by CUTTERMAN » Sun May 13, 2012 11:32 pm
by Pseudo » Mon May 14, 2012 12:07 am
by Tassie Blues » Mon May 14, 2012 12:28 am
by The Sleeping Giant » Mon May 14, 2012 1:04 am
by Grahaml » Mon May 14, 2012 1:24 am
Tassie Blues wrote:I think it’s something that has to happen for both AFL teams to become more competitive in AFL and player development. The way I see it is Power will have Magpies as reserves side that’s a no brainier. Crows will either need to have new side in SANFL taking it to a 10 team comp (no more 2 byes in the first 4 weeks of a season) or will use a current SANFL team as the reserves side.
If they go with a current SANFL side it couldn’t be Centrals or South due to distance from West Lakes so that leaves Glenelg, North, Norwood, Sturt, West and WWT. I’m not going to pick one but all are within 20km and about 30 min from West Lakes.
Some of the issue are going to be what happens when the crows/power take a young player from an SANFL club they would then change to a new AFL/SANFL club and if they don’t get on the main AFL list or they are not up to AFL standard do they keep playing for the AFL/SANFL club or go back to their original SANFL club. Also do the AFL/SANFL clubs have a SANFL salary cap? And is it the same or more than the other SANFL clubs? Does that cap include payment from playing AFL games?
I’m sure there are hundreds of other issues associated with this topic but I think it’s an interesting one.
by Sojourner » Mon May 14, 2012 1:27 am
by PhilH » Mon May 14, 2012 7:03 am
by CUTTERMAN » Mon May 14, 2012 7:46 am
by whufc » Mon May 14, 2012 9:56 am
by topsywaldron » Mon May 14, 2012 10:10 am
CUTTERMAN wrote:I think the most interesting poser of all of this is that whatever way you look at whichever model, I can't see how there will be a Port Magpies playing for Premiership points or even playing in the SANFL. The question is, as SANFL or Port supporters are we willing for this to occur.
by Booney » Mon May 14, 2012 10:19 am
topsywaldron wrote:CUTTERMAN wrote:I think the most interesting poser of all of this is that whatever way you look at whichever model, I can't see how there will be a Port Magpies playing for Premiership points or even playing in the SANFL. The question is, as SANFL or Port supporters are we willing for this to occur.
Port Magpies supporters obviously are, they voted overwhelmingly in favour of killing the Magpies off last year.
by MightyEagles » Mon May 14, 2012 10:27 am
by Dutchy » Mon May 14, 2012 11:30 am
by whufc » Mon May 14, 2012 11:35 am
Dutchy wrote:NRL, A-League and State cricket has a national reserves league, why is it so hard for the AFL?
by FlyingHigh » Mon May 14, 2012 11:45 am
Dutchy wrote:NRL, A-League and State cricket has a national reserves league, why is it so hard for the AFL?
by RustyCage » Mon May 14, 2012 1:29 pm
topsywaldron wrote:CUTTERMAN wrote:I think the most interesting poser of all of this is that whatever way you look at whichever model, I can't see how there will be a Port Magpies playing for Premiership points or even playing in the SANFL. The question is, as SANFL or Port supporters are we willing for this to occur.
Port Magpies supporters obviously are, they voted overwhelmingly in favour of killing the Magpies off last year.
by gadj1976 » Mon May 14, 2012 1:41 pm
Grahaml wrote:Tassie Blues wrote:I think it’s something that has to happen for both AFL teams to become more competitive in AFL and player development. The way I see it is Power will have Magpies as reserves side that’s a no brainier. Crows will either need to have new side in SANFL taking it to a 10 team comp (no more 2 byes in the first 4 weeks of a season) or will use a current SANFL team as the reserves side.
If they go with a current SANFL side it couldn’t be Centrals or South due to distance from West Lakes so that leaves Glenelg, North, Norwood, Sturt, West and WWT. I’m not going to pick one but all are within 20km and about 30 min from West Lakes.
Some of the issue are going to be what happens when the crows/power take a young player from an SANFL club they would then change to a new AFL/SANFL club and if they don’t get on the main AFL list or they are not up to AFL standard do they keep playing for the AFL/SANFL club or go back to their original SANFL club. Also do the AFL/SANFL clubs have a SANFL salary cap? And is it the same or more than the other SANFL clubs? Does that cap include payment from playing AFL games?
I’m sure there are hundreds of other issues associated with this topic but I think it’s an interesting one.
Lol. What a poorly thought through post. You really think the SANFL clubs are going to decide to compromise themselves and their competition to possibly, maybe help a couple kids be a little better when they go into the AFL? How much is having control over a reserves team really worth? It might not even be any advantage at all, yet you want to rip the heart out of the SANFL and use it purely to help Port lose by a couple less points a game? However strongly the AFL clubs want it, the SANFL still have control of themselves (unless they sold it to Demetriou when I wasn't watching) so solve that issue before worrying about nonsense like salary caps.
by topsywaldron » Mon May 14, 2012 2:35 pm
pafc1870 wrote:topsywaldron wrote:CUTTERMAN wrote:I think the most interesting poser of all of this is that whatever way you look at whichever model, I can't see how there will be a Port Magpies playing for Premiership points or even playing in the SANFL. The question is, as SANFL or Port supporters are we willing for this to occur.
Port Magpies supporters obviously are, they voted overwhelmingly in favour of killing the Magpies off last year.
Hardly voted to kill off the Magpies last year
by Booney » Mon May 14, 2012 2:38 pm
topsywaldron wrote:pafc1870 wrote:topsywaldron wrote:CUTTERMAN wrote:I think the most interesting poser of all of this is that whatever way you look at whichever model, I can't see how there will be a Port Magpies playing for Premiership points or even playing in the SANFL. The question is, as SANFL or Port supporters are we willing for this to occur.
Port Magpies supporters obviously are, they voted overwhelmingly in favour of killing the Magpies off last year.
Hardly voted to kill off the Magpies last year
You show me an independent board tasked solely with assisting the Maggies and I might stand a chance of believing you.
Until that day even I, as a Norwood supporter, feels for the true Port supporters who've watched their club get cannibalised.
by CUTTERMAN » Mon May 14, 2012 4:08 pm
Booney wrote:topsywaldron wrote:CUTTERMAN wrote:I think the most interesting poser of all of this is that whatever way you look at whichever model, I can't see how there will be a Port Magpies playing for Premiership points or even playing in the SANFL. The question is, as SANFL or Port supporters are we willing for this to occur.
Port Magpies supporters obviously are, they voted overwhelmingly in favour of killing the Magpies off last year.
If ( and I dont see it ever happening ) this ever happened, why would the Magpies not remain just that, the Magpies, and be a Port Adelaides AFL reserves?
Competitions SANFL Official Site | Country Footy SA | Southern Football League | VFL Footy
Club Forums Snouts Louts | The Roost | Redlegs Forum |