SA Footy

No such thing as a 1 to 35 SANFL list these days. The rule for SANFL BYE / STATE GAME BYE was clearly outlined by the Boss yesterday. If North are OK for Brazel to play then he can play for PAOC provided he has played 25 games senior/junior games for them previously. PlayHQ says he has played 19 games for PAOC but I assume he went to school at PAC so qualifies based on junior games added to that tally. No way Parky would make an error with the application of this rule so I'm sure he is eligible to play for the Reds this week.

Down the Hill wrote:No such thing as a 1 to 35 SANFL list these days. The rule for SANFL BYE / STATE GAME BYE was clearly outlined by the Boss yesterday. If North are OK for Brazel to play then he can play for PAOC provided he has played 25 games senior/junior games for them previously. PlayHQ says he has played 19 games for PAOC but I assume he went to school at PAC so qualifies based on junior games added to that tally. No way Parky would make an error with the application of this rule so I'm sure he is eligible to play for the Reds this week.

Thank goodness, always found that one to be particularly stupid.

beef wrote:Is brazel playing all year or just able to play with North Adel/SANFL bye?

The oracle TJ tells me he's finished at North so all year

Jimmy_041 wrote:

beef wrote:Is brazel playing all year or just able to play with North Adel/SANFL bye?

The oracle TJ tells me he's finished at North so all year

Was close to leaving at end of the year. Recruiting another forward in the off season didn't help.
Good player and very nice guy, wish him all the best.

When is the last time Goodwood have lost 4 games in a row?

beef wrote:

Jimmy_041 wrote:

beef wrote:Is brazel playing all year or just able to play with North Adel/SANFL bye?

The oracle TJ tells me he's finished at North so all year

Was close to leaving at end of the year. Recruiting another forward in the off season didn't help.
Good player and very nice guy, wish him all the best.

Kicked 4.4 yesterday

Antonio James playing for SPOC on the weekend - thought you had to have been a junior or played 25 games to get a permit to local league?

The Bedge wrote:Antonio James playing for SPOC on the weekend - thought you had to have been a junior or played 25 games to get a permit to local league?

This could be one of the great balls ups in Div 1 for some time.

They win their first game and now what? Can they lose points if he is deemed ineligible to play?

The Bedge wrote:Antonio James playing for SPOC on the weekend - thought you had to have been a junior or played 25 games to get a permit to local league?

Its an interesting one

Doesn't work that way in the womens divisions but it might in the mens.

Shortman wrote:

The Bedge wrote:Antonio James playing for SPOC on the weekend - thought you had to have been a junior or played 25 games to get a permit to local league?

Its an interesting one

Doesn't work that way in the womens divisions but it might in the mens.

Yes it does.

Is it possible hes left West and is now just playing for SPOC? Would that make a difference?

jo172 wrote:

Shortman wrote:

The Bedge wrote:Antonio James playing for SPOC on the weekend - thought you had to have been a junior or played 25 games to get a permit to local league?

Its an interesting one

Doesn't work that way in the womens divisions but it might in the mens.

Yes it does.

Well this is interesting........

Probably too late now but it happened a few times last year and already this year

JesseWhite wrote:Is it possible hes left West and is now just playing for SPOC? Would that make a difference?

One would assume so yes

JesseWhite wrote:Is it possible hes left West and is now just playing for SPOC? Would that make a difference?

If that was the case, wouldn't he have transferred and thus not appeared as a special permit player?

The Bedge wrote:

JesseWhite wrote:Is it possible hes left West and is now just playing for SPOC? Would that make a difference?

If that was the case, wouldn't he have transferred and thus not appeared as a special permit player?

Not necessarily
Brazza and Wildman are showing as SP for us
He could be in the same boat as Brazza

Would be a nice win for Iggies to get

Seems fair risk to recruit a player on the same weekend the sanfl has a bye though

The Bedge wrote:Seems fair risk to recruit a player on the same weekend the sanfl has a bye though

In fairness though that is a perfect time for an SANFL player to reassess where they are at as far as league selection goes etc.

Surely the league will look however at where they play next week and if thats back at SANFL footy then there is obviously an issue.

I see toby Bedford played for SPOC on the weekend, I thought he was playing in the RMFL when not picked for Sturt Reserves

Bedford played for Mannum on 6/5 but played at SPOC on 13/5 & 20/5. It appears he has decided Mannum OUT and SPOC IN as his aligned Community Club which he is quite entitled to do at least prior to 30 June.