SA Footy

Since there are only 3 games left, any ideas on the lineups/positions for the team of the year in Div 1?

Obviously i have seen Broadies play most but here are some i think that would go under serious consideration.

ROCS: Lister (FF), Chadwick (FP/Onball),
Gepps: Smith (FP/Onball), Fisher (FF/FP), Allocca (HFF), Klonan (Onball), Campbell (Wing)
Gaza: Obst (HBF),
TTG: Chambers (FF/FP)
PT Dis: Peucker (HFF), Christophers (CHF)
Sea: Coard (HBF/Onball)
Broad: Hornardt (Wing), Stevens (CHB), Grocke (FB/BP)
Good: Bartel (Oball), Demasi (HFF),
Sals Nth: Jordan (Onball/HFF)
Hen: Duncan (Onball)

Three from Broadview?!
That fact that you've seen firsthand how poor they've been would set you straight, Surely?

On1Leg wrote:Three from Broadview?!
That fact that you've seen firsthand how poor they've been would set you straight, Surely?

Well, hornhardt has kicked close to 30 goals off a wing and made the state team, Grocke has been in the best most weeks, rarely beaten at full back and made the state team, and Stevo has been the form CHB for some years now and has really dominated at that position this year also rarely beaten and kicked around 15 goals also. Obviously i have seen them first hand but i would say other teams would acknowledge these 3 players this year as the clubs best.

Well, hornhardt has kicked close to 30 goals off a wing and made the state team, Grocke has been in the best most weeks, rarely beaten at full back and made the state team, and Stevo has been the form CHB for some years now and has really dominated at that position this year also rarely beaten and kicked around 15 goals also. Obviously i have seen them first hand but i would say other teams would acknowledge these 3 players this year as the clubs best.

THIS HORNHARDT how old, first name and were he from

piccachu wrote:

Well, hornhardt has kicked close to 30 goals off a wing and made the state team, Grocke has been in the best most weeks, rarely beaten at full back and made the state team, and Stevo has been the form CHB for some years now and has really dominated at that position this year also rarely beaten and kicked around 15 goals also. Obviously i have seen them first hand but i would say other teams would acknowledge these 3 players this year as the clubs best.

THIS HORNHARDT how old, first name and were he from

22, Rian, Broadview for 6 years, Roxby Downs before that.

I've no doubt they've been the best players for their team this season, but they don't have much competition for other best players at their club.
I'd say 6 players represented from Gaza, Salisbury Nth, TTG, Henley and Goodwood - 5 of the top 6 teams - is not right. They are the teams who are obviously playing consistent footy and more players should be selected from these teams than those fighting to save relegation.
Choosing squads like this is always contentious however.

I totally agree On1Leg, does anyone know who and how they select the Team of the Year???

On1Leg wrote:I've no doubt they've been the best players for their team this season, but they don't have much competition for other best players at their club.
I'd say 6 players represented from Gaza, Salisbury Nth, TTG, Henley and Goodwood - 5 of the top 6 teams - is not right. They are the teams who are obviously playing consistent footy and more players should be selected from these teams than those fighting to save relegation.
Choosing squads like this is always contentious however.

playon wrote:I totally agree On1Leg, does anyone know who and how they select the Team of the Year???\

Usually the Team of the Year is selected by the 5RPH Amateur Show people, god forbid they do it this year. They would have no idea who plays for who and how well they have played. Would usually be a proud reward to receive, not sure about this year though, could just be lucky that your name came out of the hat.

On1Leg wrote:I've no doubt they've been the best players for their team this season, but they don't have much competition for other best players at their club.
I'd say 6 players represented from Gaza, Salisbury Nth, TTG, Henley and Goodwood - 5 of the top 6 teams - is not right. They are the teams who are obviously playing consistent footy and more players should be selected from these teams than those fighting to save relegation.
Choosing squads like this is always contentious however.

Usually the Team of the Year is selected by the 5RPH Amateur Show people, god forbid they do it this year. They would have no idea who plays for who and how well they have played. Would usually be a proud reward to receive, not sure about this year though, could just be lucky that your name came out of the hat.

Amateur Footy Budget doing Teams of Year in all grades

tigerwoods wrote:Amateur Footy Budget doing Teams of Year in all grades

Yeah, you'd have to think that has the most idea of each grade this year. I hear for the SAAFL Team of the Year, each club is to nominate its top 3 palyers of the year. I guess they will raffle it off between each position.