SA Footy

I would like some feedback on the following jumpers, to see if I have them spot on or not.
Please advise on issues like- collar wrong colour, logo on chest too low, different shade of blue etc.
I have tried to capture these faithfully, & have had to resort to memory more often than not.

I think the SA was more in the center than that high?

Glenelg's socks have 3 gold hoops and the Gold sash is a bit wider to the collar.

Why in the back view are the shorts on backwards??

Port's is pretty close.

Being picky, there are six prison-bars on the guernsey.

And there's no centred white prison-bar below the v collar.

That's just black...

Strawb wrote:I think the SA was more in the center than that high?

...and just a tad smaller?...

Glenelg's sash could be a bit straighter

grant j wrote:Glenelg's socks have 3 gold hoops and the Gold sash is a bit wider to the collar.

Why in the back view are the shorts on backwards??

1) haven't worked on socks yet
2) have worked on the sash- made it straight in stead of curved
3) - as the shorts are "flat", the SANFL side panel can be seen front & back!

Mr66 wrote:

Strawb wrote:I think the SA was more in the center than that high?

...and just a tad smaller?...

Glenelg's sash could be a bit straighter

1) will take it on board
2) see above

Magpiespower wrote:Port's is pretty close.

Being picky, there are six prison-bars on the guernsey.

And there's no centred white prison-bar below the v collar.

That's just black...

I want picky- the more detail the better, as I'm going for accuracy.

Punk Rooster wrote:

grant j wrote:Glenelg's socks have 3 gold hoops and the Gold sash is a bit wider to the collar.

Why in the back view are the shorts on backwards??

1) haven't worked on socks yet
2) have worked on the sash- made it straight in stead of curved
3) - as the shorts are "flat", the SANFL side panel can be seen front & back!

Mr66 wrote:

Strawb wrote:I think the SA was more in the center than that high?

...and just a tad smaller?...

Glenelg's sash could be a bit straighter

1) will take it on board
2) see above

Magpiespower wrote:Port's is pretty close.

Being picky, there are six prison-bars on the guernsey.

And there's no centred white prison-bar below the v collar.

That's just black...

I want picky- the more detail the better, as I'm going for accuracy.

Are you able to show us your finished products mate,

is there anything in particular these are for.

Hope this helps - Mules image shows the front, and Kirks shows finishes at the side and bottom

Interesting..
I think punky's rough looks better than the actual guernsey in the picture.
That yellow sash is too wide and too prominent and the result is unbalanced to the eye..

Psyber wrote:Interesting..
I think punky's rough looks better than the actual guernsey in the picture.
That yellow sash is too wide and too prominent and the result is unbalanced to the eye..

Nah looks perfect Psyber ( especially with Ben Mules as the model )

Psyber wrote:Interesting..
I think punky's rough looks better than the actual guernsey in the picture.
That yellow sash is too wide and too prominent and the result is unbalanced to the eye..

Agreed, looks more like an entrant to the Miss South Australia quest than a footy guernsey.

I think all the socks should have white feet

Psyber wrote:Interesting..
I think punky's rough looks better than the actual guernsey in the picture.

Agreed
...and doesn't have any god-awful advertising either...

I think the WT and WA guernseys need a bend in the sash.

Punky what era are you going for here? It looks like the early 80s to 1990? WT wore yellow shorts in 1980 and Westies' sash didn't go around the back in 1981 (a manufacturing error I heard somewhere).

Hondo wrote:I think the WT and WA guernseys need a bend in the sash.

Punky what era are you going for here? It looks like the early 80s to 1990? WT wore yellow shorts in 1980 and Westies' sash didn't go around the back in 1981 (a manufacturing error I heard somewhere).

not sure to be honest- you'll note i've used the old badges (where I could- see WA & Sturt), & try to reflect that era.
Both NA & CD have the new logos, & their current design.
As for the WT & WA- more like the one in my first Glenelg jumper?

Hondo wrote:I think the WT and WA guernseys need a bend in the sash.

Ooh no.
The bend looks horrible
Essendon's current jumper is proof of that.
And North's vee is pointed

Mr66 wrote:

Hondo wrote:I think the WT and WA guernseys need a bend in the sash.

Ooh no.
The bend looks horrible
Essendon's current jumper is proof of that.
And North's vee is pointed

I mean the WT and WA ones should be like the Glenelg one. Shouldn't they? I thought WT was just the same as GL.

Punky, they all look very professional BTW. Have you seen this web site?

http://www.footyjumpers.com/

Hondo wrote:

Mr66 wrote:

Hondo wrote:I think the WT and WA guernseys need a bend in the sash.

Ooh no.
The bend looks horrible
Essendon's current jumper is proof of that.
And North's vee is pointed

I mean the WT and WA ones should be like the Glenelg one. Shouldn't they? I thought WT was just the same as GL.

Punky, they all look very professional BTW. Have you seen this web site?

http://www.footyjumpers.com/

yeah, I have- it's a great site.
I've "fixed" the Glenelg jumper, to make it "straight"...