SA Footy

The process that was used was certainly baffling and I think definitely contributed towards the reaction, a reaction that im sure would have been handled better if he had his time again. Everyone would have rathered the umpires take a few minutes to sum up the situation, talk it through and then make a decision. That decision should then stand and players should be warned if they disagree and carry on.

Sounded like the batter middled on to his pad.
How'd the umpire not hear that.
But hey everyone makes mistakes and the Umpires don't need that sort of carry on.

tigerpie wrote:Sounded like the batter middled on to his pad.
How'd the umpire not hear that.
But hey everyone makes mistakes and the Umpires don't need that sort of carry on.

He did hear it hey….thats why he gave the lbw not out

What he didn’t see was the catch.

Grange finish 5th in A1, just one point out of the 4, having lost several points from the Sayers incident.

Trader wrote:Grange finish 5th in A1, just one point out of the 4, having lost several points from the Sayers incident.

That is Karma, how elite. Would not be too many people around the place that would not be over the moon with that result.

Hopefully the club now sacks Sayers as captain and show some balls

So ingle farm have snuck into the four on the back of 5 wins in there last 6 games with one being outright. Snuck in by a point over Grange pending the appeal. If this appeal gets over turned in anyway and the points Grange have been deducted get reinstated are part there will f for a terrible incident will be a disgrace and shows that the big clubs get favourable decisions. Happened a couple of years ago when a grange player was reported by umpires in another terrible incident only to appeal with certain allegation against the opposition which were believed at the tribunal but these allegations were false. Points reinstated. Pretty sure it cost ingle farm finals. Tribunal hearing I’ve been told is set for Friday. That’s a joke in its self, ingle farm preparing to play and could possible have there season ended pending appeal.
Ingle farm lost 2 points in the debacle against Port districts and had a player suspended . No report for umpire in this game nuts report lodged by Port districts . Those 2 points could have seen ingle farm displace goodwood .
Standard of umpiring and knowing bylaws and player behaviour quite possibly at an all time low in atca

I am curious, how many times can you appeal a decision, friday isn't ideal for either raise trying to prepare is it, I'd of thought if the points could be overturned the league wouldn't of already applied them on the ladder ?

Outside of that Ingle Farm certainly have flown home strong, where it seems Goodwood have some injury concerns, Gleadall not bowling etc.

Interesting end to the season.

Semi-Finals
Saturday 16th and Sunday 17th March
A1
Para Hills v Ingle Farm/Goodwood (Lindblom Park – Oval #1)
Pooraka v Goodwood/Grange (Para Hills Oval #1)

A2
Brighton v SPOC (Brighton Oval)
PAOC v Adelaide Lions (Park 9)

A3
Brahma Lodge v Hectorville (Brahma Lodge Oval)
Payneham v Old Ignatians (Payneham Oval)

B1
Pooraka v Hope Valley (Lindblom Park #2)
Grange v Reynella (Grange Oval #1)

B2
Adelaide Lions v Port District (West Beach Playing Fields #2)
Brighton v Blue Brigade (Brighton Oval #2)

B3
Unley v Brighton (Kingswood Oval)
Adelaide University v Reynella (Park 10 #1)

C1
PAOC v Reynella (Park 15 #1)
Grange v Trinity OS (Grange Oval #2)

Saturday 16th March
LO1
Port District v Gepps Cross (Largs Reserve)
Pembroke OS v Punjab Lions (Haslam Oval)

LO2
Rostrevor OC v Pulteney OS (Rostrevor College – Main Oval)
Old Scotch v Pembroke OS (Scotch College #2)

LO3
Old Concordians v SHOC (Concordia College)
Mawson Lakes v Adelaide Warriors (Mawson Lakes Oval)

LO4
Hope Valley v Blue Brigade (Hope Valley Oval)
Trinity OS v Pembroke OS (Trinity College #3)

LO5
Payneham v Old Concordians (Devitt Oval)
Fulham v Hectorville (Collins Reserve #1)

LO6
Flinders University v Pooraka (Flinders University Oval #1)
Old Ignatians v Blue Brigade (St Ignatius – Baulderstone Oval)

LO7
Unley v Woodville Rechabite (Scotch College – Montrose Oval)
Pulteney OS v Mawson Lakes (Pulteney Grammar – Morgan Oval)

Bluedemon wrote:Semi-Finals
Saturday 16th and Sunday 17th March
A1
Para Hills v Ingle Farm/Goodwood (Lindblom Park – Oval #1)
Pooraka v Goodwood/Grange (Para Hills Oval #1)

A2
Brighton v SPOC (Brighton Oval)
PAOC v Adelaide Lions (Park 9)

A3
Brahma Lodge v Hectorville (Brahma Lodge Oval)
Payneham v Old Ignatians (Payneham Oval)

B1
Pooraka v Hope Valley (Lindblom Park #2)
Grange v Reynella (Grange Oval #1)

B2
Adelaide Lions v Port District (West Beach Playing Fields #2)
Brighton v Blue Brigade (Brighton Oval #2)

B3
Unley v Brighton (Kingswood Oval)
Adelaide University v Reynella (Park 10 #1)

C1
PAOC v Reynella (Park 15 #1)
Grange v Trinity OS (Grange Oval #2)

Para Hills could play Grange in A1

Bluedemon wrote:Semi-Finals
Saturday 16th and Sunday 17th March
A1
Para Hills v Ingle Farm/Goodwood (Lindblom Park – Oval #1)
Pooraka v Goodwood/Grange (Para Hills Oval #1)

Technically Grange could also finish 4th, if they get some, but not all, of their points back, meaning they might also be Para Hill's opponent.

I can't see them getting anything back, but hey, stranger things have happened before!

Yeah, what SMG said

Is it the eve of the Semi final and we are still yet to find out who is playing who?

I don't think it's being heard until late afternoon mate.

Crazy

Bluedemon wrote:LO6
Pooraka v Woodville South (TBA)
Old Ignatians v Blue Brigade (St Ignatius – Baulderstone Oval)

Gotta feel sorry for Pooraka, qualify to host the final and end up playing Flinders Uni at Flinders Uni!

Trader wrote:

Bluedemon wrote:LO6
Pooraka v Woodville South (TBA)
Old Ignatians v Blue Brigade (St Ignatius – Baulderstone Oval)

Gotta feel sorry for Pooraka, qualify to host the final and end up playing Flinders Uni at Flinders Uni!

how the hell does that happen?

no_remorse28 wrote:I don't think it's being heard until late afternoon mate.

very reminiscent of Golden Grove and Iggs a few years back. we had no idea who we were playing in the GF until the night before

ATCA surely can not back down here though, you have a side thinking they have scraped in and then to potentially take it away would be brutal

Sonofbrowny25 wrote:

Trader wrote:

Bluedemon wrote:LO6
Pooraka v Woodville South (TBA)
Old Ignatians v Blue Brigade (St Ignatius – Baulderstone Oval)

Gotta feel sorry for Pooraka, qualify to host the final and end up playing Flinders Uni at Flinders Uni!

how the hell does that happen?

I think Pooraka's As and Bs are both hosting so they didn't have a third oval for their D's to also host.
Not sure what the go is with the change from Woody South to Flinders Uni though...

Trader wrote:

Sonofbrowny25 wrote:

Trader wrote:

Bluedemon wrote:LO6
Pooraka v Woodville South (TBA)
Old Ignatians v Blue Brigade (St Ignatius – Baulderstone Oval)

Gotta feel sorry for Pooraka, qualify to host the final and end up playing Flinders Uni at Flinders Uni!

how the hell does that happen?

I think Pooraka's As and Bs are both hosting so they didn't have a third oval for their D's to also host.
Not sure what the go is with the change from Woody South to Flinders Uni though...

I did notice that it has been changed to Flinders Uni, looks like Woodville South lost 5 points for some reason