SA Footy

Psyber wrote:Perhaps the simplest solution to the holding the ball issue would be that when tackled you can dispose of the ball anyway you can including throwing it to ground without penalty, and thus if you don't dispose of it then the call is holding the ball. Of course pinning the arms in a tackle would then become a pattern, but that could mean a bounce..

Zelezny Chucks wrote:No bonus points, scrap percentage and use points for as the determining stat with teams on the same premiership points.

There is too much incentive with percentage to only lose by a small margin, remove that incentive and teams should go for the win more if it makes no difference to lose by 1 goal or 10.

Psyber wrote:Perhaps the simplest solution to the holding the ball issue would be that when tackled you can dispose of the ball anyway you can including throwing it to ground without penalty, and thus if you don't dispose of it then the call is holding the ball. Of course pinning the arms in a tackle would then become a pattern, but that could mean a bounce..

daysofourlives wrote:

Psyber wrote:Perhaps the simplest solution to the holding the ball issue would be that when tackled you can dispose of the ball anyway you can including throwing it to ground without penalty, and thus if you don't dispose of it then the call is holding the ball. Of course pinning the arms in a tackle would then become a pattern, but that could mean a bounce..

Not that silly, let them throw it, would keep the ball moving alot more. Then you could penalize anybody who doesnt get it out, even if arms are pinned. No grey area at all,easy to umpire.
Its ******* rugby already as it is.

Corona Man wrote:

daysofourlives wrote:

Psyber wrote:Perhaps the simplest solution to the holding the ball issue would be that when tackled you can dispose of the ball anyway you can including throwing it to ground without penalty, and thus if you don't dispose of it then the call is holding the ball. Of course pinning the arms in a tackle would then become a pattern, but that could mean a bounce..

Not that silly, let them throw it, would keep the ball moving alot more. Then you could penalize anybody who doesnt get it out, even if arms are pinned. No grey area at all,easy to umpire.
Its ******* rugby already as it is.

Crows blokes ahead of the curve here by 20 years....

mots02 wrote:

Corona Man wrote:

daysofourlives wrote:

Psyber wrote:Perhaps the simplest solution to the holding the ball issue would be that when tackled you can dispose of the ball anyway you can including throwing it to ground without penalty, and thus if you don't dispose of it then the call is holding the ball. Of course pinning the arms in a tackle would then become a pattern, but that could mean a bounce..

Not that silly, let them throw it, would keep the ball moving alot more. Then you could penalize anybody who doesnt get it out, even if arms are pinned. No grey area at all,easy to umpire.
Its ******* rugby already as it is.

Crows blokes ahead of the curve here by 20 years....

The Crows obsession is still strong with this one.

mighty_tiger_79 wrote:Since when do umps call time off so a player can put a boot on??

Sent from my SM-A520F using Tapatalk