SA Footy

The Gimp wrote:What are we handing Bridgy the cup already??
Bridgy are doing OK but aren't near the level Lofty were last year or Echunga the year before.
Both A's and B's are a pretty open comp in div 2 at the moment and probably any of the top 3-5 side in both grades could win it on any given day IMHO.

Out of interest, when would've been the last time (if ever) Nairne have played at Bridgewater? Did they really struggle with the small confines or just didn't bother defending all day??
Fair shoot-out with 71 shots on goal for the game!!

97 or 98 when Nairne were in Div 1 before they went to RMFL for 4 years.

cracka wrote:

The Gimp wrote:What are we handing Bridgy the cup already??
Bridgy are doing OK but aren't near the level Lofty were last year or Echunga the year before.
Both A's and B's are a pretty open comp in div 2 at the moment and probably any of the top 3-5 side in both grades could win it on any given day IMHO.

Out of interest, when would've been the last time (if ever) Nairne have played at Bridgewater? Did they really struggle with the small confines or just didn't bother defending all day??
Fair shoot-out with 71 shots on goal for the game!!

97 or 98 when Nairne were in Div 1 before they went to RMFL for 4 years.

Our last game at Bridgewater was our last game in Division 1 in 2001 where we played in a foot of mud with some of the worst conditions I can remember. The oval was much better this time round but I don't think the facilities have changed one bit. Pretty disappointing really, surely they need to spend some money on these before even being considered for Division 1 again.

Bridgy were a much better side on Saturday and beat NB hands down. We didn't handle the small oval well and many of our players were down. I'd expect a much better performance next time round.

RAMS wrote:

cracka wrote:

The Gimp wrote:What are we handing Bridgy the cup already??
Bridgy are doing OK but aren't near the level Lofty were last year or Echunga the year before.
Both A's and B's are a pretty open comp in div 2 at the moment and probably any of the top 3-5 side in both grades could win it on any given day IMHO.

Out of interest, when would've been the last time (if ever) Nairne have played at Bridgewater? Did they really struggle with the small confines or just didn't bother defending all day??
Fair shoot-out with 71 shots on goal for the game!!

97 or 98 when Nairne were in Div 1 before they went to RMFL for 4 years.

Our last game at Bridgewater was our last game in Division 1 in 2001 where we played in a foot of mud with some of the worst conditions I can remember. The oval was much better this time round but I don't think the facilities have changed one bit. Pretty disappointing really, surely they need to spend some money on these before even being considered for Division 1 again.

Bridgy were a much better side on Saturday and beat NB hands down. We didn't handle the small oval well and many of our players were down. I'd expect a much better performance next time round.

Oh yeah, you came back from RMFL in 98, der cracka

RAMS wrote:

cracka wrote:

The Gimp wrote:What are we handing Bridgy the cup already??
Bridgy are doing OK but aren't near the level Lofty were last year or Echunga the year before.
Both A's and B's are a pretty open comp in div 2 at the moment and probably any of the top 3-5 side in both grades could win it on any given day IMHO.

Out of interest, when would've been the last time (if ever) Nairne have played at Bridgewater? Did they really struggle with the small confines or just didn't bother defending all day??
Fair shoot-out with 71 shots on goal for the game!!

97 or 98 when Nairne were in Div 1 before they went to RMFL for 4 years.

Our last game at Bridgewater was our last game in Division 1 in 2001 where we played in a foot of mud with some of the worst conditions I can remember. The oval was much better this time round but I don't think the facilities have changed one bit. Pretty disappointing really, surely they need to spend some money on these before even being considered for Division 1 again.

Bridgy were a much better side on Saturday and beat NB hands down. We didn't handle the small oval well and many of our players were down. I'd expect a much better performance next time round.

Wow!!

I suppose on that logic that we should include ovals. How many clubs now shouldn't be in division 1? And just to be clear Bridgewater have 3, yes 3 ovals including in my opinion the jewel in the HFL crown at Callington.

Sorry but I'm not sure why you would say that the standard of facilities you can afford should be a requirement for division 1.

Cracka, I agree that no 1 team yet should be claiming supremacy.
I wonder how much difference a large oval would make NB v Bridgee and what about Hancock? Surely a big impact with him back in.
There's plenty of games to go and it has been enjoyable seeing so many good teams go at it knowing that as you say any 1 of them could win on the day.

This old chestnut ! Now i haven't been around for the past 3 seasons and bridgys rooms wernt flash BUT mt barkers away rooms were just as bad not to mention torrens valleys were just as bad and i haven't been to cally since 2000 and they were diabolical ...
question being have any of these clubs spent any money in this area ?
All good to have pot shots at shanty but there are or were others that were just as bad if not worse !

looks like Quino got the kid he was after, James Mapstone is now playing for Gums after starting the season with Poooooooooraka, was playing div 2 last year for Broadview and only left because the weed wasnt giving him a regular go in the A grade also his brother is at Gums too, only 19 but very talented kid, kicks on both legs and not afraid of the bigger guys, noticed he was 2nd or 3rd best in his first game, hope Quino offered him more than a drinks card for his services

I see a very worrying trend developing that could spell the end for some smaller Div 2 clubs

2 years ago Echunga undefeated
Mt Lofty relegated, recruited, won undefeated
Bridgewater relegated, currently undefeated.
If things continue going as par course Bridgewater go back up, Onkas will be relegated.
A club like that will get players back from injury and players sensing a flag, will probably take out a flag.
What then? What's Gumeracha, Birdwood, Meadows and other such clubs going to do? Echunga have exceeded all expectations and good luck to them but they are the expection.

I think we need a massive overhaul of the whole competition. Clubs need to be zoned off for juniors and clubs need to merge.
Clubs like Gum, Birdwood, Kersbrook, Torrens Valley, even Lobey to an extent.
Kangarilla, Meadows, Maccy...
some tough calls need to be made otherwise there won't be ANY footy played in some of these smaller clubs in a couple of years.

Has association team squad been announced yet

Kick'n Back wrote:Has association team squad been announced yet

10 div 2 players at training Wednesday night with another 8 wanting to play but unable to train and a couple injured but OK for the long weekend.

But this from Chopper7 on the Div1 forum

Division 1 been cancelled because of lack of support from players and clubs. Attendance over the 2 nights last week were 3 Lobethal, 3 Uri, 3 Mt Barker 1 Mt Lofty and 1 Onkas.

redsox wrote:

Kick'n Back wrote:Has association team squad been announced yet

10 div 2 players at training Wednesday night with another 8 wanting to play but unable to train and a couple injured but OK for the long weekend.

But this from Chopper7 on the Div1 forum

Division 1 been cancelled because of lack of support from players and clubs. Attendance over the 2 nights last week were 3 Lobethal, 3 Uri, 3 Mt Barker 1 Mt Lofty and 1 Onkas.

Has anyone seen the list of names selected in squad

samantic wrote:

RAMS wrote:

cracka wrote:

The Gimp wrote:What are we handing Bridgy the cup already??
Bridgy are doing OK but aren't near the level Lofty were last year or Echunga the year before.
Both A's and B's are a pretty open comp in div 2 at the moment and probably any of the top 3-5 side in both grades could win it on any given day IMHO.

Out of interest, when would've been the last time (if ever) Nairne have played at Bridgewater? Did they really struggle with the small confines or just didn't bother defending all day??
Fair shoot-out with 71 shots on goal for the game!!

97 or 98 when Nairne were in Div 1 before they went to RMFL for 4 years.

Our last game at Bridgewater was our last game in Division 1 in 2001 where we played in a foot of mud with some of the worst conditions I can remember. The oval was much better this time round but I don't think the facilities have changed one bit. Pretty disappointing really, surely they need to spend some money on these before even being considered for Division 1 again.

Bridgy were a much better side on Saturday and beat NB hands down. We didn't handle the small oval well and many of our players were down. I'd expect a much better performance next time round.

Wow!!

I suppose on that logic that we should include ovals. How many clubs now shouldn't be in division 1? And just to be clear Bridgewater have 3, yes 3 ovals including in my opinion the jewel in the HFL crown at Callington.

Sorry but I'm not sure why you would say that the standard of facilities you can afford should be a requirement for division 1.

Cracka, I agree that no 1 team yet should be claiming supremacy.
I wonder how much difference a large oval would make NB v Bridgee and what about Hancock? Surely a big impact with him back in.
There's plenty of games to go and it has been enjoyable seeing so many good teams go at it knowing that as you say any 1 of them could win on the day.

Our facilities at worst were still better than bridgewaters. Was there on Anzac Day, strange setup indeed

Wow!!

I suppose on that logic that we should include ovals. How many clubs now shouldn't be in division 1? And just to be clear Bridgewater have 3, yes 3 ovals including in my opinion the jewel in the HFL crown at Callington.

Sorry but I'm not sure why you would say that the standard of facilities you can afford should be a requirement for division 1.

Cracka, I agree that no 1 team yet should be claiming supremacy.
I wonder how much difference a large oval would make NB v Bridgee and what about Hancock? Surely a big impact with him back in.
There's plenty of games to go and it has been enjoyable seeing so many good teams go at it knowing that as you say any 1 of them could win on the day.[/quote]
Our facilities at worst were still better than bridgewaters. Was there on Anzac Day, strange setup indeed[/quote]

I agree but the question is should that be a qualification for division 1?

I assume the Meadows and Gumeracha scores are wrong in both the A's and B's on sporting pulse?

Esteban Vihaio wrote:I assume the Meadows and Gumeracha scores are wrong in both the A's and B's on sporting pulse?

Meadows run away to a 15 goal win in the end for the A grade

samantic wrote:Wow!!

I suppose on that logic that we should include ovals. How many clubs now shouldn't be in division 1? And just to be clear Bridgewater have 3, yes 3 ovals including in my opinion the jewel in the HFL crown at Callington.

Sorry but I'm not sure why you would say that the standard of facilities you can afford should be a requirement for division 1.

Cracka, I agree that no 1 team yet should be claiming supremacy.
I wonder how much difference a large oval would make NB v Bridgee and what about Hancock? Surely a big impact with him back in.
There's plenty of games to go and it has been enjoyable seeing so many good teams go at it knowing that as you say any 1 of them could win on the day.

Our facilities at worst were still better than bridgewaters. Was there on Anzac Day, strange setup indeed[/quote]

I agree but the question is should that be a qualification for division 1?[/quote]

I really can't understand why some people talk so highly about the Callington oval... sure its big, and dry when the hills oval are wet.... but the facilities are awful. Back in my playing days the oval surface was littered with 3 corner jacks. I remember pulling them out of my knees after games. Footy is a winter sport so expect a bit of mud.

doubletrouble wrote:

Esteban Vihaio wrote:I assume the Meadows and Gumeracha scores are wrong in both the A's and B's on sporting pulse?

Meadows run away to a 15 goal win in the end for the A grade

How much lower can Gumeracha get??? Reports from Saturday suggest they played a player not registered under a different name in the A-Grade! Pity this player was pretty well known as he used to live in the area.

What's next??

Birdwood are really starting to gel together now and the results are suggesting so. Maccy was never going to be an easy game but was a good measuring stick to see where we were at. To come from 4 goals down at quarter time and win by 7 goals in sloppy conditions was a great effort by all, had we kicked straight it could have been more.

Hope the bloke from Maccy who got taken to hospital has pulled up ok, i didn't see the incident but saw the aftermath and it didn't look pretty.

Looking forward to the break as there are some battered and bruised bodies and then to take on the much improved Sedan before having another crack at the top 3.

http://www.adelaidenow.com.au/sport/afl ... 7428400863

So this will apply to HFL i assume? Gonna change the dynamics of some clubs pretty drastically

19thman wrote:http://www.adelaidenow.com.au/sport/afl ... 7428400863

So this will apply to HFL i assume? Gonna change the dynamics of some clubs pretty drastically

I don't think it is going to effect Division 2 HFL a great deal, but Division 1 will be a different matter along with most other Leagues.

Who's coaching Gumeracha these days?