1st Semi Final: Glenelg v Eagles Post Game Reviews

[Mickyj]

Maybe it was that incident, and both mickyj and bayman got the player wrong?

after watching the replay, sorry i was wrong, it was bode

Well there you go me and Bayman are both wrong and dutchy I am sorry I doubted you

[spell_check]

show me where i said grima didnt try hard
the fact remains he along with many others havnt performed when it gets to the real season
can someone post finals played goals scored in finals for t.grima i would think average of less than 1 goal per final

2008 2nd Semi: 2.1
2008 Preliminary: 3.0
2008 Grand: 1.2
2009 2nd Semi: 0.0
2009 Preliminary: 0.4
2010 Qualifying: 1.1
2010 1st Semi: 1.1
Total: 8.9

[CENTURION]

show me where i said grima didnt try hard
the fact remains he along with many others havnt performed when it gets to the real season
can someone post finals played goals scored in finals for t.grima i would think average of less than 1 goal per final

2008 2nd Semi: 2.1
2008 Preliminary: 3.0
2008 Grand: 1.2
2009 2nd Semi: 0.0
2009 Preliminary: 0.4
2010 Qualifying: 1.1
2010 1st Semi: 1.1
Total: 8.9

gun....

[CENTURION]

sack Grima, not Mickan!

[Aerie]

show me where i said grima didnt try hard
the fact remains he along with many others havnt performed when it gets to the real season
can someone post finals played goals scored in finals for t.grima i would think average of less than 1 goal per final

2008 2nd Semi: 2.1
2008 Preliminary: 3.0
2008 Grand: 1.2
2009 2nd Semi: 0.0
2009 Preliminary: 0.4
2010 Qualifying: 1.1
2010 1st Semi: 1.1
Total: 8.9

gun....

Well, he's no Fergus Watts...

[Mickyj]

show me where i said grima didnt try hard
the fact remains he along with many others havnt performed when it gets to the real season
can someone post finals played goals scored in finals for t.grima i would think average of less than 1 goal per final

2008 2nd Semi: 2.1
2008 Preliminary: 3.0
2008 Grand: 1.2
2009 2nd Semi: 0.0
2009 Preliminary: 0.4
2010 Qualifying: 1.1
2010 1st Semi: 1.1
Total: 8.9

gun....

Well, he's no Fergus Watts...

Ah yes Fergus Watts sat in the watts pocket at footy park sunday .The same pocket we watched him kick 10 against North

[cje]

thanks spelly
bugger me his average is over 1 goal per final i still say he is overated


serious question
what do non glenelg supporters think of t. grima
dud or gun

[Royal City]

thanks spelly
bugger me his average is over 1 goal per final i still say he is overated


serious question
what do non glenelg supporters think of t. grima
dud or gun

Todd Grima is the Leon Davis of the SANFL.

[CENTURION]

thanks spelly
bugger me his average is over 1 goal per final i still say he is overated


serious question
what do non glenelg supporters think of t. grima
dud or gun

Todd Grima is the Leon Davis of the SANFL.

and has the kicking action of Forrest Gump.

[Dirko]

serious question
what do non glenelg supporters think of t. grima
dud or gun

If half his team mates put in the effort that he puts in we'd be playing this week.

A forward is only as good as the delivery he gets from the midfield. And that was shit.

[CENTURION]

he cant be too bad if he wins the goalkicking award.

[Dutchy]

Exactly, Id be tipping it on Kirkby before Todd, as I said previously he was the one who broke Lewis's shoulder with his attacker on the ball

[therisingblues]

I imagine that Brant Chambers' goal kicking record in finals is also not so great.
Perhaps the specialist goal kicker is something that is too easy to shut down in the pressure of SANFL finals. I won't extend on those thoughts out of respect to Chambers and sitting here in front of my desk top in Japan, I am too far from the action to make better than an educated guess.
When was the last time that a specialist full-forward kicked more than say 4 goals in a final? And I mean specialist not a utility cunningly thrown forward by the coach to everyone's surprise.
(eg, Ellen and D Jarman in one of those Crows flags) I am guessing that it could be Schell for the Dogs, and I am basing that guess on the fact that he plays a number of positions and the Dogs have flexiblity as part of their game plan.

[whufc]

I imagine that Brant Chambers' goal kicking record in finals is also not so great.
Perhaps the specialist goal kicker is something that is too easy to shut down in the pressure of SANFL finals. I won't extend on those thoughts out of respect to Chambers and sitting here in front of my desk top in Japan, I am too far from the action to make better than an educated guess.
When was the last time that a specialist full-forward kicked more than say 4 goals in a final? And I mean specialist not a utility cunningly thrown forward by the coach to everyone's surprise.
(eg, Ellen and D Jarman in one of those Crows flags) I am guessing that it could be Schell for the Dogs, and I am basing that guess on the fact that he plays a number of positions and the Dogs have flexiblity as part of their game plan.

great point mate, i think your spot on the money.

That leads me to ask Spelly,

can you come up with a list of Central goalscorers in the finals since 2000, think you will find it is very much dominated by the smaller type players except for Schell

[Big Phil]

From memory, Daniel Schell kicked 6 in the record breaking win against the Eagles in 2004, that would have been the biggest haul if memory serves correct...

[birdmanptr]

show me where i said grima didnt try hard
the fact remains he along with many others havnt performed when it gets to the real season
can someone post finals played goals scored in finals for t.grima i would think average of less than 1 goal per final

2008 2nd Semi: 2.1
2008 Preliminary: 3.0
2008 Grand: 1.2
2009 2nd Semi: 0.0
2009 Preliminary: 0.4
2010 Qualifying: 1.1
2010 1st Semi: 1.1
Total: 8.9

Thats not bad for a backman...........wait whats that hes a forward shyyyyyyytttttttteeeeeeeeeeeeeeee

[Big Phil]

Here you go whufc...

_________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

In the 2000 Grand Final:

Central kicked 8 goals:

S.Dew, D.Healy 3, K.Ford, J.Gowans 1

_________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________


In the 2001 Grand Final:

Central kicked 10 goals:

D.Healy 3, K.Ford, S.McArdle 2, C.Gowans, S.Arnott, P.Scoullar 1


_________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________


In the 2003 Grand Final:

Central kicked 17 goals:

E.Sansbury 5, J.Gowans, C.Gowans, R.Cochrane, M.Slade 2, D.Schell, H.Hopwood, N.Steinberner, B.Guerra 1


_________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________


In the 2004 Grand Final:

Central kicked 23 goals:

D.Schell 6, D.Healy 5, L.Cowan, N.Steinberner, S.Arnott 2, T.Hay, P.Scoullar, E.Ware, J.Gowans, M.Bello, P.Thomas 1


________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________


In the 2005 Grand Final:

Central kicked 15 goals:

D.Schell 4, C.Gowans 3, D.Healy, L.Cowan 2, L.McCabe, M.Bello, H.Hopwood, S.Hurn 1


_________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________


In the 2007 Grand Final:

Central kicked 16 goals:

I.Callinan 4, A.Obst, D.Havelberg, J.Gowans, S.Dutschke 2, C.Gowans, A.Hayes, R.Cochrane 1


_________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________


In the 2008 Grand Final:

Central kicked 17 goals:

M.Westhoff 3, D.Schell , S.Dutschke, B.O'Hara 2, J.Gowans, I.Callinan, M.Slade, T.Goodrem, C. Gowans, McCabe, O'Sullivan, Mackenzie 1


_________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________


In the 2009 Grand Final:

Central kicked 13 goals:

E.Sansbury 4, D.Schell 2, J.Gowans, S.Dutschke, D.Havelberg, C.O’Sullivan, I.Callinan, M.Slade, C.Gowans 1


_________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________


Top 5 Goal Kicking leaderboard in Central's Premierships:

D.Schell 15, D.Healy 13, E.Sansbury 9, C.Gowans 9, J.Gowans 8

[whufc]

Cheers big phil,

i think 6th and 7th would be Callinan and Dutschke so it probably does show a bit of patter there, with Daniel Schell being the only tall key forward in the top 7

[spell_check]

Since 2000, with games on the left, then goals and behinds.

Code: Select all

Daniel   Schell   19   43   21
James   Gowans   25   25   11
Chris   Gowans   25   24   18
Daniel   Healy   12   19   13
Eddie   Sansbury   6   18   4
Ian   Callinan   7   14   11
Stuart   Dew   3   11   3
Chad   O'Sullivan   11   11   10
Luke   Cowan   9   10   7
Sam   McArdle   5   10   2
Matthew   Slade   23   10   8
Daniel   Havelberg   6   9   4
Simon   Arnott   10   8   3
Marco   Bello   13   8   12
Nathan   Steinberner   11   8   5
Scott   Dutschke   9   6   7
Rick   MacGowan   7   6   3
Luke   McCabe   8   6   4
Michael   Stevens   7   6   8
Elijah   Ware   10   6   2
Kynan   Ford   6   5   4
Andrew   Hayes   8   5   0
Daniel   Hulm   3   5   3
Brayden   O'Hara   7   5   4
Richard   Cochrane   17   4   3
Alan   Obst   2   4   3
Leigh   Westhoff   5   4   1
Matthew   Westhoff   3   4   5
Trent   Goodrem   7   3   0
Jason   Mackenzie   17   3   3
Yves   Sibenaler   20   3   4
Daniel   Stevens   5   3   4
Paul   Thomas   16   3   3
Damien   Arnold   8   2   0
Stuart   Cochrane   7   2   1
Brent   Guerra   7   2   5
Heath   Hopwood   13   2   1
Paul   Scoullar   12   2   2
Lee   Spurr   4   2   1
Ryan   Williams   7   2   2
James   Boyd   1   1   1
Brad   Currie   8   1   0
Jonathon   Giles   6   1   2
Quinton   Graham   14   1   0
Jack   Gunston   1   1   0
Tyson   Hay   10   1   1
Shannon   Hurn   3   1   1
Martin   McKinnon   2   1   0
Radlee   Moller   3   1   0
Kane   Officer   1   1   0
Justin   Westhoff   2   1   1
Adrian   Wilson   3   1   0

[spell_check]

I imagine that Brant Chambers' goal kicking record in finals is also not so great.
Perhaps the specialist goal kicker is something that is too easy to shut down in the pressure of SANFL finals. I won't extend on those thoughts out of respect to Chambers and sitting here in front of my desk top in Japan, I am too far from the action to make better than an educated guess.
When was the last time that a specialist full-forward kicked more than say 4 goals in a final? And I mean specialist not a utility cunningly thrown forward by the coach to everyone's surprise.
(eg, Ellen and D Jarman in one of those Crows flags) I am guessing that it could be Schell for the Dogs, and I am basing that guess on the fact that he plays a number of positions and the Dogs have flexiblity as part of their game plan.

Taylor Walker kicked 7 in the 2008 Elimination Final.