SA Footy

https://www.dartfish.tv/Player?CR=p132071c324807m4998387

The deliberate late shove of the ROCS player at 3:45 of the highlights at the goal umpire looks worse than any of those incidents in all honesty

Senor Moto Gadili wrote:

The Big Shrek wrote:

Trader wrote:SPOC boys fairly happy with the news that Holm (27:32), Coad (32:44) and W O'Malley (67:22) are apparently all off to Thebby HQ tomorrow night for various incidents on the weekend.

Video: https://www.dartfish.tv/Player?CR=p1320 ... 07m4998430

IMO, Coad's hit is late but probably gets off. The other two, especially O'Malley, look in trouble.

In all honesty what happened to having some pride in being a little tough? All three went down like year 8s when the boarding master called lights out. Is that the old collegians soccer match? I’m surprised their daddies didn’t run into the oval screaming “I’m a lawyer!”

No red cards handed out, so how do these three end up at the tribunal.

I think there have been numerous times throughout the season that clubs have referred footage to the league for assessment.

Not sure if that is the case here or not.

Based on similar incidents this year which have attracted suspensions Id be surprised if any of these 3 escaped sanction.

Realistically there's a process, if you stump up the $250 for an investigation and PAOC want to appear before the investigation committee then so be it (or $750 for the three complained of incidents).

jo172 wrote:https://www.dartfish.tv/Player?CR=p132071c324807m4998387

The deliberate late shove of the ROCS player at 3:45 of the highlights at the goal umpire looks worse than any of those incidents in all honesty

Agreed, give him a month and then Jolly can kick a bag this weekend!

Cash 123 wrote:I think there have been numerous times throughout the season that clubs have referred footage to the league for assessment.

It's been a series of crisis meetings for the college block since Saturday!

Do PAOC side with ROCs and keep quiet, or do they side with SPOC and help them out?

Seems to me clubs/players have become a bunch of p1ss weak dobberd1cks.

Trader wrote:

Cash 123 wrote:I think there have been numerous times throughout the season that clubs have referred footage to the league for assessment.

It's been a series of crisis meetings for the college block since Saturday!

Do PAOC side with ROCs and keep quiet, or do they side with SPOC and help them out?

Bloody secretarian conflicts have been thought between their respective ancestors over far less.

field of dreams wrote:Seems to me clubs/players have become a bunch of p1ss weak dobberd1cks.

with so many games filmed by dartfish in all grades now its no wonder this type of thing has increased..anyone can sit down and watch an entire game and go looking for "incidents"..

zedman wrote:

field of dreams wrote:Seems to me clubs/players have become a bunch of p1ss weak dobberd1cks.

with so many games filmed by dartfish in all grades now its no wonder this type of thing has increased..anyone can sit down and watch an entire game and go looking for "incidents"..

It is probably has merit if a player recalls a dirty incident that went un-noticed when they thought it deserved to be looked at.

There was a big clash in a game I umpired the other week and I was keen to see if I made the right call.

Lightning McQueen wrote:

zedman wrote:

field of dreams wrote:Seems to me clubs/players have become a bunch of p1ss weak dobberd1cks.

with so many games filmed by dartfish in all grades now its no wonder this type of thing has increased..anyone can sit down and watch an entire game and go looking for "incidents"..

It is probably has merit if a player recalls a dirty incident that went un-noticed when they thought it deserved to be looked at.

There was a big clash in a game I umpired the other week and I was keen to see if I made the right call.

Huge value if there's a dirty incident particularly one that results in injury that the umpire for whatever reason missed on the day.

jo172 wrote:

Lightning McQueen wrote:

zedman wrote:

field of dreams wrote:Seems to me clubs/players have become a bunch of p1ss weak dobberd1cks.

with so many games filmed by dartfish in all grades now its no wonder this type of thing has increased..anyone can sit down and watch an entire game and go looking for "incidents"..

It is probably has merit if a player recalls a dirty incident that went un-noticed when they thought it deserved to be looked at.

There was a big clash in a game I umpired the other week and I was keen to see if I made the right call.

Huge value if there's a dirty incident particularly one that results in injury that the umpire for whatever reason missed on the day.

For behind the play 'king hits" (coward punches) etc yes. When people are trawling videos looking for every little possible incident to try rub guys out? Disgusting.

field of dreams wrote:Seems to me clubs/players have become a bunch of p1ss weak dobberd1cks.

I think you’ll find most even the p1ss weak dobberd1cks agree to an extent but where does one draw the line in the sand ? Especially when Broken jaws concussions and broken ribs occur from a punch in a pack, If the players misses games due to injury .....then so should the instigator, if warranted

field of dreams wrote:
For behind the play 'king hits" (coward punches) etc yes. When people are trawling videos looking for every little possible incident to try rub guys out? Disgusting.

Unfortunately these don't get picked up because they are "behind the play".

Footy Chick wrote:

field of dreams wrote:Seems to me clubs/players have become a bunch of p1ss weak dobberd1cks.

I think you’ll find most even the p1ss weak dobberd1cks agree to an extent but where does one draw the line in the sand ? Especially when Broken jaws concussions and broken ribs occur from a punch in a pack, If the players misses games due to injury .....then so should the instigator, if warranted

I have no issues with clubs going through the process when an umpire has missed an incident that results in a player being injured. I believe that is where you draw the line in the sand. Correct me if I'm wrong, but none of the 3 PAOC players that were involved in the incidents sustained injuries did they?

Not sure, I was just giving general examples,

https://www.adelaidenow.com.au/messenger/sport/messengers-top-10-players-in-division-one-of-the-adelaide-footy-league-for-2019/news-story/bf836080be33d790afc559bd4d253fd5

FWIW according to News Corp:

1. J Pitt
2. T Heffernan
3. A Forster
4. L Manuel
5. L Davis
6. J Boyle
7. J O'Brien
8. P Seymour
9. D McCallum
10. H Jolly

HONOURABLE MENTIONS
Dylan Auciello (PNU), Tim Baccanello (ROC), Dylan Schoenmakers (Tea Tree Gully), James McLeay (SPOC), Damian Cunningham (Adelaide University), Jacob Carger (Brighton), Nick McGill (SPOC), Thomas Matsouliadis (SPOC), Jacob Hughes (Goodwood Saints), Brett Ancell (PNU), Ned Heath (Henley), Gavin Shephard (Port District), Tom Carter (Goodwood).

Obviously I haven't seen much D1 this year but I did hear someone say that Bretty Ancell would probably give the medal a crack on Monday? True or False?

Senor Moto Gadili wrote:

The Big Shrek wrote:

Trader wrote:SPOC boys fairly happy with the news that Holm (27:32), Coad (32:44) and W O'Malley (67:22) are apparently all off to Thebby HQ tomorrow night for various incidents on the weekend.

Video: https://www.dartfish.tv/Player?CR=p1320 ... 07m4998430

IMO, Coad's hit is late but probably gets off. The other two, especially O'Malley, look in trouble.

In all honesty what happened to having some pride in being a little tough? All three went down like year 8s when the boarding master called lights out. Is that the old collegians soccer match? I’m surprised their daddies didn’t run into the oval screaming “I’m a lawyer!”

No red cards handed out, so how do these three end up at the tribunal.

Any word on what happened at Tribunal?? All clear to play?

Footy Chick wrote:Obviously I haven't seen much D1 this year but I did hear someone say that Bretty Ancell would probably give the medal a crack on Monday? True or False?

I had Cameron Milne winning it by the length of flemington straight in 2015, and he got 4 votes, so don't ask me.

Looking at the pattern in recent years you can say it will be one of Will O'Malley, Craig Holm or Alex McKay.

Through the process of elimination I'd put my money on Will.

I'd also like Jesse O'Brien's chances too.

jo172 wrote:

Footy Chick wrote:Obviously I haven't seen much D1 this year but I did hear someone say that Bretty Ancell would probably give the medal a crack on Monday? True or False?

I had Cameron Milne winning it by the length of flemington straight in 2015, and he got 4 votes, so don't ask me.

Looking at the pattern in recent years you can say it will be one of Will O'Malley, Craig Holm or Alex McKay.

Through the process of elimination I'd put my money on Will.

I'd also like Jesse O'Brien's chances too.

I don't like Alex's chances in the D1 medal...