SA Footy

I cant see why Jaques cant get in at 6 ahead of Clarke. This guy is banging the door down. Why must he be an opener. Look at the way Blewett and Hussey started their careers at test level. 5 and 6. Clarke hasnt had to work hard enough 4 his spot nor has he performed as well as jaques at 1st class level. Nor has clarke performed aswell as players in years gone by like bevan and lehmann who were never smooched on the tockley like clarke.

On form I think Cameron White and Brad Haddin are two of the best players in the country at the moment aswell. Both are striking the ball magnificently even tho they would be left field selections.. Not to mention old Darren.

Im not convinced clarke is safe enough defensively for a big series like this yet.

In actual fact the more I think about it it is a disgrace Jaques cant get ahead of clarke. number 6 is where so many players get thier 1st chance and it should be jaques.

i am of the view the selectors will dump langer if he doesnt reach 50 in brisbane or adelaide.


opinion away folks

Don't worry Dash, if you have a look at the "Watson - made of glass" thread, you will see that there are a few of us that agree with you.

Have to agree dash, but realistically if the best line up was to be picked Langer wouldn't be in it and Jaques would be opening. Langer is on borrow time and is only in the side based on his past performances and the fact that his attitude is so good.

Agree about Lehmann as well. Surely there aren't currently 6 batsmen in Australia better than him?

rod_rooster wrote:Have to agree dash, but realistically if the best line up was to be picked Langer wouldn't be in it and Jaques would be opening. Langer is on borrow time and is only in the side based on his past performances and the fact that his attitude is so good.

Agree about Lehmann as well. Surely there aren't currently 6 batsmen in Australia better than him?

langers domestic form aint too bad

Clarke is the next best batsman since Ponting. Give him time, he will deliver. Jaques will get his turn when Langer or Hayden fail/retire.

Aerie wrote:Clarke is the next best batsman since Ponting. Give him time, he will deliver.

And when he does then pick him

Aerie wrote:Jaques will get his turn when Langer or Hayden fail/retire.

Should pick the best player for the position and Jaques is better than Langer currently. I'm not saying Langer won't do a good job or is terribly out of form but Jaques is just a better player right now.

Langer in the sixties not out...this argument was valid 2 hours ago, not anymore

rod_rooster wrote:

Aerie wrote:Clarke is the next best batsman since Ponting. Give him time, he will deliver.

And when he does then pick him

Aerie wrote:Jaques will get his turn when Langer or Hayden fail/retire.

Should pick the best player for the position and Jaques is better than Langer currently. I'm not saying Langer won't do a good job or is terribly out of form but Jaques is just a better player right now.

id have stuck with langer and hayden but when watson ot injured gone 4 jaques not clarke

Aerie wrote:Clarke is the next best batsman since Ponting. Give him time, he will deliver. Jaques will get his turn when Langer or Hayden fail/retire.

jarrad inside 50 with kic k. was that maney or cross?

rod_rooster wrote:

Aerie wrote:Clarke is the next best batsman since Ponting. Give him time, he will deliver.

And when he does then pick him

Aerie wrote:Jaques will get his turn when Langer or Hayden fail/retire.

Should pick the best player for the position and Jaques is better than Langer currently. I'm not saying Langer won't do a good job or is terribly out of form but Jaques is just a better player right now.

Langer is better. End of story.

JL is the man end of story, he has the form oin the board in the last month and the selection credits from scoring 4000+ runs in the last six years to get the gig today, his innings today confirmed that.

However I think these will be the last five tests of his career, He'll either retire or the selctors will make the generation change for the 1st test against SL in Novemeber next year...