SA Footy

Are Pooraka and Pulteney appealing the decision in the LO6 and LO7 GF's?

Bluedemon wrote:Are Pooraka and Pulteney appealing the decision in the LO6 and LO7 GF's?

Yeah the LO6 game has now been set to Old Iggies vs TBC so it seems Pooraka have lodged an appeal.
Both clubs are obviously within their rights to go through the process.

It is interesting though, 14 grades, 28 semi finals, 56 teams selecting 616 players.
614 were eligible.
When 99.7% can get it right, it's hard to have sympathy for those that didn't follow the rules.

Trader wrote:

Bluedemon wrote:Are Pooraka and Pulteney appealing the decision in the LO6 and LO7 GF's?

Yeah the LO6 game has now been set to Old Iggies vs TBC so it seems Pooraka have lodged an appeal.
Both clubs are obviously within their rights to go through the process.

It is interesting though, 14 grades, 28 semi finals, 56 teams selecting 616 players.
614 were eligible.
When 99.7% can get it right, it's hard to have sympathy for those that didn't follow the rules.

I agree with you

Great to see a decent crowd turn out Sunday for the Women's division 1 Grand Final between Para Hills and Reynella.

Was a hard fought contest, I thought Greg Gade spoke well on behalf of ATCA When presenting the awards and both sides captains spoke well after the game. Can only see the league growing from here.

Any news yet from the Pooraka and Pulteney Appeals hearing?

anyone willing to have a crack at the medals tonight? and TOTY

A1 - allrounder of the year - Hamish Winter- Irving and probably should win the medal but not winning games will hurt. Brodrick will be the danger
A2 - Pemachandra would be my bet
A3 - Tom Durrant with 350 and 30 wickets

TOTY

Broderick
Cuconits
Hermann
wordsworth
Caton
wilkins / white
A2 medal winner
C sayers
Winter- Irving
Shaminda
mcdonald

Sonofbrowny25 wrote:anyone willing to have a crack at the medals tonight? and TOTY

A1 - allrounder of the year - Hamish Winter- Irving and probably should win the medal but not winning games will hurt. Brodrick will be the danger
A2 - Pemachandra would be my bet
A3 - Tom Durrant with 350 and 30 wickets

TOTY

Broderick
Cuconits
Hermann
wordsworth
Caton
wilkins / white
A2 medal winner
C sayers
Winter- Irving
Shaminda
mcdonald

A1 - Hamish Winter- Irving, Think T.Wordsworth might poll a few as well.
A2 - N.Clayfield
A3 - J.Richter-Gilbert

WK of the year H.Caton
All rounder Winter-Irving
Fielder T.Baker

TOTY

Broderick
Cuconits
Hermann
Wordsworth
Caton WK
Wilkins
Winter-Irving
Clayfield
Mcdonald
Winter- Irving
Mcdonald

Caton to do the double, WK of the year and A1 player of the year ahead of Winter-Irvine
N Clayfield for A2 ahead of Saha
A3 medal to be a tie between Richter-Gilbert and Tommy Durrant

no_remorse28 wrote:

Sonofbrowny25 wrote:anyone willing to have a crack at the medals tonight? and TOTY

A1 - allrounder of the year - Hamish Winter- Irving and probably should win the medal but not winning games will hurt. Brodrick will be the danger
A2 - Pemachandra would be my bet
A3 - Tom Durrant with 350 and 30 wickets

TOTY

Broderick
Cuconits
Hermann
wordsworth
Caton
wilkins / white
A2 medal winner
C sayers
Winter- Irving
Shaminda
mcdonald

A1 - Hamish Winter- Irving, Think T.Wordsworth might poll a few as well.
A2 - N.Clayfield
A3 - J.Richter-Gilbert

WK of the year H.Caton
All rounder Winter-Irving
Fielder T.Baker

TOTY

Broderick
Cuconits
Hermann
Wordsworth
Caton WK
Wilkins
Winter-Irving
Clayfield
Mcdonald
Winter- Irving
Mcdonald

he was so good you picked hamish twice

Apologies, was meant to be the other hyphen, from A3, J.Richter-Gilbert

A1 - Para Hills
A2 - PAOC
A3 - Payneham
B1 - Reynella
B2 - Blue Brigade
B3 - Brighton
C1 - PAOC
LO1 - Punjab Lions
LO2 - Pembroke
LO3 - Mawson Lakes
LO4 - Pembroke
LO5 - Fulham
LO6 - Old Iggies
LO7 - Unley Gunners

I'll be happy if I can get 8 or more.

Whydontya wrote:

Bluedemon wrote:Grand Finals
Saturday 23rd & Sunday 24th March

A1
Para Hills v Goodwood (Para Hills Oval #1 – Triton Plumbing & Gas Oval)

A2
PAOC v SPOC (Park 9)

A3
Payneham v Hectorville (Payneham Oval)

B1
Reynella v Hope Valley (Reynella Oval)

B2
Adelaide Lions v Blue Brigade (West Beach Playing Fields – Oval 2)

B3
Adelaide University v Brighton (Park 10 – No. 1)

C1
PAOC v Trinity OS (Park 15 – Oval #1)

Payneham oval hosting A3 grand final. The worst pitch in ATCA. 85 Could be a winning score

You picked it, Payneham rolled for 74

Hectorville currently 5/18

Hectorville end up 6 for 20 which makes it 16 for 94 on day 1. There was a time when Payneham had the best square in Adelaide Turf. Bit sad really.

Senor Moto Gadili wrote:Hectorville end up 6 for 20 which makes it 16 for 94 on day 1. There was a time when Payneham had the best square in Adelaide Turf. Bit sad really.

ATCA set all these requirements to host a final but don't care about the actual state of the oval. Only 2 boundaries in a days play and it wasn't because of a lack of good shots.

Travis might be wishing he spoke differently at the presentation night now.

Travis might be wishing he spoke differently at the presentation night now.

Port Pirie Power wrote:Travis might be wishing he spoke differently at the presentation night now.

Ain't karma great

Senor Moto Gadili wrote:

Port Pirie Power wrote:Travis might be wishing he spoke differently at the presentation night now.

Ain't karma great

Yep the 'Prince of ATCA' might have got that one wrong on prezo night. In fairness to him, he didn't fire shots at Goodwood, but sure did to the rest of the A1 clubs.

Shame about Payneham Oval and that final. Never would have happened under Keith Duke's watch. The club has fallen a bit since their glory days under his reign, but good to see they've got out of A3.

ATCA Premiers

A1 - Goodwood
A2 - PAOC
A3 - Payneham
B1 - Reynella
B2 - Adelaide Lions
B3 - Brighton
C1 - PAOC
LO1 - Port District
LO2 - Pembroke OS
LO3 - SHOC
LO4 - Hope Valley
LO5 - Payneham
LO6 - Old Ignatians
LO7 - Unley

Under_Scrutiny wrote:

Senor Moto Gadili wrote:

Port Pirie Power wrote:Travis might be wishing he spoke differently at the presentation night now.

Ain't karma great

Yep the 'Prince of ATCA' might have got that one wrong on prezo night. In fairness to him, he didn't fire shots at Goodwood, but sure did to the rest of the A1 clubs.

Shame about Payneham Oval and that final. Never would have happened under Keith Duke's watch. The club has fallen a bit since their glory days under his reign, but good to see they've got out of A3.

What was said?