SA Footy

Booney wrote:AFL Trade Live ladder :

Gee
PA
Rich
Mel
Fre
Ade
BL
GWS

Coll
Syd
WB
Car
Haw
St K
GC
WCE
Ess
North

PatowalongaPirate wrote:If Brisbane manage to get Dunkley, I would have them 2nd on this ladder and only % behind Geelong.

To get Dunkley and also have enough points for Father/Son selections would be an outstanding result. Gunston is also a plus.

Jim05 wrote:I don’t have us as bottom 2 for this trade period either BTW.
I think we are above the Suns and have set ourselves up ok for the draft.
I think the club knows we are bottom 6 material next year and will address that at the drafts hopefully

PatowalongaPirate wrote:

Jim05 wrote:I don’t have us as bottom 2 for this trade period either BTW.
I think we are above the Suns and have set ourselves up ok for the draft.
I think the club knows we are bottom 6 material next year and will address that at the drafts hopefully

I agree. Weidemann and Setterfield coming in is a good result, and having pick 4 is also a bonus.

Booney wrote:

PatowalongaPirate wrote:

Jim05 wrote:I don’t have us as bottom 2 for this trade period either BTW.
I think we are above the Suns and have set ourselves up ok for the draft.
I think the club knows we are bottom 6 material next year and will address that at the drafts hopefully

I agree. Weidemann and Setterfield coming in is a good result, and having pick 4 is also a bonus.

Only put you there for lack of action. Weidemann < and Francis > isn't worth reporting on, Setterfield will be ok and draft hand hasn't changed. Couldn't have you above WCE, I think they've done pretty well as clubs will be spooked drafting out of state talent a bit and they'll get two WA lads.

PatowalongaPirate wrote:Reports of Hopper to Punt Road for pick 31 and a future 1st rounder.

Booney wrote:Interesting trade period :

Geelong - Bigger theft than the Great Train robbery, Bruhn, Bowes and pick 7 for 18 and future 3rd
Sydney - Nothing much
Collingwood - Frampton 5***** recruiting, Grundy gone and paying him to stay gone and get Bobby Hill in
Brisbane - Gunston in, McStay out, upgrade there. Dunkley not yet done
Melbourne - Grundy in, good get
Fremantle - Unicorn in, good get, Corbett, yeah exactly, who? Logue, Acres and Tucket out
Richmond - Bingo bango - Hopper and Taranto in, huge midfield
Bulldogs - Liam Jones in, Cordy out, net zero

Carlton - Get Acres, not much else
St Kilda - Cordy in. Meh
Port Adelaide - JHF, Rioli in, expect Ratugolea, 2nd place behind Geelong in trade week
Gold Coast - FIRE SALE Berry in, Bowes and 7 go out
Hawthorn - Amon in, meh
Adelaide - Rankine in, Frampton and pick 5 out
Essendon - Hey Essendon, it's trade week! Bit going on at HQ and no mention of Dodordumb for a while. Nice.
GWS - Hopper and Taranto out, pick 1 in, Bedford in, still have a heap of picks
West Coast - Turned pick 2 and Rioli into 8 and 12 and get Hunt from Melbourne to replace Acres
North - Didn't lose much other than JHF, pick 1 and get picks 2,3 and Port's 2023 first along with AFL* Logue and Tucker picks

Booney wrote:

Lightning McQueen wrote:
I think Melbourne, Richmond and Adelaide are above us in trade week live ladder.

I also feel as though Amon is a bit more than a "meh".

Not sure that Gunston is an upgrade for the Lions, Mc Stay has a few years in his favour and I'm not sure where Gunston will fit in up there.

I was surprised at how many goals Jack kicked this season, the only game that I had him in a SGM to kick 2 goals he played across half back

Melbourne - maybe, Richmond - probably, Adelaide - no, IMO.

Amon is "meh" for Hawthorn as they're not going to get any better because of his addition.

McStay has never kicked more than 28 goals in a year, Gunston kicked 32 in 16 games playing for Hawthorn this year. He's just turned 30 so has 2-3 years in him.

gadj1976 wrote:

Booney wrote:Interesting trade period :

Geelong - Bigger theft than the Great Train robbery, Bruhn, Bowes and pick 7 for 18 and future 3rd
Sydney - Nothing much
Collingwood - Frampton 5***** recruiting, Grundy gone and paying him to stay gone and get Bobby Hill in
Brisbane - Gunston in, McStay out, upgrade there. Dunkley not yet done
Melbourne - Grundy in, good get
Fremantle - Unicorn in, good get, Corbett, yeah exactly, who? Logue, Acres and Tucket out
Richmond - Bingo bango - Hopper and Taranto in, huge midfield
Bulldogs - Liam Jones in, Cordy out, net zero

Carlton - Get Acres, not much else
St Kilda - Cordy in. Meh
Port Adelaide - JHF, Rioli in, expect Ratugolea, 2nd place behind Geelong in trade week
Gold Coast - FIRE SALE Berry in, Bowes and 7 go out
Hawthorn - Amon in, meh
Adelaide - Rankine in, Frampton and pick 5 out
Essendon - Hey Essendon, it's trade week! Bit going on at HQ and no mention of Dodordumb for a while. Nice.
GWS - Hopper and Taranto out, pick 1 in, Bedford in, still have a heap of picks
West Coast - Turned pick 2 and Rioli into 8 and 12 and get Hunt from Melbourne to replace Acres
North - Didn't lose much other than JHF, pick 1 and get picks 2,3 and Port's 2023 first along with AFL* Logue and Tucker picks

St Kilda above 'anyone' is a mystery to me.

PatowalongaPirate wrote:

PatowalongaPirate wrote:Reports of Hopper to Punt Road for pick 31 and a future 1st rounder.

Signed a 7 year deal.

Booney wrote:Wait for the review.

Jase wrote:

Booney wrote:Wait for the review.

Port must have won....



Sorry...

Booney wrote:Come on now, I didn't do 2 reviews all year....