Page 1 of 2
Final's a Breeze
Posted:
Sat Feb 28, 2009 7:27 pmby JS SPORTS
Don't profess to know much about the World game but if what I just witnessed was worth a Red Card, then Matthew Breeze is on Merrick's Xmas card list with plenty of money inside the envelope!
Absolute f^cking bullsh*t
Re: Final's a Breeze
Posted:
Sat Feb 28, 2009 7:47 pmby JS SPORTS
There's another Yellow from Breeze, Christ, was he bashed when he was a child and now he's trying to get even?
Re: Final's a Breeze
Posted:
Sat Feb 28, 2009 7:54 pmby johntheclaret
Cockeyed Chook wrote:There's another Yellow from Breeze, Christ, was he bashed when he was a child and now he's trying to get even?
Pathetic decision. Absolutely no need. Nothing in it and AU already had the free.
I was just saying on the GF thread, that this is the 1st game I have seen this year in the A league, and the ref is poor. I thought they were bad in the UK but this is lower league quality stuff. Is h really the best ref in Aust ?
Re: Final's a Breeze
Posted:
Sat Feb 28, 2009 7:59 pmby JS SPORTS
johntheclaret wrote:Cockeyed Chook wrote:There's another Yellow from Breeze, Christ, was he bashed when he was a child and now he's trying to get even?
Pathetic decision. Absolutely no need. Nothing in it and AU already had the free.
I was just saying on the GF thread, that this is the 1st game I have seen this year in the A league, and the ref is poor. I thought they were bad in the UK but this is lower league quality stuff. Is h really the best ref in Aust ?
I even get the feeling that a couple of the Fox Sports commentators might, for the first time ever, disagree with the decision.
Has there ever been any thought given to a "referral system" upstairs for decisions such as that red card blunder?
Re: Final's a Breeze
Posted:
Sat Feb 28, 2009 8:05 pmby johntheclaret
We have that in the UK alrady Cockeyed.
Problem is, you can get a red card reversed but it does jacksh*t if you lose the game.
The ref has destroyed the game as a spectacle.
What makes it a shame is that the ref had already decided it was a yellow. He had already pulled the yelow out of his pocket. So what could the linesman possibly have seen that the ref didn't, to make him change his mind. The challenge was full on to the ref so he would have seen exactly what happened and I would hazzard a guess that the ref had a better view than the side on view the linesman had.
If the liner thought it was such a bad challenge then why didn't he raise his flag at the time ? It definitel looked like the linesman influenced the ref. P1ss poor imo.
Re: Final's a Breeze
Posted:
Sat Feb 28, 2009 9:13 pmby JS SPORTS
I am convinced that Ref Breeze and his cohorts are intimidated by Muscat to the extent they favour Melbourne at all times, I know jack sh*t about soccer but this is so obvious it ain't funny!
Re: Final's a Breeze
Posted:
Sat Feb 28, 2009 9:26 pmby Columbo
Cockeyed Chook wrote:johntheclaret wrote:Cockeyed Chook wrote:There's another Yellow from Breeze, Christ, was he bashed when he was a child and now he's trying to get even?
Pathetic decision. Absolutely no need. Nothing in it and AU already had the free.
I was just saying on the GF thread, that this is the 1st game I have seen this year in the A league, and the ref is poor. I thought they were bad in the UK but this is lower league quality stuff. Is h really the best ref in Aust ?
I even get the feeling that a couple of the Fox Sports commentators might, for the first time ever, disagree with the decision.
Has there ever been any thought given to a "referral system" upstairs for decisions such as that red card blunder?
Was it Slater the commentator tonight who said he had better be quiet before he said too much about the red card decision? Does that mean no negative comments about the refs is the go?
Re: Final's a Breeze
Posted:
Sat Feb 28, 2009 10:15 pmby Dirko
OK...I will ask Cristiano what the **** happened out there for his card. I'll see him in the next week or so, and will post his report.
But yep total Bullshit...
Re: Final's a Breeze
Posted:
Sat Feb 28, 2009 10:19 pmby goraw
Columbo wrote:Cockeyed Chook wrote:johntheclaret wrote:Cockeyed Chook wrote:There's another Yellow from Breeze, Christ, was he bashed when he was a child and now he's trying to get even?
Pathetic decision. Absolutely no need. Nothing in it and AU already had the free.
I was just saying on the GF thread, that this is the 1st game I have seen this year in the A league, and the ref is poor. I thought they were bad in the UK but this is lower league quality stuff. Is h really the best ref in Aust ?
yep it was him, but we had our chances. we should hold our heads high as we played a great game creating chances under duress, just failed to hit the back of the net with the few decent chances we had.
I even get the feeling that a couple of the Fox Sports commentators might, for the first time ever, disagree with the decision.
Has there ever been any thought given to a "referral system" upstairs for decisions such as that red card blunder?
Was it Slater the commentator tonight who said he had better be quiet before he said too much about the red card decision? Does that mean no negative comments about the refs is the go?
Re: Final's a Breeze
Posted:
Sat Feb 28, 2009 10:22 pmby Thiele
Why did Breeze go to his assiant he had a yellow card to go to give Christanio, the assiant Ref made him change his mind. Breeze is a joke. There should of been a penalty in the box when Oga was pushed
Re: Final's a Breeze
Posted:
Sun Mar 01, 2009 9:43 amby Wedgie
Im no AU fan as most know but that decision was an absolute disgrace and anyone involved with it be it the linesman or ref should be sacked.
To completely stuff a GF up with a decision that bad so early on is terrible, it wouldn't happen in football and it shows how far soccer is behind as a sport in this country when it comes to being taken serious.
I'm not sure what's happened in the last decade but refereeing was a lot better in the old NSL, I wonder WTF Donald Campbell thought of that decision last night.
Surely if there's any doubt give the guy the benefit of the doubt.
Still that's soccer, a bit of luck or one bad refereeing decision can stuff up the entire game.
Re: Final's a Breeze
Posted:
Sun Mar 01, 2009 9:50 amby Dirko
geez Wedgie, I agree with that !
That decision completely altered the game. IMO at that stage United were all over Melbourne. We had to then completely change the way we went about it.
How a linesman can over-rule the ref, when the ref had already pulled out the yellow is beyond me. Also the linesman would've been on the BLIND side. I think Muscat getting in his ear and the fact the claret was flowing made him change his mind also....
disgraceful refereeing all night......LIFT THE STANDARD FFA
Re: Final's a Breeze
Posted:
Sun Mar 01, 2009 9:58 amby Wedgie
Im in absolutely no doubt that because a bit of claret was spilt they changed the decision.
It'll get to the stage where soccer players will be like pro wrestlers and take a razor blade out in their shorts in the future to give themselves a little cut to sway the refs.
I'm still absolutey appalled by the decision so I hate to think how die hard AU fans feel about it.
Re: Final's a Breeze
Posted:
Sun Mar 01, 2009 10:09 amby dinglinga
lets not vent all our fury at matthew breeze... he was going to issue a yellow card for the incident but then was called over by the linesman ( matthew cream who is from SA). this little fu&*er explained what he saw and therefore the red card came out ....thanks to the little fu$%ker from south australia.
hope he has a seat next to sasha on the way back to adelaide..
Re: Final's a Breeze
Posted:
Sun Mar 01, 2009 10:50 amby JS SPORTS
Columbo wrote:Cockeyed Chook wrote:johntheclaret wrote:Cockeyed Chook wrote:There's another Yellow from Breeze, Christ, was he bashed when he was a child and now he's trying to get even?
Pathetic decision. Absolutely no need. Nothing in it and AU already had the free.
I was just saying on the GF thread, that this is the 1st game I have seen this year in the A league, and the ref is poor. I thought they were bad in the UK but this is lower league quality stuff. Is h really the best ref in Aust ?
I even get the feeling that a couple of the Fox Sports commentators might, for the first time ever, disagree with the decision.
Has there ever been any thought given to a "referral system" upstairs for decisions such as that red card blunder?
Was it Slater the commentator tonight who said he had better be quiet before he said too much about the red card decision? Does that mean no negative comments about the refs is the go?
You got that right!
Re: Final's a Breeze
Posted:
Sun Mar 01, 2009 10:54 amby JS SPORTS
dinglinga wrote:lets not vent all our fury at matthew breeze... he was going to issue a yellow card for the incident but then was called over by the linesman ( matthew cream who is from SA). this little fu&*er explained what he saw and therefore the red card came out ....thanks to the little fu$%ker from south australia.
hope he has a seat next to sasha on the way back to adelaide..
Surely the main man has the final say!
Even more reason to bring in the "referral system" of going to the replay. It's available so FFS use it to keep the game away from p^ss poor decisions whether made by the ref or a linesman who's not quite good enough to be a ref.
Re: Final's a Breeze
Posted:
Sun Mar 01, 2009 11:48 amby Thiele
Breeze has a facebook page
Re: Final's a Breeze
Posted:
Sun Mar 01, 2009 2:05 pmby Mic
Makes me thankful I follow Aussie Rules (AFL excluded eg,
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vRRK752t ... -fresh+div) closely and not soccer.
Re: Final's a Breeze
Posted:
Mon Mar 02, 2009 5:44 amby Thiele
SJABC wrote:OK...I will ask Cristiano what the f*** happened out there for his card. I'll see him in the next week or so, and will post his report.
But yep total Bullshit...
Apparently Cristiano was a dead man walking
http://www.news.com.au/adelaidenow/stor ... 01,00.html
Re: Final's a Breeze
Posted:
Mon Mar 02, 2009 9:34 amby JK
I've been thinking about this a bit since it happened, and I reckon it's possible the Ref had some pre-meditated plans if previous protagonists Christiano and Vargas clashed at some stage.
Later on there was a one footed studs up challenge (granted the ball was in the vicinity) far more worthy of a Red Card than Christiano's was.
Must admit, I can't recall being prouder of the Reds ... I know you can't accept defeat, but man they really gave it a shake with a very brave performance.