Flash Poll - Which grade do you think Kilburn should be in?

[Mr Beefy]

so F.C what your saying is they could not act on it before the season started ??? but all of a sudden they can now..............a nice paying job id assume im more then happy to make the tough decisions before things like this happen and the league is made to look silly

P.G we took a mate down to kilburn who had never played football we watched him train with there group and we counted 15 players trainning now our mate who is crap at football decided he didnt want to play cause some of the people out there just as bad as him

They can't make Kilburn go anywhere.

They can after their reserves forfeit another game
"25.7 The League may in its absolute discretion impose a fine, suspend or withdraw from the competition, a team or the Member Club which forfeits three matches or more during any one season and deem such Member Club to be ineligible for any refund of any fees or subscriptions, either paid or due to be paid to The League."

[Look Good In Leather]

Extraordinary meeting to be called to vote Kilburn out

http://www.news.com.au/national/south-a ... 6884942368

[Phantom Gossiper]

May sound like an obvious question.. but how would clubs vote?

[marbles]

Extraordinary meeting to be called to vote Kilburn out

http://www.news.com.au/national/south-a ... 6884942368

send them to the SFL, thrashings are acceptable there

[Robb_Stark]

so kilburn made the sunday mail and now the tuesday advertiser not bad lol ....... still im struggling to understand why the clubs have to vote on what to do with kilburn really its the SAAFL board who need to make the call 65 other clubs are not gonna agree unless they are given some options

[woodublieve12]

Extraordinary meeting to be called to vote Kilburn out

http://www.news.com.au/national/south-a ... 6884942368

wish they could get there facts right...

[Phantom Gossiper]

I'm sick of the constant reference to players not being paid that's why they left, no one that left was owed money!

FFS if you were owed money would you leave? No you would wait until you were paid

[Phantom Gossiper]

Ok another question.. if Kilburn went under or moved to C grades, and players left to another club having played first two rounds in Div 3.. would they be worth points?

[Footy Chick]

Extraordinary meeting to be called to vote Kilburn out

http://www.news.com.au/national/south-a ... 6884942368

wish they could get there facts right...

You've been stripped!

[jo172]

I'm sick of the constant reference to players not being paid that's why they left, no one that left was owed money!

FFS if you were owed money would you leave? No you would wait until you were paid

I doubt both your claim and I particularly doubt your logic.

Why would I stay and play another season at somewhere I was owed money?

An old saying of "fool me once shame on you, fool me twice shame on me" comes to mind

[heater31]

I'm sick of the constant reference to players not being paid that's why they left, no one that left was owed money!

FFS if you were owed money would you leave? No you would wait until you were paid

I doubt both your claim and I particularly doubt your logic.

Why would I stay and play another season at somewhere I was owed money?

An old saying of "fool me once shame on you, fool me twice shame on me" comes to mind

If it was me I would get my money first then leave.....

[Phantom Gossiper]

I doubt both your claim and I particularly doubt your logic.

Why would I stay and play another season at somewhere I was owed money?

An old saying of "fool me once shame on you, fool me twice shame on me" comes to mind

Sorry what I meant was why would you leave if you were owed money until you had been paid? I am not questioning the moving on after receiving the money owed, that's totally understandable.. but a lot of these players had already expressed they were moving on early after last season.. they had been paid their money.

A lot of players also moved on once they realised how difficult Kilburn were struggling eg Parks, Fox, Graham etc

[Phantom Gossiper]

If it was me I would get my money first then leave.....

Ditto..

End of the day, it was a culmination of reasons that led to the position they are in, money - or not paying players - is not the single one reason which seems to be indicated in that article.

[jo172]

I doubt both your claim and I particularly doubt your logic.

Why would I stay and play another season at somewhere I was owed money?

An old saying of "fool me once shame on you, fool me twice shame on me" comes to mind

Sorry what I meant was why would you leave if you were owed money until you had been paid? I am not questioning the moving on after receiving the money owed, that's totally understandable.. but a lot of these players had already expressed they were moving on early after last season.. they had been paid their money.

A lot of players also moved on once they realised how difficult Kilburn were struggling eg Parks, Fox, Graham etc

If you haven't been paid and it's 4 months after that money was originally due why would you hang around expecting to get paid the money you were owed? Particularly when you were forsaking the opportunity to earn an income at a different club (which you would hope would pay you) the next season?

[Robb_Stark]

P.G so at present you have coached 2 kilburn B grade games for 2 ten goal loses not bad



Kernahan said overall SAAFL registrations were up by about 200 to about 6000 thats a funny figure to go by also

[Phantom Gossiper]

If you haven't been paid and it's 4 months after that money was originally due why would you hang around expecting to get paid the money you were owed? Particularly when you were forsaking the opportunity to earn an income at a different club (which you would hope would pay you) the next season?

Yeah I suppose, ok I give up, you are right..

Won't hear that too often so enjoy!

[Phantom Gossiper]

P.G so at present you have coached 2 kilburn B grade games for 2 ten goal loses not bad

Best coaching record for the season down at Kilburn!

Kernahan said overall SAAFL registrations were up by about 200 to about 6000 thats a funny figure to go by also

Does this include 18's as well? 200 isnt a large number, especially over 66 clubs, thats an average of 3 new players to each club.. throw in clubs like Modbury who have extended to a 5th team and if they include 18's (Smithfield & Ingle Farm) suddenly over 66 clubs that is bugger all new players..

[jo172]

P.G so at present you have coached 2 kilburn B grade games for 2 ten goal loses not bad

Best coaching record for the season down at Kilburn!

Kernahan said overall SAAFL registrations were up by about 200 to about 6000 thats a funny figure to go by also

Does this include 18's as well? 200 isnt a large number, especially over 66 clubs, thats an average of 3 new players to each club.. throw in clubs like Modbury who have extended to a 5th team and if they include 18's (Smithfield & Ingle Farm) suddenly over 66 clubs that is bugger all new players..

Correct me if I'm wrong, but doesn't that indicate that the biggest Football League in Australia is still growing? From that perspective it's pretty impressive.

[Robb_Stark]

not sure where 200-6000 comes from or what it includes exactly its very random

[Phantom Gossiper]

Correct me if I'm wrong, but doesn't that indicate that the biggest Football League in Australia is still growing? From that perspective it's pretty impressive.

All i'm saying is that figure could be very misleading..