SA Footy

Can anyone help with regards to the final outomes of the 1991 tribunal of the WA v NA GF - I have the following from some hard to read handwritten notes - I have a feeling I have missed some or got a fact or two wrong - Any help appreciated

KLOMP, Kim - 5/10/1991, SANFL, 99, GF at Football Park, North Adelaide Vrs West Adelaide (Abbott, M. D.)
MELLOR, Gregory John Outcome ?????

SIMS, Steven John 5/10/1991, SANFL, 99, GF at Football Park, North Adelaide Vrs West Adelaide (Argent, L. J.)
SIMPSON, Kevin Matthew Striking Guilty Suspension 12 (Also reported by Goal Umpire Peter Symons)

PARSONS, Michael Wayne 5/10/1991, SANFL, 99, GF at Football Park, North Adelaide Vrs West Adelaide (Argent, L. J.) GOSS, Glenn John Striking (Outcome???)

SCHUMANN, Dean Maxwell 5/10/1991, SANFL, 99, GF at Football Park, West Adelaide Vrs North Adelaide (Argent, L. J.) KLOMP, Kim - Striking Guilty Suspension 2

BLYTHE, Sean Darrell 5/10/1991, SANFL, 99, GF at Football Park, West Adelaide Vrs North Adelaide (Argent, L. J.) SIMS, Steven John Striking Guilty Suspension 3

SIMPSON, Kevin Matthew 5/10/1991, SANFL, 99, GF at Football Park, West Adelaide Vrs North Adelaide (Major, R. (Video Review)) HART, Darel Peter Striking Not Guilty Dismissed 0

SCHUMANN, Dean Maxwell 5/10/1991, SANFL, 99, GF at Football Park, West Adelaide Vrs North Adelaide (Major, R. (Video Review)) HAMILTON, Steven Kerry Striking Guilty Suspension 3

KLOMP, Kim - 5/10/1991, SANFL, 99, GF at Football Park, North Adelaide Vrs West Adelaide (Major, R. (Video Review)) SCHUMANN, Dean Maxwell Unduly Rough Play Outcome ?????

MARSHALL, Marc - 5/10/1991, SANFL, 99, GF at Football Park, North Adelaide Vrs West Adelaide (Major, R. (Video Reviewer)) BLYTHE, Sean Darrell Striking Not Guilty Dismissed 0

PERKINS, Timothy Roy 5/10/1991, SANFL, 99, GF at Football Park, North Adelaide Vrs West Adelaide (Major, R. (Video Reviwer)) BLYTHE, Sean Darrell Striking Guilty Suspension 2

PERKINS, Timothy Roy 5/10/1991, SANFL, 99, GF at Football Park, North Adelaide Vrs West Adelaide (Major, R. (Video Reviwer)) BANFIELD, Peter Charles Striking Guilty Suspension 1

FITZSIMMONS, Shane Levi 5/10/1991, SANFL, 99, GF at Football Park, West Adelaide Vrs North Adelaide (Major, R. (Video Reviwer)) KRIEG, Peter Anthony Striking Guilty Suspension 3

GOSS, Glenn John 5/10/1991, SANFL, 99, GF at Football Park, West Adelaide Vrs North Adelaide (Major, R. (Video Reviwer)) PARSONS, Michael Wayne Striking Guilty Suspension 1

BANFIELD, Peter Charles 5/10/1991, SANFL, 99, GF at Football Park, West Adelaide Vrs North Adelaide (Major, R. (Video Reviwer)) Striking Guilty Suspension 2

This is what I've got from it:

Kim Klomp (North) - by Mick Abbott for striking Greg Mellor during the 1st quarter
Steven Sims (North) - by Laurie Argent and goal umpire Peter Symons for strking Matthew Simpson during the 2nd quarter - 12 matches
Mike Parsons (North) - by Argent for striking Glen Goss in the 2nd quarter.
Dean Schumann (West) - by Argent for attempting to strike a North player "at least 10 times to the head" - 2 matches
Sean Blythe (West) - by Argent for striking Steven Sims - 3 matches

Then after the head of the Umpires Board Roger Magor reviewed the tape, the following charges were laid:
Matthew Simpson (West) - striking Darel Hart in the 1st quarter - not guilty
Dean Schumann (West) - striking Steven Hamilton in the 3rd quarter - 3 matches
Kim Klomp (North) - unduly rough play towards Schumann in the 3rd quarter
Marc Marshall (North) - striking Sean Blythe in the 3rd quarter - not guilty
Tim Perkins (North) - attempting to strike Blythe in the 3rd quarter - 2 matches
Tim Perkins (North) - striking Peter Banfield in the last quarter - 1 match
Peter Banfield (West) - striking Perkins in the 4th quarter - 1 match
Shane Fitzsimmons (West) - striking Krieg in the 4th quarter - 3 matches

If anyone can help out on the verdicts of both Klomps' (that was postponed for 2 weeks as he was unavailable on a buisness trip, I think) and the Parsons and Goss reports - it wasn't reported in the Advertiser as far as I can see, that would be good.

The only differences in info I can see is you have the Banfield suspension for two matches - I have one. And you have the Goss report and suspension while I don't.

spell_check wrote:Dean Schumann (West) - by Argent for attempting to strike a North player "at least 10 times to the head" - 2 matches

How funny is that!!! "Yeah it was only 10 times, 2 weeks oughta cover it" lol

Constance_Perm wrote:

spell_check wrote:Dean Schumann (West) - by Argent for attempting to strike a North player "at least 10 times to the head" - 2 matches

How funny is that!!! "Yeah it was only 10 times, 2 weeks oughta cover it" lol

And attempted striking? So he tried it 10 times and missed each one?

Pseudo wrote:

Constance_Perm wrote:

spell_check wrote:Dean Schumann (West) - by Argent for attempting to strike a North player "at least 10 times to the head" - 2 matches

How funny is that!!! "Yeah it was only 10 times, 2 weeks oughta cover it" lol

And attempted striking? So he tried it 10 times and missed each one?

He must have gotten 2 matches for impersonating someone who could fight.

haha. Reminds me of Lynch in the 04 AFL GF who threw about 30 punches at Wakelin, missed every one of them and got given 9 matches.

Pseudo wrote:

Constance_Perm wrote:

spell_check wrote:Dean Schumann (West) - by Argent for attempting to strike a North player "at least 10 times to the head" - 2 matches

How funny is that!!! "Yeah it was only 10 times, 2 weeks oughta cover it" lol

And attempted striking? So he tried it 10 times and missed each one?

Sims was on my lap on the bench when Schumann belted him.

I was running water later and Sims couldn't see out of one eye, so Schumann didn't just attempt to strike him.