SA Footy

Dutchy wrote:Brighton starting to show why a top level Div 2 club shouldn't be in Div 3?

teams win by 10 plus goals in all grades, doesn't mean they should be higher. it all sorts itself out over the season

mighty hounds wrote:

Dutchy wrote:Brighton starting to show why a top level Div 2 club shouldn't be in Div 3?

teams win by 10 plus goals in all grades, doesn't mean they should be higher. it all sorts itself out over the season

Rumours are your planning to come out of retirement for finals?

mighty hounds wrote:

Dutchy wrote:Brighton starting to show why a top level Div 2 club shouldn't be in Div 3?

teams win by 10 plus goals in all grades, doesn't mean they should be higher. it all sorts itself out over the season

@mighty hounds How pristine is Flinders Park's oval atm? It's hard to imagine that it gets totally churned up.

Lightning McQueen wrote:

mighty hounds wrote:

Dutchy wrote:Brighton starting to show why a top level Div 2 club shouldn't be in Div 3?

teams win by 10 plus goals in all grades, doesn't mean they should be higher. it all sorts itself out over the season

@mighty hounds How pristine is Flinders Park's oval atm? It's hard to imagine that it gets totally churned up.

It's a ripper before winter hits. Between Seniors, Juniors and Superrules the oval gets no break once the rain sets in and she gets bad quite quickly. Hopefully not as bad as last year

mighty hounds wrote:
It's a ripper before winter hits. Between Seniors, Juniors and Superrules the oval gets no break once the rain sets in and she gets bad quite quickly. Hopefully not as bad as last year

I might start training with the super rules team.

And Brighton left the SFL for competitive games

Dutchy wrote:And Brighton left the SFL for competitive games

Playing the bottom side after 4 rounds......have the 9th placed side next week

Just to think there was a few on here that said Brighton would find div 3 a bit harder than expected. Even miss the finals! Every man and his dog South of ANZAC Hwy knew they would chew up and spit out the large majority of teams in this div. There are some who underestimate how good top end Southern League teams are because of 3-4 teams who go down by 20-50 goals each week.

LaughingKookaburra wrote:Just to think there was a few on here that said Brighton would find div 3 a bit harder than expected. Even miss the finals! Every man and his dog South of ANZAC Hwy knew they would chew up and spit out the large majority of teams in this div. There are some who underestimate how good top end Southern League teams are because of 3-4 teams who go down by 20-50 goals each week.

Well I tipped them to play Flinders in the GF so maybe just listen to the experts

Dutchy wrote:And Brighton left the SFL for competitive games

They will get them.

In 2019.

valleys07 wrote:

Dutchy wrote:And Brighton left the SFL for competitive games

They will get them.

In 2019.

Get a grip people.

They haven't played any of the likely other top 4 teams.

The only team they have smashed is a team that has not won in two years.

From what I can gather they are a mid to upper Div 2 standard club but still plenty to play out in this one. They deserve credit for all the off field work, recruiting and improvements made in the off season. Transferring nicely to on field performance.

wristwatcher wrote:

valleys07 wrote:

Dutchy wrote:And Brighton left the SFL for competitive games

They will get them.

In 2019.

Get a grip people.

They haven't played any of the likely other top 4 teams.

The only team they have smashed is a team that has not won in two years.

From what I can gather they are a mid to upper Div 2 standard club but still plenty to play out in this one. They deserve credit for all the off field work, recruiting and improvements made in the off season. Transferring nicely to on field performance.

The SAAFL have a no win situation placing teams from other leagues. No matter where you place them, someone will criticise or feel hard done by. Ideally they should have been in Div 2. That said, I do commend headquarters for denying the neighsayers who wanted them placed lower

wristwatcher wrote:

valleys07 wrote:

Dutchy wrote:And Brighton left the SFL for competitive games

They will get them.

In 2019.

Get a grip people.

They haven't played any of the likely other top 4 teams.

The only team they have smashed is a team that has not won in two years.

From what I can gather they are a mid to upper Div 2 standard club but still plenty to play out in this one. They deserve credit for all the off field work, recruiting and improvements made in the off season. Transferring nicely to on field performance.

The SAAFL have a no win situation placing teams from other leagues. No matter where you place them, someone will criticise or feel hard done by. Ideally they should have been in Div 2. That said, I do commend headquarters for denying the neighsayers who wanted them placed lower

The game against Seaton was pretty tight... out to a 25 point lead at quarter time... and that was the margin at the end.... It will be a good test against Flinders Park in two weeks.

Bit late on it but thanks to the Seaton players/coaches/officials who came in after the A grade and had a drink. Would've been 20 or so Seaton guys upstairs having a few beers. Always nice to see opposition teams putting some money over the bar.

Round 5 results:

MITCHAM v. BRIGHTON BOMBERS
Round 5 - 06/05/2017

Brighton Bombers 4.1, 8.6, 15.8, 19.11 (125)

Mitcham 2.5, 2.9, 7.9, 10.13 (73)


GOALS, Brighton Bombers :
Jack Juniper 7, Todd Johnstone 3, James Wray 2, Robert Kernick 2, Benjamin Tate 1, Brett Irons 1,
John Mcpherson 1, Samuel Venning 1, Dylan Lang 1

Mitcham :
Tom Cromarty 2, Stuart Henshall 2, Dennis McEvoy 2, Simon Tucker 1, Steven Webster 1, Ky Meaden 1,
James Daly 1

BEST, Brighton Bombers :
Samuel Venning, James Wray, Dylan Lang, Jack Juniper, Todd Johnstone, Samuel Kennedy

Mitcham :
Lachlan Hall, Dennis McEvoy, Joshua Wills, Brett Aitken, Tom Cromarty

MATCH REPORT:





SMOSH WEST LAKES v. WALKERVILLE
Round 5 - 06/05/2017

Walkerville 4.5, 4.8, 8.13, 9.15 (69)

SMOSH West Lakes 2.2, 4.6, 6.10, 9.14 (68)


GOALS, Walkerville :
Dustin Fromm 3, Sean Kuerschner 2, Adam Law 1, Cameron Burr 1, Hugo Wallace 1, Luke Westbury 1

SMOSH West Lakes :
Nicholas Madden 3, William Kwan 2, Lyndon Parham 1, Jay Moore 1, Nathan Brown 1, Aidan Parham 1

BEST, Walkerville :
Thomas Daly, Sean Kuerschner, Adam Law, Lachlan Warner, Lincoln Blewit

SMOSH West Lakes :
Cohen Mattner, James Watt, Nathan Brown, Bradley Moore, Zac Beecken

MATCH REPORT:





SEATON RAMBLERS v. GOLDEN GROVE
Round 5 - 06/05/2017

Seaton Ramblers 3.3, 5.6, 14.13, 16.16 (112)

Golden Grove 8.3, 10.5, 10.11, 12.16 (88)


GOALS, Seaton Ramblers :
Anthony Laudato 4, Shane Harris 3, Tyler Carroll 2, Rocco Rugari 2, Luke Rochester 1, Paul Marshall 1,
Scott Priestley 1, Brett Harland 1, Luke Walsh 1

Golden Grove :
Judd Morris 3, Brayden Shaw 3, Ben Bamford 2, Shane Walker 1, Joshua Ingram 1, Kane Blades 1,
Benjamin Jardine 1

BEST, Seaton Ramblers :
Jarrad Brusnahan, Luke Rochester, Anthony Laudato, Giuseppe Muscara, Brett Harland

Golden Grove :
Judd Morris, Ben Bamford, Jake Pitman, Joshua Ingram, Shane Scudds

MATCH REPORT:





FLINDERS PARK v. PORTLAND
Round 5 - 06/05/2017

Flinders Park 3.3, 9.9, 12.12, 19.15 (129)

Portland 7.1, 8.3, 13.10, 15.10 (100)


GOALS, Flinders Park :
Andrew Ainger 5, Jordan Carrocci 2, James Schwarz 2, Kerren Hall 2, Geordi Haklar 1, Jay Collins 1,
Jesse Whinnen 1, Tyson Horsnell 1, Matthew Green 1, Kieran Johanson 1, Adam Coe 1, Daniel Blythe 1

Portland :
Brett Prior 5, Alex Bradley 4, Troy Wilkey 2, Gavin Shephard 1, Joshua Moody 1, Dylan Cranwell 1,
Aaron Christmann 1

BEST, Flinders Park :
Benjamin George, Geordi Haklar, Daniel Blythe, James Schwarz, Michael Demant

Portland :


MATCH REPORT:





WESTMINSTER OS v. PLYMPTON
Round 5 - 06/05/2017

Westminster OS 0.3, 6.4, 7.6, 12.10 (82)

Plympton 3.4, 6.5, 8.9, 9.11 (65)


GOALS, Westminster OS :
Rhys French 3, Phillip Middlin 2, Scott Blesing 2, Benjamin Fisher 2, Matthew Newman 1, Joshua Starling 1,
Thomas Easton 1

Plympton :
Giorgio Kastrappi 3, Jim Smith 2, Heath Deer 2, Tim Dunkley 1, Max Scott 1

BEST, Westminster OS :
Scott Blesing, Matthew Newman, Rhys French, Shane Birss, Russell McInerney

Plympton :
Stuart Taverner, Max Scott, Tim Dunkley, Kieren Nelson, Jim Smith

Should be a good sized crowd at Brighton on Saturday for the top of the table clash. Is it going to be a close game like the 2009 Rd 14 Saints v Geelong top of the table clash or will it be like the Crows v Richmond thumping few weeks ago?

Suri wrote:Should be a good sized crowd at Brighton on Saturday for the top of the table clash. Is it going to be a close game like the 2009 Rd 14 Saints v Geelong top of the table clash or will it be like the Crows v Richmond thumping few weeks ago?

Looking forward to the match Suri, be a good test to see how we compare to a club that believe they should be in div 2.

Thankfully it is at Brighton the 30 Brighton supporters will be there. If away the 5 faithful may show up depending on weather..

mighty hounds wrote:

Suri wrote:Should be a good sized crowd at Brighton on Saturday for the top of the table clash. Is it going to be a close game like the 2009 Rd 14 Saints v Geelong top of the table clash or will it be like the Crows v Richmond thumping few weeks ago?

Looking forward to the match Suri, be a good test to see how we compare to a club that believe they should be in div 2.

And what makes you think that Mighty Hounds. We were offered the opportunity to come into Div 3 in 2017 and gratefully accepted without any views on our status as a Div 3 club. Plenty of SA Footy contributors from other AdFL clubs and SFL clubs have offered their own opinions but we are taking nothing for granted and just enjoying playing clubs and ovals we have never played. You would be well aware that a Div 3 team won its first 7 games last season, finished the minor round 2nd, but still find themselves in Div 3 this year. That club has done us all a favour by reminding us that it's what you do in August and September that counts.