List Assessment - Richmond Vs Crows

[Pag]

It really doesn't matter who has the best list when one will finish 10th and the other 13th, neither club will achieve anything.

FWIW, I'd rather finish 13th and try to improve that crap list a little more.

neither richmond or the crows have crap lists. that would be st kilda.

they both have something to work with, but both have glaring deficiencies too

this also shows how much you can stuff up a list through poor drafting. doesnt bode well for the crows given they are missing four draft picks from the past 2 years. thankfully we got crouch to somewhat stem that.


http://www.heraldsun.com.au/sport/afl/f ... 6980866631

Each to their own, but I will say I overrated (along with our coaching staff) our list greatly after last season. Too many players who wouldn't be anywhere near playing in a premiership-calibre team.

[Booney]

That does seem correct Pag.

When you look at the teams heading up the ladder they not only have a fistful of genuine stars, they also recruit very smartly with specific roles in mind.

I think Port with Monfries, Kangaroos with Dal Santo, Adelaide with Pods and Betts, Sydney with Tippett and Franklin etc etc.

Richmond have not been able to secure any talent of that ilk.

[am Bays]

That does seem correct Pag.

When you look at the teams heading up the ladder they not only have a fistful of genuine stars, they also recruit very smartly with specific roles in mind.

I think Port with Monfries, Kangaroos with Dal Santo, Adelaide with Pods and Betts, Sydney with Tippett and Franklin etc etc.

Richmond have not been able to secure any talent of that ilk.

et tu Booney

[bennymacca]

Howany small forwards have kicked more goals than Eddie this year?

The answer is breust.

He is on track for 50 goals which is a gun season in anyone's language.

At the start of the season I said 40 goals would be a pass for Eddie and I think he is worth his money if he gets more than that

[stan]

In regards to the topic, in my opinion Adelaide is a far way in front in regards to lists. But there are some holes there, but I believe they can be fixed.

Richmond have some holes and they filled them with some average players. Not going to take you forward in my opinion.