The records that have been maintained over the years lists Paul Caust as the 1955 Leading Goalkicker and Rex Johns as the 1958 Leading Goalkicker.
However if retrospective Ken Farmer Medals were awarded, those years would be awarded to Brian Rundle and Jim Wright, respectively.
At the end of the 1955 minor round season, Rundle lead Caust 56 goals to 52. But as Glenelg missed the 1955 finals, Caust kicked 5 goals in that major round series to overtake him by one goal.
And in the 1958 minor round season, Wright led the goalkicking with only 49 goals. Johns advanced past Wright after the Preliminary with 3.8 and 4.1 (Wright in West's successful 2nd Semi had managed just 0.4). Heading into the Grand Final Johns was clear by two goals, with the gap extending to three (he kicked 4.1 to Wright's 3.1).
Although, Johns had taken just 11 games to get to 55 goals, to Wright with 20 matches for his 52 goals. Johns had missed 10 matches during the season, including Rounds 8 to 16 with a leg injury.