SA Footy

If a A Grade playing coach is playing in the B Grade game and gets a yellow card send off, then receives a Red card for abusing the umpire while on the bench following the initial send off is he allowed on the ground to coach the A Grade game?

i would have thought so as he isnt suspended.

Thats interesting. To take the question further if an Agrader is a late withdrawl can a red carded Bgrader go up and take his place? If so then no reason why the coach cant coach the Agrade.
To me if you are redcarded its only for that game, so should be ok. thast without knowing the rule.

carey18 wrote:If a A Grade playing coach is playing in the B Grade game and gets a yellow card send off, then receives a Red card for abusing the umpire while on the bench following the initial send off is he allowed on the ground to coach the A Grade game?

Unless the league has this covered with a particular by-law,it is a new game, so he is okay to coach until such time as he offends in the new game.

Another question...If a goal umpire signals a decision and the central umpire calls all clear does the same central umpire then have the right to question goal umpires decision and overturn it ??? eg goal ump signals goal, central ump calls all clear..then runs to goal ump and questions descision..then cancels the goal and calls for a ball up in the square..what the????

turk186 wrote:Another question...If a goal umpire signals a decision and the central umpire calls all clear does the same central umpire then have the right to question goal umpires decision and overturn it ??? eg goal ump signals goal, central ump calls all clear..then runs to goal ump and questions descision..then cancels the goal and calls for a ball up in the square..what the????

Surely not.

Not club supplied central umps either

turk186 wrote:Not club supplied central umps either

They all F*#^ked it up! Once the "All clear" is given, end of story.

carey18 wrote:If a A Grade playing coach is playing in the B Grade game and gets a yellow card send off, then receives a Red card for abusing the umpire while on the bench following the initial send off is he allowed on the ground to coach the A Grade game?

i also think if you get a red and yellow in one game its an auto 2 games susp no tribunal and cannot go back on field even if red card was when he wasnt on the ground.

If a player is Red Carded in a B Grade game, he can still play in the A Grade or C grade that day. If he is Under 18, he can still play in the Under 18 comp on the Sunday. Not all red card offences carry automatic suspensions, and it is up to the umpire who issues the red card to decide if a player can accept an early quilty plea and not go to the tribunal.

He can still play because he hasnt been found guilty of any offence that would require a suspension.

what i was saying if they rec a yellow then a red in same game its 2 matches auto no tribunal

gothebombers wrote:what i was saying if they rec a yellow then a red in same game its 2 matches auto no tribunal

Bomber, using your formula which I know some leagues have, if that happened in a B grade game and due to shortage of players ,this guy was named to sit on the interchange bench in the A grade that same day, what would happen?
Can he play that day and start his suspension the following week? I would think so.

i think the susp whould start the following week, may be wrong