2021 Trade rumours and discussion

[Jim05]

[quote="Brodlach"]Rumour that Adelaide offered North Pick 4 and our two first round picks for next year for pick 1 this year.

Good on them for trying

That's exactly what I'm saying.
North should take that deal.

Yeah, nah.

You think JHF is going to be better than 4&12 this year and another top 4 pick next year?

You watch SANFL?[/quote]Yes, plenty but I don’t believe 1 player is better than 3 especially 2x top 5’s and another under 15.

[mighty_tiger_79]

North should take the deal.
The kid will be coming straight home.

Sent from my SM-G781B using Tapatalk

Yeah nah.

You don't think he's coming straight home?

Sent from my SM-G781B using Tapatalk

[stan]

[quote="tigerpie"][quote="Brodlach"]Rumour that Adelaide offered North Pick 4 and our two first round picks for next year for pick 1 this year.

Good on them for trying

That's exactly what I'm saying.
North should take that deal.

Yeah, nah.

You think JHF is going to be better than 4&12 this year and another top 4 pick next year?

You watch SANFL?[/quote]Yes, plenty but I don’t believe 1 player is better than 3 especially 2x top 5’s and another under 15.[/quote]So really that's probably pick 4, and then another top 5 pick. Depends of courses the crows didn't look terrible at times.

Who's the other pick tied to?

[stan]

Just checked it out, tied to Melbourne so what is potentially on offer is the following:

2021 - pick 4
2022 - potential top 4 pick and potential pick 16 - 18 (Melbourne likely to do well next year as well).

I mean it's a good offer it's 2 good first rounders and meh end of first round probably. But not sure it would get the job done. Unless next year is a super draft then that might get them thinking.

[gadj1976]

So North aren't actually in a rebuild then?

If you got the chance of getting three first round picks for 1, you'd jump at it. The kid is a gun, but mids are a dime a dozen and as a Carlton supporter I know full well 1 no 1 pick doesn't maketh the team.

[Dutchy]

If it was 3 top 10 picks then we would take it I reckon, however with one of them linked to Melbourne 2022 performance there is a good chance it will slip to the 20's.

Crows are offering it cause they know he wont come home, very loyal kid who is already looking forward to the move to Melbourne.

[Jim05]

If it was 3 top 10 picks then we would take it I reckon, however with one of them linked to Melbourne 2022 performance there is a good chance it will slip to the 20's.

Crows are offering it cause they know he wont come home, very loyal kid who is already looking forward to the move to Melbourne.

And playing in Tasmania every few weeks is similar to Noarlunga anyway

[mighty_tiger_79]

If it was 3 top 10 picks then we would take it I reckon, however with one of them linked to Melbourne 2022 performance there is a good chance it will slip to the 20's.

Crows are offering it cause they know he wont come home, very loyal kid who is already looking forward to the move to Melbourne.

He's coming home. 100%

Sent from my SM-G781B using Tapatalk

[tigerpie]

If it was 3 top 10 picks then we would take it I reckon, however with one of them linked to Melbourne 2022 performance there is a good chance it will slip to the 20's.

Crows are offering it cause they know he wont come home, very loyal kid who is already looking forward to the move to Melbourne.

They would've put that very question to him at interview.
His answer have convinced them he's a one club player.
Two first round picks, if you get it right is a handy leg up.

[Armchair expert]

If you listen to crows fans he was deliberately trying to tank his interviews with north

[Wedgie]

He's a top lad, he will give 150% to the Roos and will likely be a star and be there a long time.

[stan]

If it was 3 top 10 picks then we would take it I reckon, however with one of them linked to Melbourne 2022 performance there is a good chance it will slip to the 20's.

Crows are offering it cause they know he wont come home, very loyal kid who is already looking forward to the move to Melbourne.

The thing is, not a lot of kids go to Melbourne and not enjoy it. When it's up and going, obviously not now, it's an amazing city to be in. Not easy to get SA talent back from Melbourne.

The crows have gone hard knowing he could very well be a once in generation player and good on them for trying and being bold.

I agree with you about the picks, of it was 3 x top 10 picks then that would be different to what it is now.

[mighty_tiger_79]

If it was 3 top 10 picks then we would take it I reckon, however with one of them linked to Melbourne 2022 performance there is a good chance it will slip to the 20's.

Crows are offering it cause they know he wont come home, very loyal kid who is already looking forward to the move to Melbourne.

They would've put that very question to him at interview.
His answer have convinced them he's a one club player.
Two first round picks, if you get it right is a handy leg up.

I'd be concerned that North were the last club to speak to him

Sent from my SM-G781B using Tapatalk

[Brodlach]

No need to Spotify him if he is as good as they say he is

[MW]

If you listen to crows fans he was deliberately trying to tank his interviews with north

Get off bigfooty for your own mental health

[Jim05]

Bobby Hill from GWS has requested a trade to Victoria. Apparently has spoken to 6 clubs with Essendon currently leading the race.
McCartney v Dodoro round 4 here we go

[Armchair expert]

If you listen to crows fans he was deliberately trying to tank his interviews with north

Get off bigfooty for your own mental health

Was reddit actually

[Armchair expert]

Bobby Hill from GWS has requested a trade to Victoria. Apparently has spoken to 6 clubs with Essendon currently leading the race.
McCartney v Dodoro round 4 here we go

3rd rounder should do it

[Booney]

If it was 3 top 10 picks then we would take it I reckon, however with one of them linked to Melbourne 2022 performance there is a good chance it will slip to the 20's.

Crows are offering it cause they know he wont come home, very loyal kid who is already looking forward to the move to Melbourne.

Effectively 4 this year, (about) 1 (bottom) , 8 (Adelaide) and 18 (Melbourne) next year and lose 19 next year.

So this year they'd have 4, 20, 40 and change.

Next year 1,8,18 then whatever.

Potentially 5 top 25 (probably to 30 with academy etc ) picks in 2 years.

The kid looks a freak, but 5 top 30 picks, that builds lists. Good play by Adelaide and well played by North to let it go.

[tigerpie]

If it was 3 top 10 picks then we would take it I reckon, however with one of them linked to Melbourne 2022 performance there is a good chance it will slip to the 20's.

Crows are offering it cause they know he wont come home, very loyal kid who is already looking forward to the move to Melbourne.

Effectively 4 this year, (about) 1 (bottom) , 8 (Adelaide) and 18 (Melbourne) next year and lose 19 next year.

So this year they'd have 4, 20, 40 and change.

Next year 1,8,18 then whatever.

Potentially 5 top 25 (probably to 30 with academy etc ) picks in 2 years.

The kid looks a freak, but 5 top 30 picks, that builds lists. Good play by Adelaide and well played by North to let it go.

With those numbers, to me, North get a fair leg up.
If they went for it, could set them up nicely.
But if they picked 3 duds could break them.
Faith in scouts would have to be top notch.