bennymacca wrote:Why do/should the rules preclude a player playing from a lower grade?
You didn't answer the question at all, aside from being a dick about it. Also it's pretty obvious that they are regular A2 players so you enforcing that rule would just be because you are scared of getting rolled again.
I just worked out what you're complaining about.
Lets assume for a second the A2 game in question had been delayed to the following day (Sunday). Would you then agree that no player playing in that game could have also played the day before in A1 or A4 sides ? Certainly many years ago when the turf pitches were getting laid, a lot of our A1 games were held on Sundays, and we were not permitted to play other grades in the same round.
If you agree both of the above are valid assertions, then its logical to understand that players cannot play in multiple grades in the same round (player subs excluded), and to be honest, any fair minded person would understand why playing a player in two grades in the same round isn't permitted.
If your club threw a few of your better A2's in the A4s for that weekend, then they did so with a lack of forethought. That being said, if the club was under the assumption that the A2 game had been abandoned (points split) rather than delayed, then they would have a case.
[PS - I am not an Angaston player, fan, or anything else, in fact I can think of nothing better than knocking them off]