SA Footy

Notwithstanding the advice during the week seems a dangerous sling leading to concussion still a yellow in D1R

Suffice to say corrected in the ones. Many many dangerous tackles paid consistent with advice during the week.

Game itself the ugliest individual game I’ve ever seen. Pure yuk

jo172 wrote:Suffice to say corrected in the ones. Many many dangerous tackles paid consistent with advice during the week.

Game itself the ugliest individual game I’ve ever seen. Pure yuk

No scores onlne and im stuck at home with Covid Jim. What was the score in the SPOC v PNU game?

wristwatcher wrote:

jo172 wrote:Suffice to say corrected in the ones. Many many dangerous tackles paid consistent with advice during the week.

Game itself the ugliest individual game I’ve ever seen. Pure yuk

No scores onlne and im stuck at home with Covid Jim. What was the score in the SPOC v PNU game?

6.15 to 4.11 SPOC win

And 6.15 to 4.11 gave the visual spectacle justice.

Like if it had dropped 30 mm of rain during the game but perfect conditions

Port Districts sitting top of the ladder.
When was the last time they were top in Div 1?
Gotta be years if not decades.

jo172 wrote:Notwithstanding the advice during the week seems a dangerous sling leading to concussion still a yellow in D1R

Instructions are to give a yellow card to get the player off the ground - and it can be reviewed after discussion with fellow umpires and referred to the Umpiring Manager.

People don't always know what the procedures are - but it was upgraded to a Red post game.

Ezyasfallingdown wrote:

jo172 wrote:Notwithstanding the advice during the week seems a dangerous sling leading to concussion still a yellow in D1R

Instructions are to give a yellow card to get the player off the ground - and it can be reviewed after discussion with fellow umpires and referred to the Umpiring Manager.

People don't always know what the procedures are - but it was upgraded to a Red post game.

Actually think this the right process to follow. We had an incident a couple of years ago where one of our best players received a red card for a dangerous tackle early in the first quarter. He missed the rest of the game and upon review of the video footage, it was thrown out but by then he had almost sat a full week out anyway.

There is still the option for the umpire to call red if they think it warrants it, but yellow by default makes sense.

Sass! wrote:

Ezyasfallingdown wrote:

jo172 wrote:Notwithstanding the advice during the week seems a dangerous sling leading to concussion still a yellow in D1R

Instructions are to give a yellow card to get the player off the ground - and it can be reviewed after discussion with fellow umpires and referred to the Umpiring Manager.

People don't always know what the procedures are - but it was upgraded to a Red post game.

Actually think this the right process to follow. We had an incident a couple of years ago where one of our best players received a red card for a dangerous tackle early in the first quarter. He missed the rest of the game and upon review of the video footage, it was thrown out but by then he had almost sat a full week out anyway.

There is still the option for the umpire to call red if they think it warrants it, but yellow by default makes sense.

Correct - if they are certain - then red is appropriate. The League is handling this very well.

Coaches need to educate players to not throw people to the ground.

Ezyasfallingdown wrote:

Sass! wrote:

Ezyasfallingdown wrote:

jo172 wrote:Notwithstanding the advice during the week seems a dangerous sling leading to concussion still a yellow in D1R

Instructions are to give a yellow card to get the player off the ground - and it can be reviewed after discussion with fellow umpires and referred to the Umpiring Manager.

People don't always know what the procedures are - but it was upgraded to a Red post game.

Actually think this the right process to follow. We had an incident a couple of years ago where one of our best players received a red card for a dangerous tackle early in the first quarter. He missed the rest of the game and upon review of the video footage, it was thrown out but by then he had almost sat a full week out anyway.

There is still the option for the umpire to call red if they think it warrants it, but yellow by default makes sense.

Correct - if they are certain - then red is appropriate. The League is handling this very well.

Coaches need to educate players to not throw people to the ground.

It's strange in sense, not sure if it seems more prevalent or we're just more aware of it than we used to be.

Or potentially is this just us being a decade or so behind the AFL that was having a big problem with it in the early 2010s and had a similar crackdown to what's happening now that has largely disposed of them

it seems players are now receiving community service with their suspensions for dangerous tackles.....

harambe1 wrote:it seems players are now receiving community service with their suspensions for dangerous tackles.....

What are you referring to, harambe1??

harambe1 wrote:it seems players are now receiving community service with their suspensions for dangerous tackles.....

I think you might’ve over-simplified it Harambe1. To be fair I think the league are seeking as much input from its members as possible as to how they address this issue specifically and whether punitive is the only way to go. My loose understanding is it has been put to the league to introduce a combination of a suspension, a suspended component which they do now anyway and the possibility of players umpiring in junior matches as a form of education. You would imagine it to be confined for first timers or those without a record and possibly even for Abuse of Umpire offences. I suppose the precedent was set with the Scotch Coach having to umpire after he gave the umpires some advice.

Down the Hill wrote:

harambe1 wrote:it seems players are now receiving community service with their suspensions for dangerous tackles.....

I think you might’ve over-simplified it Harambe1. To be fair I think the league are seeking as much input from its members as possible as to how they address this issue specifically and whether punitive is the only way to go. My loose understanding is it has been put to the league to introduce a combination of a suspension, a suspended component which they do now anyway and the possibility of players umpiring in junior matches as a form of education. You would imagine it to be confined for first timers or those without a record and possibly even for Abuse of Umpire offences. I suppose the precedent was set with the Scotch Coach having to umpire after he gave the umpires some advice.

With the number of reports you blokes have had this year, shouldn't you be docked points?

Alan wrote:

Down the Hill wrote:

harambe1 wrote:it seems players are now receiving community service with their suspensions for dangerous tackles.....

I think you might’ve over-simplified it Harambe1. To be fair I think the league are seeking as much input from its members as possible as to how they address this issue specifically and whether punitive is the only way to go. My loose understanding is it has been put to the league to introduce a combination of a suspension, a suspended component which they do now anyway and the possibility of players umpiring in junior matches as a form of education. You would imagine it to be confined for first timers or those without a record and possibly even for Abuse of Umpire offences. I suppose the precedent was set with the Scotch Coach having to umpire after he gave the umpires some advice.

With the number of reports you blokes have had this year, shouldn't you be docked points?

How many reports have they had this year? I’d love to be able to see the tribunal list for the year - always enjoyed looking at that each week

Week 7
21/05/2022 MRP Harrison Nolen Goodwood 1 Men Dangerous Tackle Careless High Low Accept 4 (2)
21/05/2022 MRP Tom Butterworth Glenunga 1 Men Dangerous Tackle Careless High Low Accept 3 (1)
21/05/2022 MRP Jack Plenty Brighton 1 Men Dangerous Tackle Careless High Medium Accept 4 (2)
21/05/2022 MRP Brad Warner Mitcham 4R Men Striking Careless High Low Accept 3 (1)
21/05/2022 Prescribed Hayden Theunens Portland 4R Men Undue Rough Play Careless Body Severe Accept 1 (1)
21/05/2022 MRP James King Eastern Park 5R Men Abuse of Umpire Accept 3 (1)
21/05/2022 MRP Luke Woodcock West Croydon 6 Men Front on Contact Careless High Low Accept 2 (1)

Abuse to an Umpire W. James (Coach) 5 + (2) (2) Scotch OC 3 Men Accept
Abuse to an Umpire Joseph Connelly 5 North Haven 3R Men Accept
Abuse to an Umpire Jason Frost 3 Para Hills 6R Men Accept
Abuse to an Umpire R. Worthingham (Coach) (2) Hope Valley 3 Women Accept
Charging Riley Mitchell 3 + (1) Elizabeth 5 Men Careless High Medium Accept
Dangerous Tackle Kane Flanagan 5 + 1) Broadview 2 Men Careless High High Accept
Dangerous Tackle Daniel Tonkin 5 St Peters OC 2R Men Careless Body Severe Accept
Dangerous Tackle Dane Owen 4 + (1) St Pauls OS 5 Men Intentional Body Low Accept
Dangerous Tackle Justin Whitford 4 + (1) PHOS 2 Men Intentional High Medium Accept
Dangerous Tackle Tyson Breden 3 + (2) Tea Tree Gully 1 Men Careless High Medium Accept
Dangerous Tackle Blake Higgins 3 + (2) Brighton Bombers 1 Men Careless High Medium Accept
Dangerous Tackle Matthew Paine 3 + (1) Hackham 7 Men Careless High Medium Accept
Dangerous Tackle Sam Fuller 3 + (1) Gaza C2 Men Careless High Medium Accept
Dangerous Tackle Cooper Henshaw 3 + (1) Flinders Uni 7 Men Careless High Medium Accept
Dangerous Tackle Otis Carthy 3 + (1) Brighton Bombers 1 Men Careless High Medium Accept
Dangerous Tackle Rourke Turner 3 Henley 2 Men Careless High Medium Accept
Dangerous Tackle Paul Dreimann 2 + (1) Salisbury North 2 Men Careless High Low Accept
Dangerous Tackle Ben Owen-Thomas 2 + (1) Payneham NU 1 Men Careless High Low Accept
Dangerous Tackle Sam Boots 2 + (1) Old Ignatians 1 Men Careless High Low Accept
Dangerous Tackle Anthony Skara 2 + (1) Goodwood 1 Men Careless High Low Accept
Dangerous Tackle Jarman Sigal 2 Brighton Bombers 1 Men Careless Body Low Guilty
Rough Conduct M. Parfumi 2 + (1) Scotch OC 3 Men Careless High Low Accept
Striking D. Bland 5 + (2) Brighton Bombers 1R Men Intentional High Medium Accept
Striking Nick Likouresis 4 + (1) Portland 3R Men Intentional High Medium Accept
Striking Theissen Cairns 4 + (1) Brahma Lodge C6 Men Intentional High Medium Accept
Striking L. Wood 3 + (1) Woodville South 4 Men Intentional High Low Accept
Striking Jamie Coff 3 + (1) Woodville South 4 Men Intentional High Low Accept
Striking Connor Drum 3 + (1) Westminster OS 3 Men Intentional High Low Guilty
Striking H. Chaplin 3 + (1) Scotch OC 3 Men Careless High Medium Accept
Striking Jake Russo 3 + (1) Salisbury North 2 Men Careless Medium High Accept
Striking M. Riley 3 + (1) Para Hills 6R Men Intentional High Low Accept
Striking Amber Miller 3 + (1) North Haven 5 Women Intentional High Low Accept
Striking Jack Heffernan 3 + (1) Marion C6 Men Intentional Body Medium Accept
Undue Rough Play Nick Wundke 5 Glenunga Rams 1 Men Careless High Severe Guilty

The Bedge wrote:Week 7
21/05/2022 MRP Harrison Nolen Goodwood 1 Men Dangerous Tackle Careless High Low Accept 4 (2)
21/05/2022 MRP Tom Butterworth Glenunga 1 Men Dangerous Tackle Careless High Low Accept 3 (1)
21/05/2022 MRP Jack Plenty Brighton 1 Men Dangerous Tackle Careless High Medium Accept 4 (2)
21/05/2022 MRP Brad Warner Mitcham 4R Men Striking Careless High Low Accept 3 (1)
21/05/2022 Prescribed Hayden Theunens Portland 4R Men Undue Rough Play Careless Body Severe Accept 1 (1)
21/05/2022 MRP James King Eastern Park 5R Men Abuse of Umpire Accept 3 (1)
21/05/2022 MRP Luke Woodcock West Croydon 6 Men Front on Contact Careless High Low Accept 2 (1)

Abuse to an Umpire W. James (Coach) 5 + (2) (2) Scotch OC 3 Men Accept
Abuse to an Umpire Joseph Connelly 5 North Haven 3R Men Accept
Abuse to an Umpire Jason Frost 3 Para Hills 6R Men Accept
Abuse to an Umpire R. Worthingham (Coach) (2) Hope Valley 3 Women Accept
Charging Riley Mitchell 3 + (1) Elizabeth 5 Men Careless High Medium Accept
Dangerous Tackle Kane Flanagan 5 + 1) Broadview 2 Men Careless High High Accept
Dangerous Tackle Daniel Tonkin 5 St Peters OC 2R Men Careless Body Severe Accept
Dangerous Tackle Dane Owen 4 + (1) St Pauls OS 5 Men Intentional Body Low Accept
Dangerous Tackle Justin Whitford 4 + (1) PHOS 2 Men Intentional High Medium Accept
Dangerous Tackle Tyson Breden 3 + (2) Tea Tree Gully 1 Men Careless High Medium Accept
Dangerous Tackle Blake Higgins 3 + (2) Brighton Bombers 1 Men Careless High Medium Accept
Dangerous Tackle Matthew Paine 3 + (1) Hackham 7 Men Careless High Medium Accept
Dangerous Tackle Sam Fuller 3 + (1) Gaza C2 Men Careless High Medium Accept
Dangerous Tackle Cooper Henshaw 3 + (1) Flinders Uni 7 Men Careless High Medium Accept
Dangerous Tackle Otis Carthy 3 + (1) Brighton Bombers 1 Men Careless High Medium Accept
Dangerous Tackle Rourke Turner 3 Henley 2 Men Careless High Medium Accept
Dangerous Tackle Paul Dreimann 2 + (1) Salisbury North 2 Men Careless High Low Accept
Dangerous Tackle Ben Owen-Thomas 2 + (1) Payneham NU 1 Men Careless High Low Accept
Dangerous Tackle Sam Boots 2 + (1) Old Ignatians 1 Men Careless High Low Accept
Dangerous Tackle Anthony Skara 2 + (1) Goodwood 1 Men Careless High Low Accept
Dangerous Tackle Jarman Sigal 2 Brighton Bombers 1 Men Careless Body Low Guilty
Rough Conduct M. Parfumi 2 + (1) Scotch OC 3 Men Careless High Low Accept
Striking D. Bland 5 + (2) Brighton Bombers 1R Men Intentional High Medium Accept
Striking Nick Likouresis 4 + (1) Portland 3R Men Intentional High Medium Accept
Striking Theissen Cairns 4 + (1) Brahma Lodge C6 Men Intentional High Medium Accept
Striking L. Wood 3 + (1) Woodville South 4 Men Intentional High Low Accept
Striking Jamie Coff 3 + (1) Woodville South 4 Men Intentional High Low Accept
Striking Connor Drum 3 + (1) Westminster OS 3 Men Intentional High Low Guilty
Striking H. Chaplin 3 + (1) Scotch OC 3 Men Careless High Medium Accept
Striking Jake Russo 3 + (1) Salisbury North 2 Men Careless Medium High Accept
Striking M. Riley 3 + (1) Para Hills 6R Men Intentional High Low Accept
Striking Amber Miller 3 + (1) North Haven 5 Women Intentional High Low Accept
Striking Jack Heffernan 3 + (1) Marion C6 Men Intentional Body Medium Accept
Undue Rough Play Nick Wundke 5 Glenunga Rams 1 Men Careless High Severe Guilty

Thanks mate much appreciated - brighton got some serious discipline issues - but would guarantee they'd be the first club to slander northern sides.

So looking at Div 1.

Community Clubs
Brighton, Glenunga, TTG, Goodwood, PNU, Port Districts - 11 guilty, 43 weeks

Old Scholars Block
Iggies, PAC, Saints, Rostrevor - 1 guilty, 3 weeks.

Trader wrote:So looking at Div 1.

Community Clubs
Brighton, Glenunga, TTG, Goodwood, PNU, Port Districts - 11 guilty, 43 weeks

Old Scholars Block
Iggies, PAC, Saints, Rostrevor - 1 guilty, 3 weeks.

22 weeks coming from brighton

Missed a SPOC reserves player erroneously described as 2R who got 5 weeks

Also notable that only one suspension across the division for anything other than dangerous tackles.