SAAFL Div 6 2008

[Trinity]

I have an "ear-ie" feeling this argument is going to go on forever..damn it..where's Barta

sorry i will quit complaining bout it it doesnt affect me anymore anyway just thought i would try get some answers from others but im more confused then when i started
quote]
Good option Trinity. Good luck next year.

Well im hoping the B Grade have a better chance next year now HV going up I have to say i really wanted your A's to win yesterday just so that Valley B's go up!

[hawkseye]

Careful Trinity Non Observer fires up pretty quick

[Trinity]

trinity wrote......while you guys could play #29 that had played only (4) A Grade games and (1) B Grade game for the year, and another #23 (3) A Grade and (3) B Grade, another #38 (4) A Grade and (2) B Grade and also #40 (10) A Grade (2) B Grade. How is that fair? I think players should be allowed to go up in finals ........i think youll find that none of these guys played in the A s the following week,,more than likely played B s again...is this right

Im not sure if they played again in the B's i know they didnt play play A Grade. My question about Brown just really came about because i know a few boys at Paralowie and what they had happen this week and also because it was the same thing the SAAFL told me on monday and when i checked CLG team sheet Friday A Brown was named on the team sheet and no permit on the SAAFL site was applied for? So just thought i would try and fish around for other peoples views on what the rules R or R NOT?

for the paralowie instance i think youll find its in the wording......player named in A team as a replacment hasnt played in 12 weeks.......also A brown didnt need to get a permit as the free interchange rule would apply as clg had the a s and b s participating in finals and browny had played the last 6 plus a final...no permit req.....

Yeh thats what i thought but SAAFL told me different. Who knows? anyway doesnt really matter to my team now anyway would just be nice if the SAAFL gave the right information to people.

[hawkseye]

I have an "ear-ie" feeling this argument is going to go on forever..damn it..where's Barta

That was gold and i was sober

[Trinity]

Careful Trinity Non Observer fires up pretty quick

If he is who i think he is i know ive heard his anger management skills at half time before!

[Trinity]

[quote="demonseye"][quote="Footy Chick"]I have an "ear-ie" feeling this argument is going to go on forever..damn it..where's Barta : quote]
That was gold and i was soberquote]

There would to be a few blokes (and maybe a few women) not feeling so good today from HV wouldnt there?

[hawkseye]

I have an "ear-ie" feeling this argument is going to go on forever..damn it..where's Barta : quote]
That was gold and i was soberquote]

There would to be a few blokes (and maybe a few women) not feeling so good today from HV wouldnt there?

Yep theres one in my household and its not me
Sunnys were the order of the day at the Cgrade today.

[Trinity]

They have to pay their players somehow. WOS may have the overpriced BBQ, CLG whack you $5 for a park when there's plenty of space on the street free of charge. Probably the most money to be made at an SAAFL final is to have a tracksuit levy on arrival.

CLG $5 for a park? I didnt pay to park there?

[Trinity]

I have an "ear-ie" feeling this argument is going to go on forever..damn it..where's Barta : quote]
That was gold and i was soberquote]

There would to be a few blokes (and maybe a few women) not feeling so good today from HV wouldnt there?

Yep theres one in my household and its not me
Sunnys were the order of the day at the Cgrade today.

yeh im hung over too, i was celebrating not having to play your B grade next year!

[Footy Chick]

Careful Trinity Non Observer fires up pretty quick

If he is who i think he is i know ive heard his anger management skills at half time before!

In 15 years I've never heard anything like it!

eg: You F&^%&* $*%&^( #&%&^@ (thumps wall) You $%#&%$^% %%^&*%^ $^%&#* (thumps wall)
For a minute there he was screaming with such a high pitched voice I thought one of the players had a hold of his balls..

Give credit where credit is due, he's obviously done some good work with this side over the past couple of years but that was a weeny bit over the top IMO

Charlie just went about his address through the whole thing in a very calm manner and didn't even blink to it... amazing..

[scottroo]

thats compairing chalk and cheese, hope valley won, of course there coach was calm, before you bad mouth paul lets wait for this weeks game

[Footy Chick]

thats compairing chalk and cheese, hope valley won, of course there coach was calm, before you bad mouth paul lets wait for this weeks game

I wasn't badmouthing him (if you read underneath I did say he had done some great work with CLG, perhaps you're picking and choosing what you read) and I haven't doomed anyone to failure, I merely stated a fact...I don't know how you guys put up with it.. and at the end of the day, did it help? NO..

[scottroo]

thats compairing chalk and cheese, hope valley won, of course there coach was calm, before you bad mouth paul lets wait for this weeks game

I wasn't badmouthing him (if you read underneath I did say he had done some great work with CLG, perhaps you're picking and choosing what you read) and I haven't doomed anyone to failure, I merely stated a fact...I don't know how you guys put up with it.. and at the end of the day, did it help? NO..

perhaps you didnt read all that i said? im stating that if the shoe was on the other foot and clg went through to the gf, paul would of been calm, hope valley lose and i dare say charlie wouldnt of been in the best of moods

[Trinity]

Careful Trinity Non Observer fires up pretty quick

If he is who i think he is i know ive heard his anger management skills at half time before!

In 15 years I've never heard anything like it!

eg: You F&^%&* $*%&^( #&%&^@ (thumps wall) You $%#&%$^% %%^&*%^ $^%&#* (thumps wall)
For a minute there he was screaming with such a high pitched voice I thought one of the players had a hold of his balls..

Give credit where credit is due, he's obviously done some good work with this side over the past couple of years but that was a weeny bit over the top IMO

Charlie just went about his address through the whole thing in a very calm manner and didn't even blink to it... amazing..

Yeh my boys thought i yell allot i wish i could have sat them in one of his half time addresses so they could witness what yelling and abuse really is

weeny bit over the top IMO listening to him going off his tree, I would think only fired up the HV boys to want to win even more.

But your right CLG have had 2 good seasons so maybe i should give it a try next season?

[Footy Chick]

thats compairing chalk and cheese, hope valley won, of course there coach was calm, before you bad mouth paul lets wait for this weeks game

I wasn't badmouthing him (if you read underneath I did say he had done some great work with CLG, perhaps you're picking and choosing what you read) and I haven't doomed anyone to failure, I merely stated a fact...I don't know how you guys put up with it.. and at the end of the day, did it help? NO..

perhaps you didnt read all that i said? im stating that if the shoe was on the other foot and clg went through to the gf, paul would of been calm, hope valley lose and i dare say charlie wouldnt of been in the best of moods

Cant comment Scottroo, I was just the fill-in!

[scottroo]

anyway, big games at mortlock this week, tips?

[Trinity]

thats compairing chalk and cheese, hope valley won, of course there coach was calm, before you bad mouth paul lets wait for this weeks game

I wasn't badmouthing him (if you read underneath I did say he had done some great work with CLG, perhaps you're picking and choosing what you read) and I haven't doomed anyone to failure, I merely stated a fact...I don't know how you guys put up with it.. and at the end of the day, did it help? NO..

perhaps you didnt read all that i said? im stating that if the shoe was on the other foot and clg went through to the gf, paul would of been calm, hope valley lose and i dare say charlie wouldnt of been in the best of moods

He wasnt calm when we played you guys rd 17 and you guys were beating a 6th placed side????

Thought FC description was pretty tame, and quite low key compared to how some could have put it.

[observer]

[quote="Trinity"][quote="scottroo"][quote="Footy Chick"][quote="scottroo"]thats compairing chalk and cheese, hope valley won, of course there coach was calm, before you bad mouth paul lets wait for this weeks game[/quote]

I wasn't badmouthing him (if you read underneath I did say he had done some great work with CLG, perhaps you're picking and choosing what you read) and I haven't doomed anyone to failure, I merely stated a fact...I don't know how you guys put up with it.. and at the end of the day, did it help? NO..[/quote]

perhaps you didnt read all that i said? im stating that if the shoe was on the other foot and clg went through to the gf, paul would of been calm, hope valley lose and i dare say charlie wouldnt of been in the best of moods[/quote]

He wasnt calm when we played you guys rd 17 and you guys were beating a 6th placed side????

Thought FC description was pretty tame, and quite low key compared to how some could have put it.[/quote]

All trinity did in round 17 was try and bate CLG players didnt even provide a contest same old same old clg vs trinity a no contest read the scores of last five games clg vs trinity ..correct me if i am wrong dont think trinity As played finals ..thumping walls what a load of garbage Trinity ,if thats the worse u have heard maybe u should be helping the coach of the opals,

[hawkseye]

I wasn't badmouthing him (if you read underneath I did say he had done some great work with CLG, perhaps you're picking and choosing what you read) and I haven't doomed anyone to failure, I merely stated a fact...I don't know how you guys put up with it.. and at the end of the day, did it help? NO..

perhaps you didnt read all that i said? im stating that if the shoe was on the other foot and clg went through to the gf, paul would of been calm, hope valley lose and i dare say charlie wouldnt of been in the best of moods

He wasnt calm when we played you guys rd 17 and you guys were beating a 6th placed side????

Thought FC description was pretty tame, and quite low key compared to how some could have put it.

All trinity did in round 17 was try and bate CLG players didnt even provide a contest same old same old clg vs trinity a no contest read the scores of last five games clg vs trinity ..correct me if i am wrong dont think trinity As played finals ..thumping walls what a load of garbage Trinity ,if thats the worse u have heard maybe u should be helping the coach of the opals,

Non Observer check your facts again. It was footy chick commenting on thumping of walls not Trinity

[SteveStevens]

From the SAAFL newsletter:

Finals Eligibility
The whole point of having rules for finals eligibility is to make it as fair as possible.
The other point is that the rules can not possibly legislate for every situation and that is
why there is a permit committee to make interpretation and to rule on fairness. When a
club has 2 teams (eg A & B) in the finals, there is free interchange between those
teams just like a normal home and away match. When these 2 teams are in finals and
the higher graded team has a BYE, they must submit a team sheet. It is like a “frozen
in time” scenario. When they play a week apart, the team that plays later is frozen in
time to replicate the normal Saturday match when one team plays immediately after
the other.
Eg The A team has a BYE in the first week and the club wants to drop a number of it’s
A players to the B team that is playing. This is still the prerogative of the club but
these players are then ineligible to play in the A team the following week.
The other way of determining eligibility is by their games record ie. whether the player
has played most of his games in the division he seeks eligibility. In all situations when
unsure, check with the office or fill in a permit form.

Second bolded point lends itself to what Trinity has been saying IMO. Having said that, given that the likes of Brown and Maddocks played B Grade the week before the finals, I suppose they weren't necessarily been "dropped" to the Bs for the first final.

(First bolded point - seems that "free interchange" can only occur if both A and B team are playing in the same week)