2023 Adelaide Footy League - Division 2

[jake the snake]

One of the season permits

[beef]

Jamie Jones zero points??

[The Bedge]

Oh dear. Lonaragan and Jones. Bad miss.

[The Dark Knight]

Oh dear. Lonaragan and Jones. Bad miss.

How many points should Loneragen be? Played at South Adelaide in 2021?

[jo172]

Oh dear. Lonaragan and Jones. Bad miss.

How many points should Loneragen be? Played at South Adelaide in 2021?

3 I would have thought?

[jo172]

Suppose you’re better off getting stung in round 4 than round 15.

Can still get back to where they were

[The Bedge]

Suppose you’re better off getting stung in round 4 than round 15.

Can still get back to where they were

Was it Kilburn back in around 2013 who had similar? Then went on a massive heater and won the flag after being stripped off all their points?

[Footy Chick]

Suppose you’re better off getting stung in round 4 than round 15.

Can still get back to where they were

Was it Kilburn back in around 2013 who had similar? Then went on a massive heater and won the flag after being stripped off all their points?

And also Salisbury West in 2006 after starting the year on minus points as part of the previous years' GF penalty(Not APPS related)

From (my really bad) memory, it was -6 they started on

[jo172]

Suppose you’re better off getting stung in round 4 than round 15.

Can still get back to where they were

Was it Kilburn back in around 2013 who had similar? Then went on a massive heater and won the flag after being stripped off all their points?

Might have been earlier, feel like PNU was in that div, maybe 2012?

[jo172]

Suppose you’re better off getting stung in round 4 than round 15.

Can still get back to where they were

Was it Kilburn back in around 2013 who had similar? Then went on a massive heater and won the flag after being stripped off all their points?

And also Salisbury West in 2006 after starting the year on minus points as part of the previous years' GF penalty(Not APPS related)

From (my really bad) memory, it was -6 they started on

Hard to picture but wonder what the penalty would be now for that.

First game of amateur footy I ever saw that one as an innocent u16

[beef]

Play HQ ladder showing Salisbury North now 1-3 and all scores wiped for first 3 rounds

[jo172]

I realise there's likely no "good" way to do it, but always thought the wiping of the scores a bit problematic in terms of how it adjusts percentages

[Pag]

I realise there's likely no "good" way to do it, but always thought the wiping of the scores a bit problematic in terms of how it adjusts percentages

Agreed. Already gives a handy leg up to the the teams that were 'lucky' enough to cop them on those particular weeks. Give them the points, fair enough, but not the extra percentage. Uni jumped 11% and Athelstone 9%, almost an extra win if they land equal on points with someone comes finals time.

[beef]

I realise there's likely no "good" way to do it, but always thought the wiping of the scores a bit problematic in terms of how it adjusts percentages

Agreed. Already gives a handy leg up to the the teams that were 'lucky' enough to cop them on those particular weeks. Give them the points, fair enough, but not the extra percentage. Uni jumped 11% and Athelstone 9%, almost an extra win if they land equal on points with someone comes finals time.

Dont worry mate, GG will still be 17-1 and in div 1 next year with more AFL players, a bit of % to a couple teams wont matter.

[Pag]

I realise there's likely no "good" way to do it, but always thought the wiping of the scores a bit problematic in terms of how it adjusts percentages

Agreed. Already gives a handy leg up to the the teams that were 'lucky' enough to cop them on those particular weeks. Give them the points, fair enough, but not the extra percentage. Uni jumped 11% and Athelstone 9%, almost an extra win if they land equal on points with someone comes finals time.

Dont worry mate, GG will still be 17-1 and in div 1 next year with more AFL players, a bit of % to a couple teams wont matter.

Fairly sure I didn't mention GG? Would've thought any of PNU, GG, PHOS, Towns, etc would be disadvantaged a bit now.

Havens may be the only ones not affected directly at this stage.

[The Bedge]

Havens & Henley suffer - they fall deeper into the relegation zone with ROCs getting a win they didn’t deserve.

[Pag]

Havens & Henley suffer - they fall deeper into the relegation zone with ROCs getting a win they didn’t deserve.

Fair point.

[Jimmy_041]

Adelaide Footy League club Salisbury North docked premiership points

An Adelaide Footy League club has been docked almost all of its accrued premiership points so far this season after breaching the approved player points system.

Daniel Renfrey
May 15, 2023 - 5:04PM
The Messenger

An Adelaide Footy League club has been stripped of almost all of its premiership points so far this season after breaching the approved player points system.

Salisbury North has been docked six premiership points and percentage from the first three weeks of the season after exceeding the player point limit – used to sign players – of 15.

The Adelaide Footy League last week became aware it needed to look at clubs’ points through an APPS audit conducted by the SA Community Football League.

The Hawks were found to have exceeded the 15-point limit.

In a letter to all division two clubs from the league, chief John Kernahan said the club had cooperated seamlessly to reach an outcome.

“The SNFC have paid a heavy price for a relatively innocuous oversight. But the SNFC have owned their part in this without question which has allowed us to collaborate with SANFL and draw this matter to a close citing absolute cooperation in their (SNFC) very transparent explanation of the breach,” Kernahan said.

“As a result, SNFC have been penalised the premiership points and percentage accrued from the first 3 weeks of the season and results have been amended reflecting a revised ladder. The potential for fines or availability of APPS points have been set aside due to the club’s cooperation.

“It is also opportune to flag from the outset that Audits of APPS values for all AdFL Clubs will continue by both SACFL and the AdFL as matter of priority.”

The points certain players (AFL, SANFL, affiliated amateur league club etc) are worth is stipulated under the current Approved Player Points System.

Clubs and players also need to present a signed declaration to the league including a player’s playing history and an assessment of the player points rating of that player calculated under the APPS.

The development comes just after division three club Gaza was investigated for alleged breaches of the salary cap.

Salisbury North was previously undefeated this season, but is now 1-3 and sits third bottom

[Brodlach]

Why was the discussion on this removed? It was very civil.


Or am I going nuts?

[The Bedge]

Why was the discussion on this removed? It was very civil.


Or am I going nuts?

I can't see anything removed?