SA Footy

So Brisbane have given us 5 and Mayes for pick 6?

Booney wrote:So Brisbane have given us 5 and Mayes for pick 6?

This deal seems silly on Brisbane’s part

Booney wrote:

HH3 wrote:North Melbourne have picked up Polec, Pittard, Dyson and Hall...for f**k all.

Not too shabby.

Rockliff, Motlop, Watts....

Who?

Booney wrote:So Brisbane have given us 5 and Mayes for pick 6?

They get 35 as well (Hawks pick i am guessing?). So they have given us an upgrade to 5 & Mayes for 35 + whatever other picks are involved at the lower end of the scale. Not sure they allowed us to upgrade to 5

mighty hounds wrote:

Brodlach wrote:And a player

Which one? Doesn’t say above?

Saying Brisbane give up a player (Mayes)

bertiebeatle wrote:

Booney wrote:So Brisbane have given us 5 and Mayes for pick 6?

They get 35 as well (Hawks pick i am guessing?). So they have given us an upgrade to 5 & Mayes for 35 + whatever other picks are involved at the lower end of the scale. Not sure they allowed us to upgrade to 5

Yep,

Brisbane :
In - pick 6, 35 and future 3rd rounder
Out - pick 5 and Mayes to Port

Hawthorn :
In - Wingard
Out - pick 15 and Burton ( Port ) pick 35 future 3rd rounder ( Brisbane )

Port :
Out - pick 6 ( Brisbane ) Wingard ( Hawthorn )
In - pick 5 and Mayes ( Brisbane ) pick 15 and Burton ( Hawthorn )

I don’t understand that from Brisbane at all

Booney wrote:

bertiebeatle wrote:

Booney wrote:So Brisbane have given us 5 and Mayes for pick 6?

They get 35 as well (Hawks pick i am guessing?). So they have given us an upgrade to 5 & Mayes for 35 + whatever other picks are involved at the lower end of the scale. Not sure they allowed us to upgrade to 5

Yep,

Brisbane :
In - pick 6, 35 and future 3rd rounder
Out - pick 5 and Mayes to Port

Hawthorn :
In - Wingard
Out - pick 15 and Burton ( Port ) pick 35 future 3rd rounder ( Brisbane )

Port :
Out - pick 6 ( Brisbane ) Wingard ( Hawthorn )
In - pick 5 and Mayes ( Brisbane ) pick 15 and Burton ( Hawthorn )

I am guessing 6 & 35 will go to Freo for Neale?

bertiebeatle wrote:I am guessing 6 & 35 will go to Freo for Neale?

I'd say so, that's why they don't care if they went from 5 to 6.

Fremantle get pick 6 back!

Might see a few trades drop now that this one is unlocked.

I think Port have still lost out. Wingard is a great player and I'm sure you would find a way to work with him to get the best out of him. Maybe he just needed more time in the middle, how knows. We will find out next season as I reckon he will year it up at the Hawks.

stan wrote:Might see a few trades drop now that this one is unlocked.

I think Port have still lost out. Wingard is a great player and I'm sure you would find a way to work with him to get the best out of him. Maybe he just needed more time in the middle, how knows. We will find out next season as I reckon he will year it up at the Hawks.

Think Wingard will have a good year next season. Something to prove, however most of those type of players then go back to old habits after 12 months when he feels he showed port and probably got his money.

Booney wrote:

bertiebeatle wrote:

Booney wrote:So Brisbane have given us 5 and Mayes for pick 6?

They get 35 as well (Hawks pick i am guessing?). So they have given us an upgrade to 5 & Mayes for 35 + whatever other picks are involved at the lower end of the scale. Not sure they allowed us to upgrade to 5

Yep,

Brisbane :
In - pick 6, 35 and future 3rd rounder
Out - pick 5 and Mayes to Port

Hawthorn :
In - Wingard
Out - pick 15 and Burton ( Port ) pick 35 future 3rd rounder ( Brisbane )

Port :
Out - pick 6 ( Brisbane ) Wingard ( Hawthorn )
In - pick 5 and Mayes ( Brisbane ) pick 15 and Burton ( Hawthorn )

Port wins this big time

Booney wrote:Brisbane :
In - pick 6, 35 and future 3rd rounder
Out - pick 5 and Mayes to Port

Brodlach wrote:I don’t understand that from Brisbane at all

Brisbane 'lost' 127 points on the downgrade from 5 to 6.
Pick 35 is 'worth' 522 points. So they've won there.

Mayes for a future 3rd rounder is nothing. Players a lot better than Mayes are going for lower than 3rd rounders.

I think Brisbane did fine here.

Booney wrote:

bertiebeatle wrote:I am guessing 6 & 35 will go to Freo for Neale?

I'd say so, that's why they don't care if they went from 5 to 6.

Fremantle get pick 6 back!

Brisbane already have pick 32.

Hawthorn have f..ked this trade big time. Massive overs for Chad. Well done Port.

stan wrote:Might see a few trades drop now that this one is unlocked.

I think Port have still lost out. Wingard is a great player and I'm sure you would find a way to work with him to get the best out of him. Maybe he just needed more time in the middle, how knows. We will find out next season as I reckon he will year it up at the Hawks.

Clarko will get the best out of him on and off the field, not sure that Hinkley or Port could've, he seemed somewhat cancerous to the group, wont get away with it at a successful Melbourne club such as Hawthorn.
Sad to see him depart as a Port supporter, I wish him all the best though as he is very talented on his day.

Hawthorn get Wingard, future 3rd round selection

Port get Burton, pick 15, pick 35 and future fourth round selection

MW wrote:Hawthorn have f..ked this trade big time. Massive overs for Chad. Well done Port.

Time will tell.

MW wrote:Hawthorn have f..ked this trade big time. Massive overs for Chad. Well done Port.

If you want a super star to come to your club you have to give something good up.

Booney wrote:

MW wrote:Hawthorn have f..ked this trade big time. Massive overs for Chad. Well done Port.

If you want a super star to come to your club you have to give something good up.

Superstar??! Pardon?

Buddy’s a superstar, Dusty’s a superstar - Chad ain’t no superstar.