Page 9 of 18
Re: 2022 Adelaide Footy League- Division 1
Posted:
Thu May 26, 2022 11:04 pmby harambe1
Sticks28 wrote:The Bedge wrote:Week 7
21/05/2022 MRP Harrison Nolen Goodwood 1 Men Dangerous Tackle Careless High Low Accept 4 (2)
21/05/2022 MRP Tom Butterworth Glenunga 1 Men Dangerous Tackle Careless High Low Accept 3 (1)
21/05/2022 MRP Jack Plenty Brighton 1 Men Dangerous Tackle Careless High Medium Accept 4 (2)
21/05/2022 MRP Brad Warner Mitcham 4R Men Striking Careless High Low Accept 3 (1)
21/05/2022 Prescribed Hayden Theunens Portland 4R Men Undue Rough Play Careless Body Severe Accept 1 (1)
21/05/2022 MRP James King Eastern Park 5R Men Abuse of Umpire Accept 3 (1)
21/05/2022 MRP Luke Woodcock West Croydon 6 Men Front on Contact Careless High Low Accept 2 (1)
Abuse to an Umpire W. James (Coach) 5 + (2) (2) Scotch OC 3 Men Accept
Abuse to an Umpire Joseph Connelly 5 North Haven 3R Men Accept
Abuse to an Umpire Jason Frost 3 Para Hills 6R Men Accept
Abuse to an Umpire R. Worthingham (Coach) (2) Hope Valley 3 Women Accept
Charging Riley Mitchell 3 + (1) Elizabeth 5 Men Careless High Medium Accept
Dangerous Tackle Kane Flanagan 5 + 1) Broadview 2 Men Careless High High Accept
Dangerous Tackle Daniel Tonkin 5 St Peters OC 2R Men Careless Body Severe Accept
Dangerous Tackle Dane Owen 4 + (1) St Pauls OS 5 Men Intentional Body Low Accept
Dangerous Tackle Justin Whitford 4 + (1) PHOS 2 Men Intentional High Medium Accept
Dangerous Tackle Tyson Breden 3 + (2) Tea Tree Gully 1 Men Careless High Medium Accept
Dangerous Tackle Blake Higgins 3 + (2) Brighton Bombers 1 Men Careless High Medium Accept
Dangerous Tackle Matthew Paine 3 + (1) Hackham 7 Men Careless High Medium Accept
Dangerous Tackle Sam Fuller 3 + (1) Gaza C2 Men Careless High Medium Accept
Dangerous Tackle Cooper Henshaw 3 + (1) Flinders Uni 7 Men Careless High Medium Accept
Dangerous Tackle Otis Carthy 3 + (1) Brighton Bombers 1 Men Careless High Medium Accept
Dangerous Tackle Rourke Turner 3 Henley 2 Men Careless High Medium Accept
Dangerous Tackle Paul Dreimann 2 + (1) Salisbury North 2 Men Careless High Low Accept
Dangerous Tackle Ben Owen-Thomas 2 + (1) Payneham NU 1 Men Careless High Low Accept
Dangerous Tackle Sam Boots 2 + (1) Old Ignatians 1 Men Careless High Low Accept
Dangerous Tackle Anthony Skara 2 + (1) Goodwood 1 Men Careless High Low Accept
Dangerous Tackle Jarman Sigal 2 Brighton Bombers 1 Men Careless Body Low Guilty
Rough Conduct M. Parfumi 2 + (1) Scotch OC 3 Men Careless High Low Accept
Striking D. Bland 5 + (2) Brighton Bombers 1R Men Intentional High Medium Accept
Striking Nick Likouresis 4 + (1) Portland 3R Men Intentional High Medium Accept
Striking Theissen Cairns 4 + (1) Brahma Lodge C6 Men Intentional High Medium Accept
Striking L. Wood 3 + (1) Woodville South 4 Men Intentional High Low Accept
Striking Jamie Coff 3 + (1) Woodville South 4 Men Intentional High Low Accept
Striking Connor Drum 3 + (1) Westminster OS 3 Men Intentional High Low Guilty
Striking H. Chaplin 3 + (1) Scotch OC 3 Men Careless High Medium Accept
Striking Jake Russo 3 + (1) Salisbury North 2 Men Careless Medium High Accept
Striking M. Riley 3 + (1) Para Hills 6R Men Intentional High Low Accept
Striking Amber Miller 3 + (1) North Haven 5 Women Intentional High Low Accept
Striking Jack Heffernan 3 + (1) Marion C6 Men Intentional Body Medium Accept
Undue Rough Play Nick Wundke 5 Glenunga Rams 1 Men Careless High Severe Guilty
Thanks mate much appreciated - brighton got some serious discipline issues - but would guarantee they'd be the first club to slander northern sides.
Did Brighton hurt your feelings?
Their round 1 suspensions weren’t even match day reports and came from a goodwood complaint. They’ve had 2 red cards in the 2s that’s all.
It seems every club is still adjusting to the changes of dangerous tackle reports/suspensions so I’d argue they aren’t alone.
Re: 2022 Adelaide Footy League- Division 1
Posted:
Fri May 27, 2022 12:58 amby Down the Hill
Sticks28 wrote:Trader wrote:So looking at Div 1.
Community Clubs
Brighton, Glenunga, TTG, Goodwood, PNU, Port Districts - 11 guilty, 43 weeks
Old Scholars Block
Iggies, PAC, Saints, Rostrevor - 1 guilty, 3 weeks.
22 weeks coming from brighton
A bit of context Sticks. You have counted the plus matches which are those that sit in the suspension bank for 3 years so that does inflate your figures. Plus there were some errors in this weeks tribunal update. Our lad got 2 + 2 not 4 + 2. And thanks for your opinion on our discipline issues. 4 of our 5 reports have been for dangerous tackles. All of those tackle reports were A grade players who have never been reported previously. 3 of them in Round 1 which kickstarted the whole education process. Clearly some players (including one more of ours) across several clubs haven't learnt from what was widely reported after Round 1 and have been paying the price since.
Re: 2022 Adelaide Footy League- Division 1
Posted:
Fri May 27, 2022 8:34 amby MoP
Down the Hill wrote:Sticks28 wrote:Trader wrote:So looking at Div 1.
Community Clubs
Brighton, Glenunga, TTG, Goodwood, PNU, Port Districts - 11 guilty, 43 weeks
Old Scholars Block
Iggies, PAC, Saints, Rostrevor - 1 guilty, 3 weeks.
22 weeks coming from brighton
A bit of context Sticks. You have counted the plus matches which are those that sit in the suspension bank for 3 years so that does inflate your figures. Plus there were some errors in this weeks tribunal update. Our lad got 2 + 2 not 4 + 2. And thanks for your opinion on our discipline issues. 4 of our 5 reports have been for dangerous tackles. All of those tackle reports were A grade players who have never been reported previously. 3 of them in Round 1 which kickstarted the whole education process. Clearly some players (including one more of ours) across several clubs haven't learnt from what was widely reported after Round 1 and have been paying the price since.
I think there is still plenty of confusion around the dangerous tackle, despite the league's education process. I watched the Glenunga v Goodwood game on the weekend and there were 2 such tackles in about 5 minutes (1 from each team). Glenunga were paid a free kick for Goodwood's dangerous tackle, yet just after that, Goodwood were paid a free kick AND the Glenunga player was sent off. No consistency in the interpretation. Too much emphasis is placed on what happens to the player rather than the actual incident itself.
Re: 2022 Adelaide Footy League- Division 1
Posted:
Fri May 27, 2022 10:02 amby The Bedge
Confusion starts with the umpires - like the poor bloke from Salisbury North.. rewarded with a free kick for his tackle on the Saturday, suspended on review on the Monday,
Re: 2022 Adelaide Footy League- Division 1
Posted:
Fri May 27, 2022 10:35 amby jo172
The Bedge wrote:Confusion starts with the umpires - like the poor bloke from Salisbury North.. rewarded with a free kick for his tackle on the Saturday, suspended on review on the Monday,
I'd even wager a guess that more things later suspended for dangerous tackles have been paid holding the ball at the time than have received a yellow card at the time.
Umpires adjusting just as everyone else is.
Re: 2022 Adelaide Footy League- Division 1
Posted:
Fri May 27, 2022 11:05 amby The Bedge
Personally I see no confusion in what constitutes a dangerous tackle, it's pretty straight forward.
If you sling / throw with deliberate force that's dangerous.
If you grab, drive / dump with deliberate force into the ground that's dangerous.
If adjudicating it as an official, i'd probably ask myself - did that look bad? Yes.. then pay it.
Re: 2022 Adelaide Footy League- Division 1
Posted:
Fri May 27, 2022 12:43 pmby jo172
Looking at the video I can see a dangerous tackle too.
When you've got a split second a lot look like holding the ball.
Hell, usually because a dangerous tackle involves hanging on to a bloke long enough to cause the danger it's more likely to be holding the ball in the traditional sense.
In the same way I've got sympathy for a lot of the players learning as they're going I've got sympathy for the umpires.
We played Goodwood in Round 2, and after the incidents in Round 1 they were almost comically oversensitive to what constituted a dangerous tackle. Finding the right balance instinctively will naturally take time.
Re: 2022 Adelaide Footy League- Division 1
Posted:
Sat May 28, 2022 2:19 pmby Bluedemon
Did Brighton's C grade forfeit today?
Re: 2022 Adelaide Footy League- Division 1
Posted:
Sat May 28, 2022 2:42 pmby locky801
Bluedemon wrote:Did Brighton's C grade forfeit today?
Yes
Re: 2022 Adelaide Footy League- Division 1
Posted:
Sat May 28, 2022 9:06 pmby FOURTH ESTATE
That must be a concern or covid related???
Re: 2022 Adelaide Footy League- Division 1
Posted:
Sat Jun 04, 2022 5:47 pmby jo172
Had some domestic matters meaning I couldn’t get to Petaringa today. What a great product the live streaming is.
Who would have thought our little old league would have this service. Brilliant.
At the half way point this is a fantastically poised division (that Goodwood will go on to win, because they always do)
Re: 2022 Adelaide Footy League- Division 1
Posted:
Sun Jun 05, 2022 2:22 pmby harambe1
interesting scoreline at the brighton spoc game yesterday
Re: 2022 Adelaide Footy League- Division 1
Posted:
Mon Jun 06, 2022 10:16 amby JD1981
harambe1 wrote:interesting scoreline at the brighton spoc game yesterday
I went and had a look, that was the 3/4 time score... SPOC's 4 goals came in the last part of the last qtr...
Brighton hunted the ball well, ran in good numbers and were a bit tougher in the clinches...
Brighton oval is in bad shape, it will only get worse from here too and cause games to be mud wrestling for the rest of the season...
Re: 2022 Adelaide Footy League- Division 1
Posted:
Mon Jun 06, 2022 11:08 amby TheTranzlator
JD1981 wrote:harambe1 wrote:interesting scoreline at the brighton spoc game yesterday
I went and had a look, that was the 3/4 time score... SPOC's 4 goals came in the last part of the last qtr...
Brighton hunted the ball well, ran in good numbers and were a bit tougher in the clinches...
Brighton oval is in bad shape, it will only get worse from here too and cause games to be mud wrestling for the rest of the season...
Yep, I think a fair few ovals will be the same. Going to be a long, muddy winter after the downpour over the weekend.
Re: 2022 Adelaide Footy League- Division 1
Posted:
Fri Jun 17, 2022 5:04 pmby Senor Moto Gadili
I notice work has started on the Grand Palace at Park 9. What is the completion date jimmy?
Re: 2022 Adelaide Footy League- Division 1
Posted:
Fri Jun 17, 2022 5:17 pmby Jimmy_041
Senor Moto Gadili wrote:I notice work has started on the Grand Palace at Park 9. What is the completion date jimmy?
Half way through next year (and it's the Gin Palace according to Peter Goers)
I own a few bricks in it - I reckon they're going to name a dunny after me
Re: 2022 Adelaide Footy League- Division 1
Posted:
Fri Jun 17, 2022 6:46 pmby Yank Man
Jimmy_041 wrote:Senor Moto Gadili wrote:I notice work has started on the Grand Palace at Park 9. What is the completion date jimmy?
Half way through next year (and it's the Gin Palace according to Peter Goers)
I own a few bricks in it - I reckon they're going to name a dunny after me
More like put up a statue......with a cheeky grin.
Re: 2022 Adelaide Footy League- Division 1
Posted:
Sat Jun 25, 2022 6:23 pmby hollywood7477
Read on HQ Goodies v Payneham game abandoned!!!!
Re: 2022 Adelaide Footy League- Division 1
Posted:
Sat Jun 25, 2022 6:40 pmby Down the Hill
Either a data entry error or even if game was called off due to a bad injury? The last qtr was clearly in progress so the team ahead on the scoreboard is still the winner.
Re: 2022 Adelaide Footy League- Division 1
Posted:
Sat Jun 25, 2022 6:51 pmby Jimmy_041
Senor Moto Gadili wrote:I notice work has started on the Grand Palace at Park 9. What is the completion date jimmy?
Edit: will be finished by December this year.
The entertainment area is smaller than the massage rooms.
The good folk of the AdFL and ATCA will only have a small area out of the weather
Really disappointing after the improvements at other clubs.