SA Footy

Booney wrote:

Brodlach wrote:Just so I’m clear, are Adelaide just paying them or are they going to be traded to Adelaide for a late pick?

Traded to Adelaide so they get off of the St Kilda books.

Saints are chasing McKernan so need the coin

Booney wrote:

Brodlach wrote:Just so I’m clear, are Adelaide just paying them or are they going to be traded to Adelaide for a late pick?

Traded to Adelaide so they get off of the St Kilda books.

That’s how I took it so deal would be

Adelaide
Get Webster, Dunstan and Pick 2

Give Crouch and a late pick

Brodlach wrote:

Booney wrote:

Brodlach wrote:Just so I’m clear, are Adelaide just paying them or are they going to be traded to Adelaide for a late pick?

Traded to Adelaide so they get off of the St Kilda books.

That’s how I took it so deal would be

Adelaide
Get Webster, Dunstan and Pick 2

Give Crouch and a late pick

Yes and if the ICAC don't investigate the deal they might as well disband.

Even if Webster never plays we win that trade

Brodlach wrote:

Booney wrote:

Brodlach wrote:Just so I’m clear, are Adelaide just paying them or are they going to be traded to Adelaide for a late pick?

Traded to Adelaide so they get off of the St Kilda books.

That’s how I took it so deal would be

Adelaide
Get Webster, Dunstan and Pick 2

Give Crouch and a late pick

Yeah I struggle to see how it works.

If they lose Crouch on his own, that's not enough to get pick to.

However, if they recieve two players in exchange for Crouch, the compensation goes up, not down????

Adelaide lose crouch as a free agent and receive compo of pick 2.
They then do a separate trade for the 2 players for later picks.

Trader wrote:

Brodlach wrote:

Booney wrote:

Brodlach wrote:Just so I’m clear, are Adelaide just paying them or are they going to be traded to Adelaide for a late pick?

Traded to Adelaide so they get off of the St Kilda books.

That’s how I took it so deal would be

Adelaide
Get Webster, Dunstan and Pick 2

Give Crouch and a late pick

Yeah I struggle to see how it works.

If they lose Crouch on his own, that's not enough to get pick to.

However, if they recieve two players in exchange for Crouch, the compensation goes up, not down????

St Kilda say to Crouch 5 years x $550k. That isn't high enough for Adelaide to get pick 2, would be pick 19.

St Kilda say to Adelaide, take these two blokes ( let's say on $350k each ) and we'll up the Crouch offer to 5 years x $700k and that means you get pick 2 instead of pick 19.

I am sure Brad Crouch's manager presented him a deal that was $100k / year less per year than he is on atm. This guy could sell ice to Eskimo's if that's the case or Brad is totally dumb. Those reports are totally press driven. I can believe the second part that a player is involved to free up St Kilda's cap.

Mythical Creature wrote:Adelaide lose crouch as a free agent and receive compo of pick 2.
They then do a separate trade for the 2 players for later picks.

Yup, separate trades makes sense, thanks (and Booney too).

Herald Sun saying Fantasia has a 3 year offer from Port and that pick 26 or 31 is on the table

Jim05 wrote:Herald Sun saying Fantasia has a 3 year offer from Port and that pick 26 or 31 is on the table

might get 6 games out of him in that time

Well done to Port

Adelaide and Crouch have made it Incredibly clear for the last 5-6 weeks that Crouch ideally wants to stay on his terms at Adelaide, however if the right offer comes along personally for Crouch Adelaide aren’t going to hold him back as long as they get adequate compensation. Crouch has “Found” his new destination which shows all parties that there has been an agreement found and that it’s moved quickly so far. Keep in mind this bloke has no bargaining chips right now to force the Crows hand...

Josh Dunkley has apparently told the Dogs he wants to be traded to Essendon.
Still contracted for 2 years so going to cost us big time in the event the Dogs even consider letting him go

Fox Footy claiming that Riley Bonner from Port possibly to be used in a trade for Fantasia with Essendon

locky801 wrote:Fox Footy claiming that Riley Bonner from Port possibly to be used in a trade for Fantasia with Essendon

Most Port fans I know would give us a pick to take Bonner!

It is what it is though. Take it and move on. With well over $2m of salary cap space to bank we can throw some cash at Dunkley and others and shake a few trees

Bonner is an actual dud

Dododoro is not that stupid

Brodlach wrote:

Booney wrote:

Brodlach wrote:Just so I’m clear, are Adelaide just paying them or are they going to be traded to Adelaide for a late pick?

Traded to Adelaide so they get off of the St Kilda books.

That’s how I took it so deal would be

Adelaide
Get Webster, Dunstan and Pick 2

Give Crouch and a late pick

Dunstan will be good value. Good player, just been I injuried.

Not a trade all up as such, Well part is but yeah out of aloof that you come out in front. No doubt. I mean so do the Saints, Webster and Dunstan for Crouch.

Jim05 wrote:Smart by both parties but it’s legalised draft tampering no matter how the AFL spins it

Very much so, but we'll done for both parties using the rules to there advantage.

stan wrote:

Jim05 wrote:Smart by both parties but it’s legalised draft tampering no matter how the AFL spins it

Very much so, but we'll done for both parties using the rules to there advantage.

Might be draft tampering if it was part of the draft

Sent from my CPH1951 using Tapatalk