Page 1 of 1
AFL listed players in finals
Posted:
Tue Jul 11, 2006 2:13 pmby -
Who has been the most influential AFL listed player in helping his team win a premiership since the inception of the Crows?
You have to choose someone who played the majority of the season for their AFL side which means players like Cochran are ineligable.
My choice is Darel Hart 1991.
Posted:
Tue Jul 11, 2006 3:50 pmby Leaping Lindner
Hart immediately springs to mind for me. He was BOG or close to it in all three finals that year. To be honest though I probably haven't followed other clubs September successes that closely.
Posted:
Tue Jul 11, 2006 3:58 pmby drebin
Leaping Lindner wrote:Hart immediately springs to mind for me. He was BOG or close to it in all three finals that year. To be honest though I probably haven't followed other clubs September successes that closely.
That's because since 1991 there's been very little for us in terms of finals to watch the other sides!
Posted:
Tue Jul 11, 2006 5:09 pmby -
drebin wrote:Leaping Lindner wrote:Hart immediately springs to mind for me. He was BOG or close to it in all three finals that year. To be honest though I probably haven't followed other clubs September successes that closely.
That's because since 1991 there's been very little for us in terms of finals to watch the other sides!
10 finals to be exact.
Other clubs total finals 1992-2005 that have played less than North
South 0
Glenelg 9
West 11 (will be different after this year)
Posted:
Tue Jul 11, 2006 6:19 pmby Macca19
Trying to think back about the Magpies players.
92 saw Scotty play a great finals series. Kicked 6 goals in the big one.
Anderson was great in 1995. I think he only played about 4 games during the year.
98 was the year of the whingers. We had 7 AFL listed players in the GF side and everyone whinged that it was unfair despite the fact that all of them had spent considerable time at the Magpies that year.
We had:
P Burgoyne - 13 Games
D Brown - 13 Games
T Carr - 12 Games
B Chalmers - 14 Games
N Fiegert - 12 Games
T Ormond-Allen - 10 Games
S Tregenza - 9 Games
Fabian Francis just qualified with 3 games during the year but he never showed up to training and went missing so never played.
99 we had Chalmers who only played 4 matches (including the GF) and he kicked 3 goals and was a good performer in the GF.
Posted:
Tue Jul 11, 2006 10:30 pmby GWW
I'd say Darel Hart by far as well, given his performance on the day that matters.
Posted:
Tue Jul 11, 2006 11:19 pmby drebin
- wrote:drebin wrote:Leaping Lindner wrote:Hart immediately springs to mind for me. He was BOG or close to it in all three finals that year. To be honest though I probably haven't followed other clubs September successes that closely.
That's because since 1991 there's been very little for us in terms of finals to watch the other sides!
10 finals to be exact.
Other clubs total finals 1992-2005 that have played less than North
South 0
Glenelg 9
West 11 (will be different after this year)
It was meant to be a funny comment - not literal!
Posted:
Tue Jul 11, 2006 11:40 pmby -
drebin wrote:- wrote:drebin wrote:Leaping Lindner wrote:Hart immediately springs to mind for me. He was BOG or close to it in all three finals that year. To be honest though I probably haven't followed other clubs September successes that closely.
That's because since 1991 there's been very little for us in terms of finals to watch the other sides!
10 finals to be exact.
Other clubs total finals 1992-2005 that have played less than North
South 0
Glenelg 9
West 11 (will be different after this year)
It was meant to be a funny comment - not literal!
I knew that.
Posted:
Tue Jul 18, 2006 6:38 amby northernblue
Macca19 wrote:Trying to think back about the Magpies players.
92 saw Scotty play a great finals series. Kicked 6 goals in the big one.
Anderson was great in 1995. I think he only played about 4 games during the year.
98 was the year of the whingers. We had 7 AFL listed players in the GF side and everyone whinged that it was unfair despite the fact that all of them had spent considerable time at the Magpies that year.
We had:
P Burgoyne - 13 Games
D Brown - 13 Games
T Carr - 12 Games
B Chalmers - 14 Games
N Fiegert - 12 Games
T Ormond-Allen - 10 Games
S Tregenza - 9 Games
Fabian Francis just qualified with 3 games during the year but he never showed up to training and went missing so never played.
99 we had Chalmers who only played 4 matches (including the GF) and he kicked 3 goals and was a good performer in the GF.
In 98 don't forget one Brian Bienke...
Posted:
Tue Jul 18, 2006 7:54 amby am Bays
IIRC 1998 got Bienke back on an AFL list so he technically wasn't an AFL listed player when he took Scott Robinson (sorry Robbo) to teh cleaners....
Not 100% certain on that so I'll need confirmation cue Spelly......
Posted:
Thu Aug 10, 2006 5:36 pmby Aerie
Wayne Weidemann was a major player in the 1993 premiership. Think he played in the finals for the Crows and then was close to best on ground in the Grand Final for the Eagles, Steven Sziller just pipping him for the Jack Oatey Medal.
Posted:
Thu Aug 10, 2006 10:00 pmby Macca19
1980 Tassie Medalist wrote:IIRC 1998 got Bienke back on an AFL list so he technically wasn't an AFL listed player when he took Scott Robinson (sorry Robbo) to teh cleaners....
Not 100% certain on that so I'll need confirmation cue Spelly......
Beinke wasnt an AFL listed player in 1998. He had just come back from one year on North Melbournes rookie list.