Page 1 of 2

Possible Non Paying Divisions for 2013

PostPosted: Wed Jul 18, 2012 10:18 pm
by FOURTH ESTATE
POSSIBLE A1 2013

Adelaide University (C and D)

CBCOC

Old Ignatians

Pembroke OS

PAOC

Pulteney

Scotch OC

SPOC

Westminster OS

Henley (C and D)



POSSIBLE A2 2013

Blackfriars OS

Flinders University

Mawson Lakes

Trinity OS

Modbury (C and D)

Flinders Park (C and D)

SMOSH West Lakes (C and D)

Tea Tree Gully (C and D)

Adelaide Lutheran (?)

Mitchell Park (?)


I received this in an blind email today any one know anything about it.

Re: Possible Non Paying Divisions for 2013

PostPosted: Wed Jul 18, 2012 10:24 pm
by Yank Man
FOURTH ESTATE wrote:POSSIBLE A1 2013

Adelaide University (C and D)

CBCOC

Old Ignatians

Pembroke OS

PAOC

Pulteney

Scotch OC

SPOC

Westminster OS

Henley (C and D)



POSSIBLE A2 2013

Blackfriars OS

Flinders University

Mawson Lakes

Trinity OS

Modbury (C and D)

Flinders Park (C and D)

SMOSH West Lakes (C and D)

Tea Tree Gully (C and D)

Adelaide Lutheran (?)

Mitchell Park (?)


I received this in an blind email today any one know anything about it.




Spam mail maybe?

Re: Possible Non Paying Divisions for 2013

PostPosted: Thu Jul 19, 2012 12:30 am
by Yardy Lard
FOURTH ESTATE wrote:POSSIBLE A1 2013

Adelaide University (C and D)

CBCOC

Old Ignatians

Pembroke OS

PAOC

Pulteney

Scotch OC

SPOC

Westminster OS

Henley (C and D)



POSSIBLE A2 2013

Blackfriars OS

Flinders University

Mawson Lakes

Trinity OS

Modbury (C and D)

Flinders Park (C and D)

SMOSH West Lakes (C and D)

Tea Tree Gully (C and D)

Adelaide Lutheran (?)

Mitchell Park (?)


I received this in an blind email today any one know anything about it.


Obviously some reference to some lower grade competitions you would think unless you have been hitting the bottle a bit too hard, which it looks like :drinkers: :drinkers:
All the teams in the A1 list all have a background leaning towards college/university/old scholars clubs, (H.H.O.S) while there are five in the A2 group with a background towards the college/university sides. Not sure it all means much, but who knows.

Re: Possible Non Paying Divisions for 2013

PostPosted: Thu Jul 19, 2012 1:03 am
by Blacks130
It could be a full amateur grade but that gets blown out the water with Spoc, paoc and Iggies being in there. They have well and truly forgotten their roots.

Re: Possible Non Paying Divisions for 2013

PostPosted: Thu Jul 19, 2012 8:39 am
by beef
Adelaide Lutheran V Flinders Uni would be a close game :roll:

Re: Possible Non Paying Divisions for 2013

PostPosted: Thu Jul 19, 2012 8:41 am
by Mr Beefy
I think it highly unlikely that Lutherans would get into any "Non Paying" division

Re: Possible Non Paying Divisions for 2013

PostPosted: Thu Jul 19, 2012 9:14 am
by Q.
ROFLMAO at a couple of those teams being 'non-paying' :lol:

Re: Possible Non Paying Divisions for 2013

PostPosted: Thu Jul 19, 2012 11:02 am
by Cash 123
what

Re: Possible Non Paying Divisions for 2013

PostPosted: Thu Jul 19, 2012 12:33 pm
by Jimmy_041
Blacks130 wrote:It could be a full amateur grade but that gets blown out the water with Spoc, paoc and Iggies being in there. They have well and truly forgotten their roots.


I've never forgotten

Re: Possible Non Paying Divisions for 2013

PostPosted: Thu Jul 19, 2012 12:40 pm
by Lightning McQueen
Jimmy_041 wrote:
Blacks130 wrote:It could be a full amateur grade but that gets blown out the water with Spoc, paoc and Iggies being in there. They have well and truly forgotten their roots.


I've never forgotten


You would've had a few aswell hey Stud Muffin ;)

Re: Possible Non Paying Divisions for 2013

PostPosted: Thu Jul 19, 2012 1:52 pm
by tigerpie
Being an amateur competition shouldnt player payments be zero. :?

Its always amused me that so called amateur clubs pay big money.

Re: Possible Non Paying Divisions for 2013

PostPosted: Thu Jul 19, 2012 2:13 pm
by heater31
Would be safe to say that all but 3 of those teams in that division 1 would not be paying players to play.

2 of them are the C grade sides.

Re: Possible Non Paying Divisions for 2013

PostPosted: Thu Jul 19, 2012 2:31 pm
by Yardy Lard
tigerpie wrote:Being an amateur competition shouldnt player payments be zero. :?

Its always amused me that so called amateur clubs pay big money.



There are not any rules to say you can't pay players. The payment of players has been going on since the late 70's that I know of. (Fact)
The days of players having to be "white washed" to play are long gone, and players can be legally paid to play and have been for many, many years.
Remember that the SAAFL just replaced a salary cap with a points system (both running together actually) so silly to suggest players are not paid as nobody hides it, nor should they.

Re: Possible Non Paying Divisions for 2013

PostPosted: Thu Jul 19, 2012 4:30 pm
by tigerpie
Then it should be called S.A. Football Association.

Re: Possible Non Paying Divisions for 2013

PostPosted: Thu Jul 19, 2012 4:41 pm
by Yardy Lard
tigerpie wrote:Then it should be called S.A. Football Association.



Clearly not well versed on the history of the game. The SAFA or the SA Football Association went out of business in the early 80's and all the clubs that defected, nearly all coming running back, except one or two in the Southern League. For some of the clubs, it was the end of them as well, as they started that far back in the SAAFL, that they also went out of business, over the years. Do you want to re-name the SAAFL with the name of something, that went broke?

It is the SAAFL and always will be. The fact that players get paid and have done for over 30 years seems your only grievance. Build the bridge sunshine and get over it, as it won't be stopping the payment of players, no matter what you have as the name of the association.

Re: Possible Non Paying Divisions for 2013

PostPosted: Thu Jul 19, 2012 5:02 pm
by The Ash Man
Yardy Lard wrote:
tigerpie wrote:Then it should be called S.A. Football Association.



Clearly not well versed on the history of the game. The SAFA or the SA Football Association went out of business in the early 80's and all the clubs that defected, nearly all coming running back, except one or two in the Southern League. For some of the clubs, it was the end of them as well, as they started that far back in the SAAFL, that they also went out of business, over the years. Do you want to re-name the SAAFL with the name of something, that went broke?

It is the SAAFL and always will be. The fact that players get paid and have done for over 30 years seems your only grievance. Build the bridge sunshine and get over it, as it won't be stopping the payment of players, no matter what you have as the name of the association.


I think you will find it was a lot later than that.

Try 1995

Re: Possible Non Paying Divisions for 2013

PostPosted: Thu Jul 19, 2012 5:09 pm
by Jimmy_041
Actually tigerpie, you are on the money
The name is under discussion
But there's as much chance of it being called SAFA as Ireland asking to join Great Britain

Re: Possible Non Paying Divisions for 2013

PostPosted: Thu Jul 19, 2012 5:11 pm
by morell
I actually quite like this concept.

No idea how it could be possibly implemented or managed though.

Re: Possible Non Paying Divisions for 2013

PostPosted: Thu Jul 19, 2012 5:23 pm
by Yardy Lard
The Ash Man wrote:
Yardy Lard wrote:
tigerpie wrote:Then it should be called S.A. Football Association.



Clearly not well versed on the history of the game. The SAFA or the SA Football Association went out of business in the early 80's and all the clubs that defected, nearly all coming running back, except one or two in the Southern League. For some of the clubs, it was the end of them as well, as they started that far back in the SAAFL, that they also went out of business, over the years. Do you want to re-name the SAAFL with the name of something, that went broke?

It is the SAAFL and always will be. The fact that players get paid and have done for over 30 years seems your only grievance. Build the bridge sunshine and get over it, as it won't be stopping the payment of players, no matter what you have as the name of the association.


I think you will find it was a lot later than that.

Try 1995



Yes. You are right. Was meant to be early 90's (typo). Did not think it was as late at 1995 though, but you are obviously right as it was sometime in the 1990's. Anyway. Will never be the SAFA.

Re: Possible Non Paying Divisions for 2013

PostPosted: Thu Jul 19, 2012 6:13 pm
by tigerpie
Yardy i played for a SAFA club in the late 80's early 90's.That club then went to the ammos, and now SFL.
I dont really care what the comp is called. I'm just making the point that its called an amateur comp when it clearly isnt.
Had a mate back in the mid 80's who got big money at Kilburn when apparently player payments werent allowed.

Maybe call it the claytons amateur league. ;)