Magarey Medal runners up.

[spell_check]

So, Murdy has the most runners up without winning it with three; and doubles to Chigwidden, Cicolella, Colville, Feast, Marker, Nelson and Tregenza.

Brodie Atkinson 3?

He won one; my post made reference to the opening post of those who didn't.

[sapaul]

oops sorry, my bad.

[spell_check]

oops sorry, my bad.

My bad too, that was what those names were for (runners up but no medal), but b&w was looking for winners who were runners up!

[sapaul]

So, with an ounce of luck Brodie Atkinson could have been held in the same breath as Russell Ebert?

<sarcasm post>

[Adelaide Hawk]

So, with an ounce of luck Brodie Atkinson could have been held in the same breath as Russell Ebert?

<sarcasm post>

This is why we must never fall into the trap of judging a player's greatness by sheer weight of Magarey Medals alone.

[blueandwhite]

Great work Spelly.
Interesting that Jim Deane was runner up 3 times and won the medal twice. It surely can be said that he was one of the all time great players in the sanfl. In the late 40's and '50's he was competing in a bottom side against the likes of Head,Hank,Fitzgerald and Quinn and many other notables.
Sad to say that Jim is not in the best of health at the moment.

[Magpiespower]

Great work Spelly.
Interesting that Jim Deane was runner up 3 times and won the medal twice. It surely can be said that he was one of the all time great players in the sanfl. In the late 40's and '50's he was competing in a bottom side against the likes of Head,Hank,Fitzgerald and Quinn and many other notables.
Sad to say that Jim is not in the best of health at the moment.

Appointed Port coach for 1950.

South refused to clear him.

Fos Williams wasn't a bad second choice...