Ashes 4th test Boxing Day - Melbourne Discussion

[locky801]

3/135 at tea

im picking 4/255 at stumps

[mal]

FFS, get a sub who can actually field

Before the end of the days play I hope you post something intelligent
That would make up for this post

[whufc]

I would like to see a rule like in the NFL where if a player lands both feet inside the boundary then it's a fair catch

[mal]

I think a bloke with a sombrero 3 rows back eventually caught it ...

Before the end of the days play, I hope you post something intelligent
That would make up for this post

[dedja]

Has AH hijacked your account?

[mal]

Dedja
Coulter Nile did most things right when trying to catch that ball
It was a good enough effort , in my opinion
Does not deserve to be rubbished by you or anyone else for that effort

[Jim05]

Dedja
Coulter Nile did most things right when trying to catch that ball
It was a good enough effort , in my opinion
Does not deserve to be rubbished by you or anyone else for that effort

Sorry Mal I disagree.
I would think that nearly every other player out there would of taken that catch. Lyon and Harris in particular have taken some rippers at fine leg.
Coulter-Nile positioned himself poorly and paid the price

[dedja]

I've stated my opinion and you have stated yours ... It's still a free country isn't it?

[whufc]

Dedja
Coulter Nile did most things right when trying to catch that ball
It was a good enough effort , in my opinion
Does not deserve to be rubbished by you or anyone else for that effort

Sorry Mal I disagree.
I would think that nearly every other player out there would of taken that catch. Lyon and Harris in particular have taken some rippers at fine leg.
Coulter-Nile positioned himself poorly and paid the price

I don't think Lyon and Harris have taken any of their catches when they have been going backwards.

The problem was his starting position 15m in from the boundary which I would guess is where Clarke and Harris placed him

He did 99% of things right, got there caught it, got off the ground from the rope unfortunately all his body weight was heading towards the boundary, unfortunately he stuffed the throw back in

[dedja]

Regardless of what could have happened, he didn't legally complete the catch and figjam is still out there ... could be very costly.

[Squids]

He bowls to the left he bowls to the right

[whufc]

Regardless of what could have happened, he didn't legally complete the catch and figjam is still out there ... could be very costly.

Agree but doesn't mean it was a shit effort and your comment about a sub fielder who can field is so far off the mark considering his widely accepted by cricket experts as one of the most athletic and best fielders in oz currently.

Ps as i type Ian Chappell made the exact comments I made that's good enough for me

[dedja]

Are you and mal in a relationship?

[locky801]

Johnson bowling porridge

[whufc]

Are you and mal in a relationship?

R u and jim in a relationship because u have the same opinion.

[dedja]

He follows teams that are either salary cap drug cheats ... wouldn't touch him with a barge pole

[whufc]

He follows teams that are either salary cap drug cheats ... wouldn't touch him with a barge pole

Lol

[Jim05]

Time for the Blonde Don to send down a few, has troubled Bell in the past. With Watto down need to get a few overs from elsewhere

[Jim05]

He follows teams that are either salary cap drug cheats ... wouldn't touch him with a barge pole

At Essendon we do both!
No point doing something half-arsed

[dedja]

Need a KP brain explosion soon ...