SA Footy

beef wrote:What do people think is a fair penalty if these sanctions are too soft??

Oval Ball wrote:When you break down the penalties the CFB are all puff and wind.
$7000. fine, the donnybrooks have a couple of shows coming up so the fine is covered.
Lost of six points this year and if things go there way they will still play finals.
Lost of Apps points next 2 years, so when you take the six points off this year and the way the BLGFA points are worked out they will probably end up with more points next year than they had this year.
The coach gets 12 months suspension and from what I've heard he wasn't coaching next year anyway.
The other official gets 24 months and he isn't involved anymore and I've been told he is not to fussed about the suspension as he is up on the sunshine coast working on his tan, drinking corona's all day.

Lightning McQueen wrote:

beef wrote:What do people think is a fair penalty if these sanctions are too soft??

I'd chuck in the loss of 4 home games for 2019, the days they were meant to host the bottom 4 sides they play them away.

beef wrote:What do people think is a fair penalty if these sanctions are too soft??

Lightning McQueen wrote:

beef wrote:What do people think is a fair penalty if these sanctions are too soft??

Was there actually any prescribed penalties drawn up when they introduced the new rules?

OnSong wrote:Yeah, pretty sure

Lightning McQueen wrote:

OnSong wrote:Yeah, pretty sure

Found something, page 31 has something about salary cap breach but I didn't find anything on sign on fees, I didn't look too hard though.

http://websites.sportstg.com/get_file.cgi?id=2416654

daysofourlives wrote:

Lightning McQueen wrote:

beef wrote:What do people think is a fair penalty if these sanctions are too soft??

I'd chuck in the loss of 4 home games for 2019, the days they were meant to host the bottom 4 sides they play them away.

Id make the player who accepted the sign on pay the same amount plus 50% in fines to the CFB. Not all the responsibilty should rest with the clubs, some has to fall on the players accepting it.

On another id love to be there next time Greenwood and Glenn run into each other, i wouldnt want to be Glenn

Lightning McQueen wrote:

daysofourlives wrote:

Lightning McQueen wrote:

beef wrote:What do people think is a fair penalty if these sanctions are too soft??

I'd chuck in the loss of 4 home games for 2019, the days they were meant to host the bottom 4 sides they play them away.

Id make the player who accepted the sign on pay the same amount plus 50% in fines to the CFB. Not all the responsibilty should rest with the clubs, some has to fall on the players accepting it.

On another id love to be there next time Greenwood and Glenn run into each other, i wouldnt want to be Glenn

Absolutely, Josh is a pretty solid young lad but Mal is a ball of muscle with no fear or concern for his own safety.

daysofourlives wrote:

Oval Ball wrote:When you break down the penalties the CFB are all puff and wind.
$7000. fine, the donnybrooks have a couple of shows coming up so the fine is covered.
Lost of six points this year and if things go there way they will still play finals.
Lost of Apps points next 2 years, so when you take the six points off this year and the way the BLGFA points are worked out they will probably end up with more points next year than they had this year.
The coach gets 12 months suspension and from what I've heard he wasn't coaching next year anyway.
The other official gets 24 months and he isn't involved anymore and I've been told he is not to fussed about the suspension as he is up on the sunshine coast working on his tan, drinking corona's all day.

Whos coaching for the remainder of the season?

Oval Ball wrote:Any news are Willaston challenging the penalties handed down.