2017 All Australian

[Booney]

Reckon the Bont got in purely due to hype. He was largely ordinary this year from what I saw.

How does Bont, Selwood and Treloar get a nom but Duncan doesn't?

regards,

REB

You really need to be told why Selwood gets a gig?

[Senor Moto Gadili]

I think the number of games you play should be a factor as to whether you get picked in the final 22. Toby Greene only played 16 games, Josh Kennedy (WCE) 17 games and Joel Selwood and Michael Hibberd only played 18 games. How can Toby Greene make the final 22 if he has missed more than a quarter of the season? I'm not convinced the others have done enough in less games to get selected.

[David Brent]

I think the number of games you play should be a factor as to whether you get picked in the final 22. Toby Greene only played 16 games, Josh Kennedy (WCE) 17 games and Joel Selwood and Michael Hibberd only played 18 games. How can Toby Greene make the final 22 if he has missed more than a quarter of the season? I'm not convinced the others have done enough in less games to get selected.

If Buddy hadn't kicked a bag last week Kennedy would have won the Coleman despite only playing 17 games. Pretty harsh to leave him out on that basis...?

[hollywood7477]

I read on social media that Kennedy, McGovern and Yeo have flown to Melbourne. You would think all 3 would be in the side if thats the case

[Brodlach]

All 40 would have gone surely

[hollywood7477]

All 40 would have gone surely

Nah they would have you fly from WA just to be told bad lluck you didn t make it

[Senor Moto Gadili]

I think the number of games you play should be a factor as to whether you get picked in the final 22. Toby Greene only played 16 games, Josh Kennedy (WCE) 17 games and Joel Selwood and Michael Hibberd only played 18 games. How can Toby Greene make the final 22 if he has missed more than a quarter of the season? I'm not convinced the others have done enough in less games to get selected.

If Buddy hadn't kicked a bag last week Kennedy would have won the Coleman despite only playing 17 games. Pretty harsh to leave him out on that basis...?

I think Kennedy is fighting for Full Forward with Ben Brown. So does Kennedy's 65 goals in 17 games for a top 8 team that won 12 games warrant his selection over Ben Brown's 63 goals in 22 games for a team that finished 15th and won half as many games. I reckon Ben Brown will get it. We'll see.

[The Dark Knight]

Full back line-
Hibbard, Rance, McGovern

[The Dark Knight]

Half back line
Laird, Hurley, Docherty

[Brodlach]

Lairdy!!!!!

[hollywood7477]

Half back line
Laird, Hurley, Docherty

What's with Mark Robinson love affair with Zac Toohey. He didn't be make it get over it

[The Dark Knight]

Centre line-
Kelly, Martin, Merrett

[carey]

Paddy.

Well deserved.

[The Dark Knight]

Midfield
Ryder, Dangerfield, Mitchell

[Spargo]

Cameron Ling, f#ck me he is tedious
One of the main reasons I avoid channel 7's coverage
Now the flog's on Fox tonight

[Jim05]

They will have to find a spot for Selwood, his jacket is fitted before the season starts

[bertiebeatle]

Yeah Paddy!

[carey]

Cameron Ling, f#ck me he is tedious
One of the main reasons I avoid channel 7's coverage
Now the flog's on Fox tonight

Spot on mate.

Flog

[Brodlach]

Paddy.

Well deserved.

Morrell is going to swarm all over this

[The Dark Knight]

How does Luke Darcy worm his way into the selection panel??