrote:
That could hurt teams out our way (Golden Grove, TTG, Modbury, Houghton, Pooraka, Ingle Farm, Para Hills etc) if players are in quarantine still. I think we'll have another week off (games) for a return the week after. After that time, surely they'd have to look at a top 3 finals series?

Shit yeah, I didn't think of that.

gadj1976 wrote: That could hurt teams out our way (Golden Grove, TTG, Modbury, Houghton, Pooraka, Ingle Farm, Para Hills etc) if players are in quarantine still. I think we'll have another week off (games) for a return the week after. After that time, surely they'd have to look at a top 3 finals series?

we've had players in and out of quarantine all year. in the spirit of amateur / community sport I don't see how playing this week would be any different.

If reduced finals series - rather than top 3, make it top 4? 1v4 2v3 gives an extra team a chance.

Lightning McQueen wrote:

gadj1976 wrote:
That could hurt teams out our way (Golden Grove, TTG, Modbury, Houghton, Pooraka, Ingle Farm, Para Hills etc) if players are in quarantine still. I think we'll have another week off (games) for a return the week after. After that time, surely they'd have to look at a top 3 finals series?

Shit yeah, I didn't think of that.

Yep, fair shout. We would be stretched with maybe a dozen or so of our players (that im aware of) having to quarantine for the 14 days as well as some of our Committee and Support Staff (head trainer for one). Would definitely stretch us from both a volunteer perspective and we'd also probably be close to forfeiting our D Grade.

No easy call for the league though as they often have to cater to the majority and not the minority.

Sass! wrote:

Lightning McQueen wrote:

gadj1976 wrote:
That could hurt teams out our way (Golden Grove, TTG, Modbury, Houghton, Pooraka, Ingle Farm, Para Hills etc) if players are in quarantine still. I think we'll have another week off (games) for a return the week after. After that time, surely they'd have to look at a top 3 finals series?

Shit yeah, I didn't think of that.

Yep, fair shout. We would be stretched with maybe a dozen or so of our players (that im aware of) having to quarantine for the 14 days as well as some of our Committee and Support Staff (head trainer for one). Would definitely stretch us from both a volunteer perspective and we'd also probably be close to forfeiting our D Grade.

No easy call for the league though as they often have to cater to the majority and not the minority.

The numbers in the Eastern clubs are very dense and that's where the centre of the iso's are atm.

am hearing therell be hubs and players will be bunking at scout halls for 2 weeks so they can play

Lightning McQueen wrote:

Sass! wrote:

Lightning McQueen wrote:

gadj1976 wrote:That could hurt teams out our way (Golden Grove, TTG, Modbury, Houghton, Pooraka, Ingle Farm, Para Hills etc) if players are in quarantine still. I think we'll have another week off (games) for a return the week after. After that time, surely they'd have to look at a top 3 finals series?

Shit yeah, I didn't think of that.

Yep, fair shout. We would be stretched with maybe a dozen or so of our players (that im aware of) having to quarantine for the 14 days as well as some of our Committee and Support Staff (head trainer for one). Would definitely stretch us from both a volunteer perspective and we'd also probably be close to forfeiting our D Grade.

No easy call for the league though as they often have to cater to the majority and not the minority.

The numbers in the Eastern clubs are very dense and that's where the centre of the iso's are atm.

I was going to ask the question after reading Gadj's post and Sass sort of answered it, do other posters on here have members of their clubs currently in quarantine? I initially assumed Modbury might have some.

davideyy71 wrote:

gadj1976 wrote: That could hurt teams out our way (Golden Grove, TTG, Modbury, Houghton, Pooraka, Ingle Farm, Para Hills etc) if players are in quarantine still. I think we'll have another week off (games) for a return the week after. After that time, surely they'd have to look at a top 3 finals series?

we've had players in and out of quarantine all year. in the spirit of amateur / community sport I don't see how playing this week would be any different.

If reduced finals series - rather than top 3, make it top 4? 1v4 2v3 gives an extra team a chance.

Umm, cos it's been a lockdown?

I don’t think that should make a difference, injures and sickness are part of every club’s issue throughout a season

Brodlach wrote:I don’t think that should make a difference, injures and sickness are part of every club’s issue throughout a season

These people aren't ill, they have "stay at home" orders because they were in the wrong spot at the wrong time, the individual's shouldn't be disadvantaged too.

I have at least 150 people that I know of that are in government enforced isolation just from going about doing their normal regime, and that is just my circle that I'm aware of.

If we are holding up the season because of a club having guys in quarantine we will never finish the season

If we are given the green light to play this week, we will play

scottroo wrote:If we are holding up the season because of a club having guys in quarantine we will never finish the season

If we are given the green light to play this week, we will play

Ripper. At this rate I could get a game with the A's!

If they were going to rule out sport being played this weekend they would have pulled the trigger today, Id say its on