North's players from Spell_check's list

[Leaping Lindner]

KYM LOVIE (74)
SIMON JORGENSEN (91)
BARRY LONGMAN (64)

According to the Annual Report of 74 it's definetly Kevin Lovie.
Simon Jorgensen! Theres a name I haven't heard for a while. Picked him up from the Vic Country and could have been a great player, but packed his bags and went home the minute he was dropped to the reserves.

[LEGS 11]

Max Eatts (and GL)

[LEGS 11]

Frederick Stigwood (and WT)

[Ian]

Frederick Stigwood (and WT)

I reckon that would be the Fred Stigwood already in the list.

[LEGS 11]

J Martin (51)
C Matthews (12)

[LEGS 11]

Owen Weatherley
Leigh Ryswyk
Steven Koops
Nathan Lonie
Dean Howard (also W.A)
Brett O'Hara (also Eagles)

[LEGS 11]

Matthew Down
Kingsley Walker

[spell_check]

Ryswyk must be the first player to play SANFL that has no vowels in his last name.

[Ian]

1099

[spell_check]

Shane Schubert - that was his first game yesterday? He isn't on the list yet.

[LEGS 11]

He should have been on the list, as according to the Budget on the weekend, he had already played 1 match.

[spell_check]

Legs and Ian, you might be able to help with these:

A.Mangelsdorf - could be Herbert Mangelsdorf
Alfred Ronald May - is this just Alfred May i.e. no two Alfred Mays?
Anthony "Bos" Daly is a pre 1907 player
Arthur Beaton - I think it is H.Arthur Beaton who is already on the list
Brian Edwards - did he also play for Glenelg?
Ian you have a typo - Caude Homan should be Claude Homan
I have C.Robert Barrett but your list hasn't.
Charles Edwards - did he also play for Glenelg?
Clem Dayman - did he also play for Port?
You have two David C. Wilsons on the list. Is this correct?
David Crawford - did he also play for Norwood?
You have two Edward Morris' on the list. Is this correct?
Is Fred Curnow the same player who played for all of South, Port and Sturt?
Is Frederick C. Bennett in the post 1907 list the same player as Frederick Bennett in the pre 1907 list?
I have H. Frederick Hardwick instead of Frederick Hardwick
You have two Garfield Storers'. Is this correct?
I have George Farrell, but your list doesn't.
You have another typo - George Wenake should be George Wenske
Another two of - Graham Ashby. Is this correct?
Hank Lindner and Theo Lindner are the same player.
Did Harold Dickens also play for South and West?
You have two Ian Kroehn?
Is J Mackay, Jack Mackay?
I have Jeff Page and John Ashby on my list, but yours doesn't.

[LEGS 11]

Hope this helps :
.Mangelsdorf - could be Herbert Mangelsdorf --must be. I only have 1 listed :Herbert Mangelsdorf (1929)
Alfred Ronald May - is this just Alfred May i.e. no two Alfred Mays? -- ALFRED RONALD MAY (also S.A)
Anthony "Bos" Daly is a pre 1907 player --??? ANTHONY J DALY(1907-12)
Arthur Beaton - I think it is H.Arthur Beaton who is already on the list : ARTHUR A BEATON (also W.A)
Brian Edwards - did he also play for Glenelg? -- NO
I have C.Robert Barrett but your list hasn't. -- YES (29)
Charles Edwards - did he also play for Glenelg? -- Did he play for N.A?
Clem Dayman - did he also play for Port? -- YES
You have two David C. Wilsons on the list. Is this correct? --NO
David Crawford - did he also play for Norwood? --YEP
You have two Edward Morris' on the list. Is this correct? --NO
Is Fred Curnow the same player who played for all of South, Port and Sturt? --YEP
Is Frederick C. Bennett in the post 1907 list the same player as Frederick Bennett in the pre 1907 list? --??? FREDERICK BENNETT (N.A)37, (NWD)41.
I have H. Frederick Hardwick instead of Frederick Hardwick --Frederick Hardwick
You have two Garfield Storers'. Is this correct? -- Only 1
I have George Farrell, but your list doesn't. -- GRAEME FARRELL (63-67)
Another two of - Graham Ashby. Is this correct? --ONE PLAYED FOR N.A (62), THE OTHER W.T (48)
Did Harold Dickens also play for South and West? --NOT WEST
Is J Mackay, Jack Mackay? -- PLAYED FOR S.AD, ALSO(26) N.A(31)
I have Jeff Page and John Ashby on my list, but yours doesn't.-- SHOULD BE JOHN PAGE, JEFF PLAYED FOR NWD. JOHN ASHBY(W.T)36, AND ANOTHER ONE FOR (C.D) 64

[Leaping Lindner]

Legs and Ian, you might be able to help with these:

A.Mangelsdorf - could be Herbert Mangelsdorf
Herbert Henry Magelsdorf (1929-1935)only one
Alfred Ronald May - is this just Alfred May i.e. no two Alfred Mays?
Alfred Ronald May (1930-32) Only One
Anthony "Bos" Daly is a pre 1907 player
Played at North 1902-07;1909,1912
Arthur Beaton - I think it is H.Arthur Beaton who is already on the list
Arthur Beaton (1949) Only Beaton to play at NAFC
Brian Edwards - did he also play for Glenelg?
not sure
Ian you have a typo - Caude Homan should be Claude Homan
It's Claude
I have C.Robert Barrett but your list hasn't.
Cyril Robert Barrett (1929-1935)
Charles Edwards - did he also play for Glenelg?
not sure
Clem Dayman - did he also play for Port?
not sure
You have two David C. Wilsons on the list. Is this correct?
David C Wilson (1911) - only one
David Crawford - did he also play for Norwood?
not sure
You have two Edward Morris' on the list. Is this correct?
Edward J.Morris (1923-28 )
Is Fred Curnow the same player who played for all of South, Port and Sturt?
not sure
Is Frederick C. Bennett in the post 1907 list the same player as Frederick Bennett in the pre 1907 list?
No. Frederick Chester Bennett played for North in 1937 and 1938
I have H. Frederick Hardwick instead of Frederick Hardwick
Frederick James E. Hardwick (1929-31; 1933)
You have two Garfield Storers'. Is this correct?
Garfield Victor Storer (1930-33) Only one
I have George Farrell, but your list doesn't.
I have Graeme S. Farrell (1963-67)
You have another typo - George Wenake should be George Wenske
Yes it is Wenske
Another two of - Graham Ashby. Is this correct?
One only- Graham E. Ashby (1962-64)
Hank Lindner and Theo Lindner are the same player.
Yep. Hank was his nickname
Did Harold Dickens also play for South and West?
not sure
You have two Ian Kroehn?
Only one. Also played for Central.
Is J Mackay, Jack Mackay?
not sure
I have Jeff Page and John Ashby on my list, but yours doesn't.
Do you mean JOHN Page? (1963,1965-66)
Do you mean GRAHAM Ashby (1962-1964)?

[spell_check]

Thanks Legs! I have a question on Frederick Bennett. I don't have him down for Norwood - do you know how many games and goals he got for them in 1941?

Jack Mackay is another new addition to the South list.

[spell_check]

...or then theres' Leaping Lindner! Thank you very much for this information! I will go through the rest of the two lists and post the differences later on.

[LEGS 11]

6 GAMES

[spell_check]

Thanks. That's player no. 1000 since 1907 for Norwood.

P.S. I have deleted the post that you had on here with the West players.

[spell_check]

Here are the rest of the differences:

You have L Westbrook and Lou Westerbrook, which I think is just Lou Westbrook (1 player) as Leaping Lindner explained.
Did Leonard Dangerfield play for Glenelg as well, or just North?
You have a Peter J. May and Peter May. Is this correct, or are they the same player?
You have a Peter Schulz and a Peter Schultz. Are they the same player?
You have two Peter Sheppards'. Is there two, or just one?
Robert Jervis, who played in the combined comp. with Norwood. On my list he is a North player, as discussed with Leaping Lindner about the residential area in which players lived in at the time.
Did Scott Norton play for North and Centrals? Or just the one team?
I have Shane Bennett on my list, but yours doesn't.
You have both Stan Simmons and Stan Simmonds on the list. Are these the same player?
I have two Sydney Prices' on my list, but yours only has one. Is there one or two?
I have Sydney Scott on my list, but yours doesn't.
Did William Crowe also play for Norwood?

When these are worked out, I'll give you a copy of the North players I have, Ian.

[LEGS 11]

I have ONE each of the following :

Leonard Dangerfield (NWD/N.A, GL/W.A, GL)
PETER J May
Peter Schultz
Peter Sheppard
Robert V Jervis (Nwd/N.A)
Sydney Price
Stuart Scott (Sydney Scott played for S.A, and W.A)
William Crowe (NWD, and N.A)
Blake Norton, Geoffrey Norton, Howard Norton played for N.A.