Page 1 of 2
		
			
				Re: Ch9 AFL Division 4 - 2015
				
Posted: 
Sat Nov 15, 2014 12:56 pm 
				by superboot7
				Crak would it be fair to say that many country clubs are filled with lads who are not local? 
I'm actually genuinely interested.
Reading the forum it does seem the hfl does pay a lot of money to get players up there. Obviously there would be guns who grew up in the country and live in the city so I don't mean those blokes.
What would the ratio of paid city imports versus locals in the top comp?
			 
			
		
			
				Re: Ch9 AFL Division 4 - 2015
				
Posted: 
Sun Nov 16, 2014 7:19 am 
				by daysofourlives
				superboot7 wrote:Crak would it be fair to say that many country clubs are filled with lads who are not local? 
I'm actually genuinely interested.
Reading the forum it does seem the hfl does pay a lot of money to get players up there. Obviously there would be guns who grew up in the country and live in the city so I don't mean those blokes.
What would the ratio of paid city imports versus locals in the top comp?
What percentage of an amateur league club would be guys that have grown up with that club from juniors through to seniors?
 
			 
			
		
			
				Re: Ch9 AFL Division 4 - 2015
				
Posted: 
Sun Nov 16, 2014 9:44 am 
				by superboot7
				I'd probably say a similar percentage to country maybe a little in favour. But I wouldn't say they've gone to new clubs in the SAAFL for the financial luring of HFL club. Eg haven lads may be a junior at haven then go to the magpies SANFL thn play at districts and then back to haven. Easier to leave the club but not necessarily the region. Actually I'd say 90% of Haven lads are local to the area.
			 
			
		
			
				Re: Ch9 AFL Division 4 - 2015
				
Posted: 
Sun Nov 16, 2014 1:59 pm 
				by Footy Chick
				I know HV would be 85-95% juniors. S Demon can probably confirm that,
Even the coach is a HV Junior
			 
			
		
			
				Re: Ch9 AFL Division 4 - 2015
				
Posted: 
Sun Nov 16, 2014 8:31 pm 
				by Demon Juke
				Footy Chick wrote:I know HV would be 85-95% juniors. S Demon can probably confirm that,
Even the coach is a HV Junior
From the side that lost to Pooraka in the final, 14 of the 22 are HV juniors.
 
			 
			
		
			
				Re: Ch9 AFL Division 4 - 2015
				
Posted: 
Sun Nov 16, 2014 8:53 pm 
				by Footy Chick
				is that all?  are you talking U18's or actual juniors.
I still refer to U18's as juniors and I would've thought that more of them played 18s...
*edit* just checked myself...we'll I'll be buggered, I counted 14 too.  

 
			 
			
		
			
				Re: Ch9 AFL Division 4 - 2015
				
Posted: 
Mon Nov 17, 2014 1:47 pm 
				by Boosh
				Footy Chick wrote:is that all?  are you talking U18's or actual juniors.
I still refer to U18's as juniors and I would've thought that more of them played 18s...
*edit* just checked myself...we'll I'll be buggered, I counted 14 too.  

 
12 of the 22 that played in North Havens GF side were former junior players, we would like that figure to be closer to 75% but our juniors are a work in progress. 
21 of the 22 live in the local area which we are happy with.
 
			 
			
		
			
				Re: Ch9 AFL Division 4 - 2015
				
Posted: 
Mon Nov 17, 2014 2:22 pm 
				by WOS Dragons
				Boosh wrote:Footy Chick wrote:is that all?  are you talking U18's or actual juniors.
I still refer to U18's as juniors and I would've thought that more of them played 18s...
*edit* just checked myself...we'll I'll be buggered, I counted 14 too.  

 
12 of the 22 that played in North Havens GF side were former junior players, we would like that figure to be closer to 75% but our juniors are a work in progress. 
21 of the 22 live in the local area which we are happy with.
 
13 of our GF 22 were old scholars and I think we only played with about 5 points too
 
			 
			
		
			
				Re: Ch9 AFL Division 4 - 2015
				
Posted: 
Mon Nov 17, 2014 4:07 pm 
				by Boosh
				WOS Dragons wrote:Boosh wrote:Footy Chick wrote:is that all?  are you talking U18's or actual juniors.
I still refer to U18's as juniors and I would've thought that more of them played 18s...
*edit* just checked myself...we'll I'll be buggered, I counted 14 too.  

 
12 of the 22 that played in North Havens GF side were former junior players, we would like that figure to be closer to 75% but our juniors are a work in progress. 
21 of the 22 live in the local area which we are happy with.
 
13 of our GF 22 were old scholars and I think we only played with about 5 points too
 
We played with 6, and we both played in the GF. Maybe that says something for stability and familiarity.
 
			 
			
		
			
				Re: Ch9 AFL Division 4 - 2015
				
Posted: 
Mon Nov 17, 2014 9:40 pm 
				by Jetters
				WOS Dragons wrote:Boosh wrote:Footy Chick wrote:is that all?  are you talking U18's or actual juniors.
I still refer to U18's as juniors and I would've thought that more of them played 18s...
*edit* just checked myself...we'll I'll be buggered, I counted 14 too.  

 
12 of the 22 that played in North Havens GF side were former junior players, we would like that figure to be closer to 75% but our juniors are a work in progress. 
21 of the 22 live in the local area which we are happy with.
 
13 of our GF 22 were old scholars and I think we only played with about 5 points too
 
We were 18/22 last year from juniors or Mercedes, a lot were both.
 
			 
			
		
			
				Re: Ch9 AFL Division 4 - 2015
				
Posted: 
Tue Nov 18, 2014 7:47 am 
				by jo172
				In 2013 we were 19/22, that number declined to 15/22 this year though.
			 
			
		
			
				ratio of juniors/non juniors
				
Posted: 
Tue Nov 18, 2014 8:29 am 
				by Footy Chick
				I've taken the posts from the D4 thread.
Take your last game for 2014.
How many juniors out of 22 players played in your A grade squad?
			 
			
		
			
				Re: ratio of juniors/non juniors
				
Posted: 
Tue Nov 18, 2014 9:39 am 
				by Pag
				Of the 21 that lost to Athelstone in Round 18, we had one current Under 16, two current Under 18s, 15 former SFC juniors, two from other junior clubs and one who took up footy with us as an adult.
			 
			
		
			
				Re: ratio of juniors/non juniors
				
Posted: 
Tue Nov 18, 2014 9:43 am 
				by Fricky
				We would have only half a dozen guys at best who played juniors at Walkerville. Most of our juniors go on to play for SPOC (mainly), PAOC and Blackfriars as that's where they went to school.
			 
			
		
			
				Re: Ch9 AFL Division 4 - 2015
				
Posted: 
Tue Nov 18, 2014 3:02 pm 
				by Sheik Yerbouti
				Footy Chick wrote:is that all?  are you talking U18's or actual juniors.
I still refer to U18's as juniors and I would've thought that more of them played 18s...
*edit* just checked myself...we'll I'll be buggered, I counted 14 too.  

 
18's are classed as seniors dear
 
			 
			
		
			
				Re: ratio of juniors/non juniors
				
Posted: 
Tue Nov 18, 2014 3:23 pm 
				by Footy Chick
				I know that but I'm old school.
I never stopped calling footy park, footy park  

 
			 
			
		
			
				Re: ratio of juniors/non juniors
				
Posted: 
Tue Nov 18, 2014 3:24 pm 
				by Footy Smart
				The Modbury premiership side would have had all MFC juniors apart from 4, then had 3 blokes who didnt play junior football at all.
			 
			
		
			
				Re: ratio of juniors/non juniors
				
Posted: 
Tue Nov 18, 2014 3:26 pm 
				by jo172
				Would be very curious as to Goodwood's
			 
			
		
			
				Re: ratio of juniors/non juniors
				
Posted: 
Tue Nov 18, 2014 6:03 pm 
				by daysofourlives
				Ok so it seems the lower division clubs have high numbers of juniors progressing to senior ranks.
The only reply from a high division team (Walkerville) suggests that the higher you go the less local players there are.
Would be good to get some more numbers from the higher division clubs
			 
			
		
			
				Re: ratio of juniors/non juniors
				
Posted: 
Tue Nov 18, 2014 6:46 pm 
				by Footy Chick
				Walkerville is a bit of an exception DOOL.
They have plenty of juniors but because of their location, lose all their kids after u15's because they play college footy. Makes it hard to get them back thereafter.