Adelaide Footy League Division 2 - 2018

[LaughingKookaburra]

Saw it on the news. Clearly an intentional punch to the face. Not worth 8 weeks though. Unlucky for SN it was on video. Would have got 2 max in the SFL probably a reprimand.

It's not a bad issue to have mate. We all have to go to work on Monday. Football incidents occur but striking people has never been an acceptable part of the game.

[Senor Moto Gadili]

Saw it on the news. Clearly an intentional punch to the face. Not worth 8 weeks though. Unlucky for SN it was on video. Would have got 2 max in the SFL probably a reprimand.

So you think an intentional strike to the head with high impact should range from reprimand to 2 weeks? Seriously. I think the Adelaide FL have got it right at 8 to 10 weeks.

[Dutchy]

Interesting that they say they would welcome them back for 2019 season, is a few months going to change a few years of problems?

[Brodlach]

Interesting that they say they would welcome them back for 2019 season, is a few months going to change a few years of problems?

That’s not what they said

“The SNFC is welcome to re-apply for Affiliation with The League in season 2019.”


Doesn’t mean they will be allowed back but can just re apply. AdFl can say ‘no’

[Dutchy]

OK so what could change in 3-4 months that will allow them back in?

[heater31]

OK so what could change in 3-4 months that will allow them back in?

Well taking points off them for the last 3 seasons has done nothing to curb the behavior.....the application to be readmitted is looking very shakey I would say!

[Lightning McQueen]

The question about clearances is irrelevant for most of you i would have thought? Why would you want any of these uncontrollable players at your club? Or is it just the SN jumper that makes them uncontrollable?

I wouldn't go tarnishing the whole place mate, there are many good people out there and the club has done some wonderful things for the community over the years.

[The Bedge]

The Adelaide Footy League has also deregistered Stengle — the league’s division one best and fairest in 2011 — for exceeding its 12-game suspension threshold.

Last night’s ban was Stengle’s first in the Adelaide Footy League but he received a six-match suspension for striking while playing for Central District’s reserves in 2005.

Stengle can move to another competition because he has not reached the 16-game threshold of football’s national deregistration policy that has been adopted by the SANFL and many country leagues..

I understand i'm the minority here, but is it time the league revisited either its 12 game threshold, or the severity of its suspensions? This is a good example of how severe it is - a player who hasn't received a suspension for 13yrs, who copped his suspension in the reserves of league footy - completely different competition - a player who has won a league medal and been an compliant member of the competition is now deregistered following one single incident in the comp.. seems bit extreme to me.

Strangely enough, suspensions don't carry over to AFL, and there is no threshold, but if they come back from those levels their suspensions count - it's stupid. AFL and SANFL suspensions shouldn't count in ammo footy, and if they do then they should also count at those levels.

[The Bedge]

It has begun..

Salisbury North Hills Football League SA Bingos, Dylan Pending 2018-06-21
Salisbury North Barossa Light and Gawler Football Association Cochrane, Joel Pending 2018-06-21
Salisbury North River Murray Football League Haseldine, Toby Pending 2018-06-21
Salisbury North Barossa Light and Gawler Football Association Hay, Callum Pending 2018-06-21
Salisbury North Barossa Light and Gawler Football Association Hay, Joseph Pending 2018-06-21
Salisbury North Hills Football League SA Miller, Daniel Pending 2018-06-21
Salisbury North Kilburn Owen, Jharien Pending 2018-06-21
Salisbury North West Croydon Wiles, Ben Pending 2018-06-21

[Lightning McQueen]

The Adelaide Footy League has also deregistered Stengle — the league’s division one best and fairest in 2011 — for exceeding its 12-game suspension threshold.

Last night’s ban was Stengle’s first in the Adelaide Footy League but he received a six-match suspension for striking while playing for Central District’s reserves in 2005.

Stengle can move to another competition because he has not reached the 16-game threshold of football’s national deregistration policy that has been adopted by the SANFL and many country leagues..

I understand i'm the minority here, but is it time the league revisited either its 12 game threshold, or the severity of its suspensions? This is a good example of how severe it is - a player who hasn't received a suspension for 13yrs, who copped his suspension in the reserves of league footy - completely different competition - a player who has won a league medal and been an compliant member of the competition is now deregistered following one single incident in the comp.. seems bit extreme to me.

Strangely enough, suspensions don't carry over to AFL, and there is no threshold, but if they come back from those levels their suspensions count - it's stupid. AFL and SANFL suspensions shouldn't count in ammo footy, and if they do then they should also count at those levels.

The AFL bit gets me, they get suspended for stupid misdemeanours that shouldn't warrant suspensions, there wouldn't be many 150+ game players that haven't been suspended at one stage or another, it's no reflection on their fairness though.

[Lightning McQueen]

It has begun..

Salisbury North Hills Football League SA Bingos, Dylan Pending 2018-06-21
Salisbury North Barossa Light and Gawler Football Association Cochrane, Joel Pending 2018-06-21
Salisbury North River Murray Football League Haseldine, Toby Pending 2018-06-21
Salisbury North Barossa Light and Gawler Football Association Hay, Callum Pending 2018-06-21
Salisbury North Barossa Light and Gawler Football Association Hay, Joseph Pending 2018-06-21
Salisbury North Hills Football League SA Miller, Daniel Pending 2018-06-21
Salisbury North Kilburn Owen, Jharien Pending 2018-06-21
Salisbury North West Croydon Wiles, Ben Pending 2018-06-21

Anyone know where Callum is heading? Willaston perhaps? Thought he may end up at Virginia, they could use him right now.

[jo172]

The Adelaide Footy League has also deregistered Stengle — the league’s division one best and fairest in 2011 — for exceeding its 12-game suspension threshold.

Last night’s ban was Stengle’s first in the Adelaide Footy League but he received a six-match suspension for striking while playing for Central District’s reserves in 2005.

Stengle can move to another competition because he has not reached the 16-game threshold of football’s national deregistration policy that has been adopted by the SANFL and many country leagues..

I understand i'm the minority here, but is it time the league revisited either its 12 game threshold, or the severity of its suspensions? This is a good example of how severe it is - a player who hasn't received a suspension for 13yrs, who copped his suspension in the reserves of league footy - completely different competition - a player who has won a league medal and been an compliant member of the competition is now deregistered following one single incident in the comp.. seems bit extreme to me.

Strangely enough, suspensions don't carry over to AFL, and there is no threshold, but if they come back from those levels their suspensions count - it's stupid. AFL and SANFL suspensions shouldn't count in ammo footy, and if they do then they should also count at those levels.

The AFL bit gets me, they get suspended for stupid misdemeanours that shouldn't warrant suspensions, there wouldn't be many 150+ game players that haven't been suspended at one stage or another, it's no reflection on their fairness though.

Pretty sure AFL suspensions count for half towards national deregistration.

Have to be a pretty bad AFL player to get done for 32 weeks...

[Booney]

OK so what could change in 3-4 months that will allow them back in?

I guess the same as Rosewater did. Demonstrate that the right people have been put into the right roles within the club, that the leaders on and off field have been able to get the playing group to acknowledge the wrong doings of the past and show the SAAFL that everyone at the club is determined to change their reputation within the league.

It can be done.

[The Bedge]

Pretty sure AFL suspensions count for half towards national deregistration.

Have to be a pretty bad AFL player to get done for 32 weeks...

So if a player gets 2x AFL games suspension, when they return to community footy it's only listed as 1 game on their record?

[Lightning McQueen]

Pretty sure AFL suspensions count for half towards national deregistration.

Have to be a pretty bad AFL player to get done for 32 weeks...

Bazza?

[Bombers4EVA]

Wolves are well and truly circling as we speak. Phones are running hot.

SN are going to BL&G next year I’m lead to believe. Time to get a fence and some netball courts!

Tell me this. If a club gets kicked out of the league because of the issues thats happened in the present and the past. And I know it's only due to a few individuals who cause these issues. Then how is it that the rest of the players can easily be cleared to play for other clubs? I know that most of the players shouldn't be punished as the result of a few. But the SAAFL has punished the club as a whole.

[jo172]

Pretty sure AFL suspensions count for half towards national deregistration.

Have to be a pretty bad AFL player to get done for 32 weeks...

Bazza?

Precisely an example of a blokes AFL suspensions which were hardly trifling

[Senor Moto Gadili]

Wolves are well and truly circling as we speak. Phones are running hot.

SN are going to BL&G next year I’m lead to believe. Time to get a fence and some netball courts!

Tell me this. If a club gets kicked out of the league because of the issues thats happened in the present and the past. And I know it's only due to a few individuals who cause these issues. Then how is it that the rest of the players can easily be cleared to play for other clubs? I know that most of the players shouldn't be punished as the result of a few. But the SAAFL has punished the club as a whole.

Haven't you answered your own question? Adelaide FL have punished the club for ongoing indiscretions and one player for an indiscretion. The other players should not be punished. They should be able to move to another club before the June 30 deadline. Surely you are not suggesting all of the Salisbury North players should be made to sit out the remainder of the 2018 season?

[Lightning McQueen]

Wolves are well and truly circling as we speak. Phones are running hot.

SN are going to BL&G next year I’m lead to believe. Time to get a fence and some netball courts!

Tell me this. If a club gets kicked out of the league because of the issues thats happened in the present and the past. And I know it's only due to a few individuals who cause these issues. Then how is it that the rest of the players can easily be cleared to play for other clubs? I know that most of the players shouldn't be punished as the result of a few. But the SAAFL has punished the club as a whole.

Did you read that to yourself before you posted it?

[Fricky]

BOMBER2.png (354.34 KiB) Viewed 2192 times