JK wrote:Bandit wrote:I dont think any cat fans will begrudge kelly for seeking a trade to be closer to family, he gave his all during his time at geelong especially this year when he could have sooked it up. If however he is only willing to deal with WCE despite Freo (potentially) having a much better deal then thats poor form from kelly and geelong should remind him that gold coast have pre season draft pick #1.
Lucky that firm stance wasn't applied when Gaz was trying to find his way home, or Jack Steven
It seems to ch age a bit depending on the yes involved. Look at Dangerfield to Geelong, Polec to Port, Judd to Carton. It's all the same, now Kelly to West Coast oohhh that's different it should either WA team.
Come on, would you want to go to Fremantle and that shit farm? Probably not.
But in saying all of that my opinion on this matter is that if a player wants to get to his home state for family reason such as a Dangerfield or Judd or Kelly, then yes it should be home state and a bidding war should take place.
As much as bum crack comes on here and is super arrogant (assuming he logs in as the right user for this one) Geelong will deal with West Coast and it will get done. But that doesn't change the fact that the system really is garbage that a player can nominate a team straight up.
Read my reply. It is directed at you because you have double standards