Page 5 of 15

Re: 2016 gradings

PostPosted: Tue Oct 06, 2015 2:15 pm
by Footy Chick
The Ash Man wrote:
jo172 wrote:
Q. wrote:
jo172 wrote:Word on the street is Edwardstown have indicated an intent to request affiliation with the SAAFL.


Any further news regarding this?


A certain easterly club is hitting the phones in an attempt not to get relegated ...


Starts with a H?



Why do we feel the need to tiptoe around these things?

It didn't take a rocket scientist to work out, they're one of 4 eastern clubs the only only relgated club within the new grading zone. :roll:

Re: 2016 gradings

PostPosted: Tue Oct 06, 2015 2:21 pm
by zedman
Q. wrote:Okay, so Edwardstown is a 100% lock?


the clubs have to vote them in still..i wouldnt say thats over the line yet..

Re: 2016 gradings

PostPosted: Tue Oct 06, 2015 2:26 pm
by The Bedge
zedman wrote:
Q. wrote:Okay, so Edwardstown is a 100% lock?


the clubs have to vote them in still..i wouldnt say thats over the line yet..

Surely the clubs will vote yes? It's better for the league with them in.. as long as they don't go running away again in a couple years time!

Re: 2016 gradings

PostPosted: Tue Oct 06, 2015 2:45 pm
by zedman
Zartan wrote:
zedman wrote:
Q. wrote:Okay, so Edwardstown is a 100% lock?


the clubs have to vote them in still..i wouldnt say thats over the line yet..


Surely the clubs will vote yes? It's better for the league with them in.. as long as they don't go running away again in a couple years time!


Image

Re: 2016 gradings

PostPosted: Tue Oct 06, 2015 2:54 pm
by jo172
Footy Chick wrote:
The Ash Man wrote:
jo172 wrote:
Q. wrote:
Any further news regarding this?


A certain easterly club is hitting the phones in an attempt not to get relegated ...


Starts with a H?



Why do we feel the need to tiptoe around these things?

It didn't take a rocket scientist to work out, they're one of 4 eastern clubs the only only relgated club within the new grading zone. :roll:


Because we've got 6 months to kill?

Re: 2016 gradings

PostPosted: Wed Oct 07, 2015 1:23 pm
by oldman
Can someone please post the proposed divisions for 2016? Who will be playing in what grade, surely this should be confirmed by now as how can a club try to recruit players if they don't know what grade they will be playing in!!

Re: 2016 gradings

PostPosted: Wed Oct 07, 2015 1:34 pm
by Mr Beefy
oldman wrote:Can someone please post the proposed divisions for 2016? Who will be playing in what grade, surely this should be confirmed by now as how can a club try to recruit players if they don't know what grade they will be playing in!!

not Confirmed..
DIV 1 - TTG, Goodwood, Henley, PNU, ROCS, Pt District, Adel Uni, Salis Nth, Unley, PAOC
DIV 2 - SHOC, Portland, Gaza, Modbury, Scotch, SPOC, Broadview, SMOSH, PHOS, Old Ig
DIV 3 - Walkerville, Gepps, Athelstone, Grove, Pembroke, Flinders Pk, Plympton, Edwardstown, Kilburn, Salisbury
DIV 4 - Mitcham, Seaton, Nth Haven, EP, Pooraka, Westminster, Kenilworth, Hope Valley, CLG, Para Hills
DIV 5 - Hectorville, Glenunga, Blackfriars, Elizabeth, CBCOC, Rosewater, Greenacres, Pulteney, Smithfield, Lockleys
DIV 6 - Adel Lutheran, Woody Sth, West Croydon, Trinity, Fitzroy, Ingle Farm, Mawson Lakes, Brahma Lodge, Mitchell Pk,Houghton
DIV 7 - Central United, Adel Uni, St Pauls, Angle Vale, Salisbury West, Flinders Uni, PAOC, Unley, TTG, Golden Grove

Re: 2016 gradings

PostPosted: Wed Oct 07, 2015 1:58 pm
by S Demon
Mr Beefy wrote:
oldman wrote:Can someone please post the proposed divisions for 2016? Who will be playing in what grade, surely this should be confirmed by now as how can a club try to recruit players if they don't know what grade they will be playing in!!

not Confirmed..
DIV 1 - TTG, Goodwood, Henley, PNU, ROCS, Pt District, Adel Uni, Salis Nth, Unley, PAOC
DIV 2 - SHOC, Portland, Gaza, Modbury, Scotch, SPOC, Broadview, SMOSH, PHOS, Old Ig
DIV 3 - Walkerville, Gepps, Athelstone, Grove, Pembroke, Flinders Pk, Plympton, Edwardstown, Kilburn, Salisbury
DIV 4 - Mitcham, Seaton, Nth Haven, EP, Pooraka, Westminster, Kenilworth, Hope Valley, CLG, Para Hills
DIV 5 - Hectorville, Glenunga, Blackfriars, Elizabeth, CBCOC, Rosewater, Greenacres, Pulteney, Smithfield, Lockleys
DIV 6 - Adel Lutheran, Woody Sth, West Croydon, Trinity, Fitzroy, Ingle Farm, Mawson Lakes, Brahma Lodge, Mitchell Pk,Houghton
DIV 7 - Central United, Adel Uni, St Pauls, Angle Vale, Salisbury West, Flinders Uni, PAOC, Unley, TTG, Golden Grove


I thought it was:
DIV 3 - Walkerville, Gepps, Athelstone, Grove, Pembroke, Flinders Pk, Plympton, Kilburn, Mitcham Edwardstown/Salisbury
DIV 4 - Seaton, Nth Haven, EP, Pooraka, Westminster, Kenilworth, Hope Valley, CLG, Para Hills, Edwardstown/Salisbury

Re: 2016 gradings

PostPosted: Wed Oct 07, 2015 2:00 pm
by Q.
That's the strongest D1-D7 the league has had for some time.

Re: 2016 gradings

PostPosted: Thu Oct 08, 2015 8:35 am
by Mr Beefy
S Demon wrote:
Mr Beefy wrote:
oldman wrote:Can someone please post the proposed divisions for 2016? Who will be playing in what grade, surely this should be confirmed by now as how can a club try to recruit players if they don't know what grade they will be playing in!!

not Confirmed..
DIV 1 - TTG, Goodwood, Henley, PNU, ROCS, Pt District, Adel Uni, Salis Nth, Unley, PAOC
DIV 2 - SHOC, Portland, Gaza, Modbury, Scotch, SPOC, Broadview, SMOSH, PHOS, Old Ig
DIV 3 - Walkerville, Gepps, Athelstone, Grove, Pembroke, Flinders Pk, Plympton, Edwardstown, Kilburn, Salisbury
DIV 4 - Mitcham, Seaton, Nth Haven, EP, Pooraka, Westminster, Kenilworth, Hope Valley, CLG, Para Hills
DIV 5 - Hectorville, Glenunga, Blackfriars, Elizabeth, CBCOC, Rosewater, Greenacres, Pulteney, Smithfield, Lockleys
DIV 6 - Adel Lutheran, Woody Sth, West Croydon, Trinity, Fitzroy, Ingle Farm, Mawson Lakes, Brahma Lodge, Mitchell Pk,Houghton
DIV 7 - Central United, Adel Uni, St Pauls, Angle Vale, Salisbury West, Flinders Uni, PAOC, Unley, TTG, Golden Grove


I thought it was:
DIV 3 - Walkerville, Gepps, Athelstone, Grove, Pembroke, Flinders Pk, Plympton, Kilburn, Mitcham Edwardstown/Salisbury
DIV 4 - Seaton, Nth Haven, EP, Pooraka, Westminster, Kenilworth, Hope Valley, CLG, Para Hills, Edwardstown/Salisbury


I was just making it up

Re: 2016 gradings

PostPosted: Thu Oct 08, 2015 8:56 am
by beef
Mr Beefy wrote:
S Demon wrote:
Mr Beefy wrote:
oldman wrote:Can someone please post the proposed divisions for 2016? Who will be playing in what grade, surely this should be confirmed by now as how can a club try to recruit players if they don't know what grade they will be playing in!!

not Confirmed..
DIV 1 - TTG, Goodwood, Henley, PNU, ROCS, Pt District, Adel Uni, Salis Nth, Unley, PAOC
DIV 2 - SHOC, Portland, Gaza, Modbury, Scotch, SPOC, Broadview, SMOSH, PHOS, Old Ig
DIV 3 - Walkerville, Gepps, Athelstone, Grove, Pembroke, Flinders Pk, Plympton, Edwardstown, Kilburn, Salisbury
DIV 4 - Mitcham, Seaton, Nth Haven, EP, Pooraka, Westminster, Kenilworth, Hope Valley, CLG, Para Hills
DIV 5 - Hectorville, Glenunga, Blackfriars, Elizabeth, CBCOC, Rosewater, Greenacres, Pulteney, Smithfield, Lockleys
DIV 6 - Adel Lutheran, Woody Sth, West Croydon, Trinity, Fitzroy, Ingle Farm, Mawson Lakes, Brahma Lodge, Mitchell Pk,Houghton
DIV 7 - Central United, Adel Uni, St Pauls, Angle Vale, Salisbury West, Flinders Uni, PAOC, Unley, TTG, Golden Grove


I thought it was:
DIV 3 - Walkerville, Gepps, Athelstone, Grove, Pembroke, Flinders Pk, Plympton, Kilburn, Mitcham Edwardstown/Salisbury
DIV 4 - Seaton, Nth Haven, EP, Pooraka, Westminster, Kenilworth, Hope Valley, CLG, Para Hills, Edwardstown/Salisbury


I was just making it up

Eastern Park would want salisbury in div 4. Bad going to Westminster / Kenilworth / CLG & Edwardstown

Re: 2016 gradings

PostPosted: Thu Oct 08, 2015 9:14 am
by Footy Chick
Jeez, Div 4 sucks travel wise next year.

Re: 2016 gradings

PostPosted: Thu Oct 08, 2015 9:24 am
by am Bays
Footy Chick wrote:Jeez, Div 4 sucks travel wise next year.


Boo Hoo, 45 -60 mins of traveling

Try doing what country footballers do - Nhill to Ararat 160 km!!!

Re: 2016 gradings

PostPosted: Thu Oct 08, 2015 9:32 am
by jo172
am Bays wrote:
Footy Chick wrote:Jeez, Div 4 sucks travel wise next year.


Boo Hoo, 45 -60 mins of traveling

Try doing what country footballers do - Nhill to Ararat 160 km!!!


It's not country football, it's metropolitan football

Re: 2016 gradings

PostPosted: Thu Oct 08, 2015 9:50 am
by Footy Chick
am Bays wrote:
Footy Chick wrote:Jeez, Div 4 sucks travel wise next year.


Boo Hoo, 45 -60 mins of traveling

Try doing what country footballers do - Nhill to Ararat 160 km!!!


I used to do it, when I trained with United @am Bays ! Never minded the country drive though.

Considering it takes the same amount of time to get from Hope Valley to CLG or Kenilworth, as it does to get from Horsham to Ararat, that's why it's crap.

Re: 2016 gradings

PostPosted: Thu Oct 08, 2015 10:14 am
by jo172
Footy Chick wrote:
am Bays wrote:
Footy Chick wrote:Jeez, Div 4 sucks travel wise next year.


Boo Hoo, 45 -60 mins of traveling

Try doing what country footballers do - Nhill to Ararat 160 km!!!


I used to do it, when I trained with United @am Bays ! Never minded the country drive though.

Considering it takes the same amount of time to get from Hope Valley to CLG or Kenilworth, as it does to get from Horsham to Ararat, that's why it's crap.


C4 a few years ago had Trinity OS in the same grade as Mitchell Park and Flinders Uni.

That thing between those clubs is what most of us refer to as metropolitan Adelaide

Re: 2016 gradings

PostPosted: Thu Oct 08, 2015 10:27 am
by TEX07
Mr Beefy wrote:
oldman wrote:Can someone please post the proposed divisions for 2016? Who will be playing in what grade, surely this should be confirmed by now as how can a club try to recruit players if they don't know what grade they will be playing in!!

not Confirmed..
DIV 1 - TTG, Goodwood, Henley, PNU, ROCS, Pt District, Adel Uni, Salis Nth, Unley, PAOC
DIV 2 - SHOC, Portland, Gaza, Modbury, Scotch, SPOC, Broadview, SMOSH, PHOS, Old Ig
DIV 3 - Walkerville, Gepps, Athelstone, Grove, Pembroke, Flinders Pk, Plympton, Edwardstown, Kilburn, Salisbury
DIV 4 - Mitcham, Seaton, Nth Haven, EP, Pooraka, Westminster, Kenilworth, Hope Valley, CLG, Para Hills
DIV 5 - Hectorville, Glenunga, Blackfriars, Elizabeth, CBCOC, Rosewater, Greenacres, Pulteney, Smithfield, Lockleys
DIV 6 - Adel Lutheran, Woody Sth, West Croydon, Trinity, Fitzroy, Ingle Farm, Mawson Lakes, Brahma Lodge, Mitchell Pk,Houghton
DIV 7 - Central United, Adel Uni, St Pauls, Angle Vale, Salisbury West, Flinders Uni, PAOC, Unley, TTG, Golden Grove


Would div7 still be like the C and D grade comps ie 25 players you think? Originally I was happy with the bigger bench but it does make it hard to get players on the park, might open up a 5th side for a few clubs maybe?

Re: 2016 gradings

PostPosted: Thu Oct 08, 2015 10:30 am
by Q.
TEX07 wrote:Would div7 still be like the C and D grade comps ie 25 players you think? Originally I was happy with the bigger bench but it does make it hard to get players on the park, might open up a 5th side for a few clubs maybe?


I'm sure that would be up for discussion.

Perhaps 21-man D7 teams and 25-man D7R teams would be the way to go.

Re: 2016 gradings

PostPosted: Thu Oct 08, 2015 10:46 am
by TEX07
Q. wrote:
TEX07 wrote:Would div7 still be like the C and D grade comps ie 25 players you think? Originally I was happy with the bigger bench but it does make it hard to get players on the park, might open up a 5th side for a few clubs maybe?


I'm sure that would be up for discussion.

Perhaps 21-man D7 teams and 25-man D7R teams would be the way to go.


Thats a good idea - we had players play in D8 that got stuff all game time so when D8 was being selected during the season they were taking up guys from our D8R bench to not weaken the D grade for a guy who was sitting on the pine

Re: 2016 gradings

PostPosted: Thu Oct 08, 2015 10:50 am
by Q.
TEX07 wrote:
Q. wrote:
TEX07 wrote:Would div7 still be like the C and D grade comps ie 25 players you think? Originally I was happy with the bigger bench but it does make it hard to get players on the park, might open up a 5th side for a few clubs maybe?


I'm sure that would be up for discussion.

Perhaps 21-man D7 teams and 25-man D7R teams would be the way to go.


Thats a good idea - we had players play in D8 that got stuff all game time so when D8 was being selected during the season they were taking up guys from our D8R bench to not weaken the D grade for a guy who was sitting on the pine


Would you be happy for 25-man teams to apply to all teams in D7R, whether they be a B-Grade or D-Grade?