1980 Tassie Medalist wrote:Dutchy, trust me having compared the aerobic capacities of Australian footballers and Soccer players Hockey etc there is no difference aerobically between our athletes and theirs. They are not fitter and the movement patterns are very similar.
The amount of standing around in Australian Football is minimal now compared to the study of Jaques and Pavia in 1973 - even at U/18 level
Subjectively they may look fitter to you but I'll back Tommy Logan, Van Berlo, Kane Cornes & Burton against any of those blokes in a 3 km run
Physical the sports are the same but to compensate for those defiencies they use a round ball, far easier to control and becasue of their neural deficiencies they assit them by limiting their skill level to their feet......
I can not believe how any sane sport watcher anywhere in the world can comprehend for a nano-second how that sport is in the same galaxy when it comes to looking at skill level, physical capacity, demnds on its athletes, decision making and mental application.
Soccer is so far behind Australin Football it is not funny.
Seriously taking my emotions and biases out of it and look at both sports analytically as a trained exercise physiologist it is not a contest....
One day the rest of the world will wake up....
Contrdicted yourself there Tassie...
Firstly having a round ball makes the game harder as there are less variables so you need more skill to deceive opposition and goalkeepers...it also makes it harder that you cant pick it up as in aussie rules
18 players on the field in footy with sometimes up to 60 interchanges per game - they get plenty of rest time, have a look at a forward line when the ball is up in the other pocket
Neil Craig is successful as he has identified that AFL players can get fitter and more dynamic...there are many teams that havent got anywhere near the capacity of the Crows or top level soccer players (Rioli from Essendon...LOL)
anyway have a good weekend and Im sure we both agree on one thing - go the tiges tomorrow...looking forward to it