Page 1 of 3
Redbacks One - Day Eleven Of All Time.
Posted:
Sat Dec 01, 2007 10:06 pmby SOTTERS
M.Elliott
G.Blewett
I.Chappell
D.Lehmann
D.Hookes
M.Cosgrove
W.Phillips (wk)
T.May
J.Gillespie
P.Wilson
S.Tait
Re: Redbacks One - Day Eleven Of All Time.
Posted:
Sat Dec 01, 2007 10:10 pmby spell_check
On their day, that side would be unstoppable. Particularly the batting. Maybe have Siddons in as 12th man/in the team for his fielding. Cosgrove might be the unlucky one if Siddons is in the team.
Re: Redbacks One - Day Eleven Of All Time.
Posted:
Sat Dec 01, 2007 10:32 pmby SOTTERS
The NSW side may give them a run !
M.Slater
M.Waugh
S.Waugh
M.Bevan
B.Haddin (wk)
S.Katich
S.Lee
B.Lee
G.Robertson
N.Bracken
G.McGrath
Re: Redbacks One - Day Eleven Of All Time.
Posted:
Sat Dec 01, 2007 10:50 pmby Hondo
What about Glenn Bishop he was a superb one day player?
Others to consider would be Andrew Zesers (part of 87 Aust World Cup squad), Siddons (as Spelly said in place of Cossie) or Paul Nobes. I would also put Rod McCurdy or Rodney Hogg in place of Blocker.
Cossie seems lucky to make the XI at this stage IMO
I reckon I'd slot Bishop in place of Elliot, Hogg in place of Wilson and Siddons in place of Cossie
Re: Redbacks One - Day Eleven Of All Time.
Posted:
Sat Dec 01, 2007 10:53 pmby GWW
Yes I'd DEFINITELY have Bishop in the side. Wouldn't have Cosgrove though, I'd have Nobes (and Siddons) in before him.
Re: Redbacks One - Day Eleven Of All Time.
Posted:
Sat Dec 01, 2007 10:54 pmby Hondo
SOTTERS wrote:The NSW side may give them a run !
M.Slater
M.Waugh
S.Waugh
M.Bevan
B.Haddin (wk)
S.Katich
S.Lee
B.Lee
G.Robertson
N.Bracken
G.McGrath
You would have to consider Mo Matthews or Peter Taylor ahead of Robertson and Geoff Lawson ahead of Bracken. Maybe McNamara ahead of Shane Lee? How about Rick McKosker ahead of the Kat (maybe not)?
Where's REB?
Re: Redbacks One - Day Eleven Of All Time.
Posted:
Sat Dec 01, 2007 10:57 pmby bayman
Re: Redbacks One - Day Eleven Of All Time.
Posted:
Sat Dec 01, 2007 11:02 pmby GWW
Bradman played one day cricket
Re: Redbacks One - Day Eleven Of All Time.
Posted:
Sat Dec 01, 2007 11:05 pmby Hondo
The great man can't go in a best XI side in a format he never played IMO
Even tho he would have dominated if he did
Re: Redbacks One - Day Eleven Of All Time.
Posted:
Sat Dec 01, 2007 11:07 pmby bayman
hondo71 wrote:The great man can't go in a best XI side in a format he never played IMO
Even tho he would have dominated if he did
it says 'of all time' so surely he & others do come into it
Re: Redbacks One - Day Eleven Of All Time.
Posted:
Sat Dec 01, 2007 11:09 pmby GWW
bayman wrote:hondo71 wrote:The great man can't go in a best XI side in a format he never played IMO
Even tho he would have dominated if he did
it says 'of all time' so surely he & others do come into it
What are his one day stats?
By all time it basically means from the the time one day cricket started, which i believe was mid 70's, although i think there were a few games played in the early 70's as well (late 60's in England i think).
Re: Redbacks One - Day Eleven Of All Time.
Posted:
Sat Dec 01, 2007 11:10 pmby Hondo
Bayman 'all time' for one day cricket means from early 1970s to today, 30 years after Bradman retired.
Bradman romps in the best Test and NSW Shield XI by a mile
But he never played a ODI - how do his ODI stats compare to Steve Waugh?
Re: Redbacks One - Day Eleven Of All Time.
Posted:
Sat Dec 01, 2007 11:29 pmby bayman
i know what you are saying but answer me this if you could pick a oneday side from all eras of cricket would you have bradman in or not ?
Re: Redbacks One - Day Eleven Of All Time.
Posted:
Sat Dec 01, 2007 11:35 pmby smithy
bayman wrote:hondo71 wrote:The great man can't go in a best XI side in a format he never played IMO
Even tho he would have dominated if he did
it says 'of all time' so surely he & others do come into it
That's just a downright stupid comment !
Re: Redbacks One - Day Eleven Of All Time.
Posted:
Sat Dec 01, 2007 11:57 pmby bayman
a bit rude aren't you ?
Re: Redbacks One - Day Eleven Of All Time.
Posted:
Sat Dec 01, 2007 11:59 pmby smithy
Sorry Bayman,, it was a bit harsh,, but you can't pick someone who never played the game.(1 Dayers)
Next are we going to pick him as captain of the all time 20/20 team of the century?..
I should spot a downright stupid comment when I see one as I have lots of practise typing them.
Re: Redbacks One - Day Eleven Of All Time.
Posted:
Thu Dec 06, 2007 9:59 amby bulldogproud
I am one of Herb's biggest fans (particularly as he is a West Torrens man) however I would not find a place for him in that team. I would go with either Bishop or Rick Darling in his place. I would also possibly think of Peter Sleep ahead of Tim May. Sounda's batting may give him the edge.
Cheers.
Re: Redbacks One - Day Eleven Of All Time.
Posted:
Thu Dec 06, 2007 2:39 pmby Ecky
So are these guys eligible - they all played one-dayers for SA!
Barry Richards
Joel Garner
Lance Gibbs
Greg Chappell
Les Favell
Barrie Robran
(averaged 42!)
Sobers didn't though.
Re: Redbacks One - Day Eleven Of All Time.
Posted:
Thu Dec 06, 2007 2:40 pmby Ecky
GWW wrote:Yes I'd DEFINITELY have Bishop in the side. Wouldn't have Cosgrove though, I'd have Nobes (and Siddons) in before him.
Bishop averaged 24.58 for SA in one-dayers.
Re: Redbacks One - Day Eleven Of All Time.
Posted:
Thu Dec 06, 2007 2:46 pmby mighty_tiger_79
SOTTERS wrote:M.Elliott
G.Blewett
I.Chappell
D.Lehmann
D.Hookes
M.Cosgrove
W.Phillips (wk)
T.May
J.Gillespie
P.Wilson
S.Tait
the 2 highlighted wouldnt be in my team, but agree with the rest
elliott and cosi
