Q. wrote:Saints lose pick 5, not pick 9
Cheers Q, edited.
by valleys07 » Tue Oct 13, 2015 11:51 am
Q. wrote:Saints lose pick 5, not pick 9
by Dutchy » Tue Oct 13, 2015 11:56 am
by MW » Tue Oct 13, 2015 11:58 am
valleys07 wrote:MW wrote:valleys07 wrote:Following trade proposal mentioned this morning, which could see the Carlisle deal done:
Essendon:
Lose- Jake Carlisle
Gain- Pick 9
St. Kilda:
Lose- Pick 9
Gain- Pick 28, Jake Carlisle
Adelaide:
Lose- Picks 9 & 28
Gain- Pick 5
Personally- not a bad deal for all parties concerned, IMO.
I think the Crows lose in that. Basically giving up pick 28 to go 4 spots higher in their first pick. Silly.
Disagree. Giving up pick 28 in what is considered a weak draft, to consolidate 2 x 1st round picks, and giving Adelaide a crack at securing highly rated WAFC lad, Aaron Francis.
by valleys07 » Tue Oct 13, 2015 12:08 pm
MW wrote:valleys07 wrote:MW wrote:valleys07 wrote:Following trade proposal mentioned this morning, which could see the Carlisle deal done:
Essendon:
Lose- Jake Carlisle
Gain- Pick 9
St. Kilda:
Lose- Pick 9
Gain- Pick 28, Jake Carlisle
Adelaide:
Lose- Picks 9 & 28
Gain- Pick 5
Personally- not a bad deal for all parties concerned, IMO.
I think the Crows lose in that. Basically giving up pick 28 to go 4 spots higher in their first pick. Silly.
Disagree. Giving up pick 28 in what is considered a weak draft, to consolidate 2 x 1st round picks, and giving Adelaide a crack at securing highly rated WAFC lad, Aaron Francis.
The talent between 5 and 9 is worth giving away pick 28?
by JK » Tue Oct 13, 2015 12:30 pm
valleys07 wrote:Well 9,13 & 28 or 5 & 13.
Could the crows be satisfied with Gore, and potentially be looking at a Rookie upgrade?
Are they eyeing off 2 SA lads (Francis and perhaps Milera) to avoid the go home factor?
by stan » Tue Oct 13, 2015 12:37 pm
JK wrote:valleys07 wrote:Well 9,13 & 28 or 5 & 13.
Could the crows be satisfied with Gore, and potentially be looking at a Rookie upgrade?
Are they eyeing off 2 SA lads (Francis and perhaps Milera) to avoid the go home factor?
Im no scout or draft expert, but I'd be taking the 2nd of those options in a heartbeat. All clubs need injections of top-end talent, especially the Crows after losing their best player, and the the earlier the pick, the better the chance of finding it.
by stan » Tue Oct 13, 2015 12:38 pm
heater31 wrote:Why are West Coast bitching about the compensation given? They could not find a spot in their best 22 for their vice captain who was out of contract and they want more than a 2nd round pick? Tell them their dreaming Gill
by stan » Tue Oct 13, 2015 12:40 pm
Jim05 wrote:stan wrote:St.kilda and Essendon are at road block now with the Carlsie deal. Probably need a third club now.
Definately
We want a first rounder and they are offering a second rounder. They need to trade players/picks to get a first rounder.
by valleys07 » Tue Oct 13, 2015 12:45 pm
JK wrote:valleys07 wrote:Well 9,13 & 28 or 5 & 13.
Could the crows be satisfied with Gore, and potentially be looking at a Rookie upgrade?
Are they eyeing off 2 SA lads (Francis and perhaps Milera) to avoid the go home factor?
Im no scout or draft expert, but I'd be taking the 2nd of those options in a heartbeat. All clubs need injections of top-end talent, especially the Crows after losing their best player, and the the earlier the pick, the better the chance of finding it.
by gadj1976 » Tue Oct 13, 2015 12:52 pm
Zartan wrote:heater31 wrote:Why are West Coast bitching about the compensation given? They could not find a spot in their best 22 for their vice captain who was out of contract and they want more than a 2nd round pick? Tell them their dreaming Gill
Not to mention Selwood is at the back end of his career - hardly warrants anything more than a 2nd round pick IMO.
by JK » Tue Oct 13, 2015 12:52 pm
by MW » Tue Oct 13, 2015 12:57 pm
JK wrote:Even if Francis isn't around by Pick 5, still have a better chance of picking a future gun than at pick 9. Pick 28 in a shallow draft could be more miss than hit, so might aswell use it to bump up your starting point in the draft.
Have the Crows ever had a pick as high as 5?
by JK » Tue Oct 13, 2015 1:01 pm
MW wrote:JK wrote:Even if Francis isn't around by Pick 5, still have a better chance of picking a future gun than at pick 9. Pick 28 in a shallow draft could be more miss than hit, so might aswell use it to bump up your starting point in the draft.
Have the Crows ever had a pick as high as 5?
No, pick 7 was our highest and we know how that went...
by valleys07 » Tue Oct 13, 2015 1:10 pm
JK wrote:MW wrote:JK wrote:Even if Francis isn't around by Pick 5, still have a better chance of picking a future gun than at pick 9. Pick 28 in a shallow draft could be more miss than hit, so might aswell use it to bump up your starting point in the draft.
Have the Crows ever had a pick as high as 5?
No, pick 7 was our highest and we know how that went...
Angwin? What number was Dangerfield?
by kneedeepinthehoopla » Tue Oct 13, 2015 3:32 pm
MW wrote:JK wrote:Even if Francis isn't around by Pick 5, still have a better chance of picking a future gun than at pick 9. Pick 28 in a shallow draft could be more miss than hit, so might aswell use it to bump up your starting point in the draft.
Have the Crows ever had a pick as high as 5?
No, pick 7 was our highest and we know how that went...
by MW » Tue Oct 13, 2015 3:33 pm
kneedeepinthehoopla wrote:MW wrote:JK wrote:Even if Francis isn't around by Pick 5, still have a better chance of picking a future gun than at pick 9. Pick 28 in a shallow draft could be more miss than hit, so might aswell use it to bump up your starting point in the draft.
Have the Crows ever had a pick as high as 5?
No, pick 7 was our highest and we know how that went...
K McGregor?
by valleys07 » Tue Oct 13, 2015 3:55 pm
by MW » Tue Oct 13, 2015 4:03 pm
valleys07 wrote:Courtesy of the Kane Johnson trade in 2002, Adelaide did have pick 2- which was on traded for Wayne Carey.
Does that count?
by stan » Tue Oct 13, 2015 4:52 pm
Competitions SANFL Official Site | Country Footy SA | Southern Football League | VFL Footy
Club Forums Snouts Louts | The Roost | Redlegs Forum |