Best League/Association

[Andy #24]

can anybody rank the following leagues in order
div1
western border
div 2
div3
sfl
hills
gsfl

would that be right ???????????????????????????????????

Div 3? I don't think so. None of the Div 3 sides would play finals in any of the above country comps. Yes Div 1 is the clear stand out but it is contentious after that. For all round depth you would probably have to go with Division 2 next but sides like Willunga & Mt.Lofty would smash most Div 2 sides.

After that it is really tight between the GSFL, SFL and Hills Central comps. Haven't seen the Western Border comp so cannot comment but if it is as good as everyone says it is then you would have to throw them in to the mix.

I think you are being a little parochial ted. Div 3 is on par with most country comps.

[tedbullpit]

can anybody rank the following leagues in order
div1
western border
div 2
div3
sfl
hills
gsfl

would that be right ???????????????????????????????????

Div 3? I don't think so. None of the Div 3 sides would play finals in any of the above country comps. Yes Div 1 is the clear stand out but it is contentious after that. For all round depth you would probably have to go with Division 2 next but sides like Willunga & Mt.Lofty would smash most Div 2 sides.

After that it is really tight between the GSFL, SFL and Hills Central comps. Haven't seen the Western Border comp so cannot comment but if it is as good as everyone says it is then you would have to throw them in to the mix.

I think you are being a little parochial ted. Div 3 is on par with most country comps.

Andy,

Have played Both Div 3 and Country Footy and have played with and against a lot of players in both Div 3 and HFL and I'm telling you Athelstone or SMOSH would not get near the Top 4 HFL Central, SFL & GSFL clubs.