SAAFL Div 5 & Div 5R (2011)

[Lightning McQueen]

Im pretty certain I know who it was. Salisbury West's current coach was the coach at North Haven at the time I reckon.

I am not going to comment on the guy as I don't know him and did not witness any other incidents so im in no position to comment on them, other than the one I just mentioned which I witnessed from about 5 metres away

I also only mentioned it to illustrate that is unfair to mention Ricky in the same sentence as the other guy as I have never seen him Ricky do anything at all of this nature.

I'm just saying that I find it hard to beleive that Tyson would do that.

[Robran]

Well my biased view of Ricky is that he is a top bloke and a great player who plays very hard and gives as good as he gets.

As for Creek, I don't know the bloke and I wasn't present for his previous offences so I can't comment on them. However I can comment on behalf of the North Haven player he kicked square in the face in the worst act of violence I have seen on a football ground in 23 years of footy and that is he is banned for a very good reason.

You might want to check your facts on which Creek you are referring to mate.

Im pretty certain I know who it was. Salisbury West's current coach was the coach at North Haven at the time I reckon.

I am not going to comment on the guy as I don't know him and did not witness any other incidents so im in no position to comment on them, other than the one I just mentioned which I witnessed from about 5 metres away

I also only mentioned it to illustrate that is unfair to mention Ricky in the same sentence as the other guy as I have never seen him Ricky do anything at all of this nature.

um gee i only mentioned them both because they were the 2 players that stood out on sun in trial simple as that and ricky can play thats for sure. and yeah rick had a few words to say to his former team mates i was told but me think all tongue in cheek.

[mighty hounds]

Well my biased view of Ricky is that he is a top bloke and a great player who plays very hard and gives as good as he gets.

As for Creek, I don't know the bloke and I wasn't present for his previous offences so I can't comment on them. However I can comment on behalf of the North Haven player he kicked square in the face in the worst act of violence I have seen on a football ground in 23 years of footy and that is he is banned for a very good reason.

You might want to check your facts on which Creek you are referring to mate.

Im pretty certain I know who it was. Salisbury West's current coach was the coach at North Haven at the time I reckon.

I am not going to comment on the guy as I don't know him and did not witness any other incidents so im in no position to comment on them, other than the one I just mentioned which I witnessed from about 5 metres away

I also only mentioned it to illustrate that is unfair to mention Ricky in the same sentence as the other guy as I have never seen him Ricky do anything at all of this nature.

um gee i only mentioned them both because they were the 2 players that stood out on sun in trial simple as that and ricky can play thats for sure. and yeah rick had a few words to say to his former team mates i was told but me think all tongue in cheek.

Surley if it was in the huddle Robran you would of heard it first hand?

[Boosh]

Well my biased view of Ricky is that he is a top bloke and a great player who plays very hard and gives as good as he gets.

As for Creek, I don't know the bloke and I wasn't present for his previous offences so I can't comment on them. However I can comment on behalf of the North Haven player he kicked square in the face in the worst act of violence I have seen on a football ground in 23 years of footy and that is he is banned for a very good reason.

You might want to check your facts on which Creek you are referring to mate.

Im pretty certain I know who it was. Salisbury West's current coach was the coach at North Haven at the time I reckon.

I am not going to comment on the guy as I don't know him and did not witness any other incidents so im in no position to comment on them, other than the one I just mentioned which I witnessed from about 5 metres away

I also only mentioned it to illustrate that is unfair to mention Ricky in the same sentence as the other guy as I have never seen him Ricky do anything at all of this nature.

um gee i only mentioned them both because they were the 2 players that stood out on sun in trial simple as that and ricky can play thats for sure. and yeah rick had a few words to say to his former team mates i was told but me think all tongue in cheek.

No probs mate, didn't think you were saying they are the same just pointing out my differnet opinions on the two.

[Boosh]

Im pretty certain I know who it was. Salisbury West's current coach was the coach at North Haven at the time I reckon.

I am not going to comment on the guy as I don't know him and did not witness any other incidents so im in no position to comment on them, other than the one I just mentioned which I witnessed from about 5 metres away

I also only mentioned it to illustrate that is unfair to mention Ricky in the same sentence as the other guy as I have never seen him Ricky do anything at all of this nature.

I'm just saying that I find it hard to beleive that Tyson would do that.

OK no worries. I won't comment on it again.

[Howgdizhe]

Im pretty certain I know who it was. Salisbury West's current coach was the coach at North Haven at the time I reckon.

I am not going to comment on the guy as I don't know him and did not witness any other incidents so im in no position to comment on them, other than the one I just mentioned which I witnessed from about 5 metres away

I also only mentioned it to illustrate that is unfair to mention Ricky in the same sentence as the other guy as I have never seen him Ricky do anything at all of this nature.

I'm just saying that I find it hard to beleive that Tyson would do that.

OK no worries. I won't comment on it again.

Probaly the best thing to do boosh....

[Howgdizhe]

Salisbury West to win the flag this year, no problems.

Im with you there NO MERCY.... Your olmate Geoffrey part of the coaching staff and very excited down at the downs

[Footy Chick]

Salisbury West to win the flag this year, no problems.

Im with you there NO MERCY.... Your olmate Geoffrey part of the coaching staff and very excited down at the downs

I can't believe you're going around again We're all taking sweeps on when you pull another calf

Shortest odds are on getting out of the car before the first game

As long as you last long enough to help me with operation "backyard blitz"

[beeched iizzz]

Why would that be best? Just a bit of a sweep it under the rug issue hey??? Ol Lightning defends the guy...Fine. You start tellin blokes to drop issue. the issue is only relevant due to the names history. if you dont want the discussion dont get a reputation.

Im pretty certain I know who it was. Salisbury West's current coach was the coach at North Haven at the time I reckon.

I am not going to comment on the guy as I don't know him and did not witness any other incidents so im in no position to comment on them, other than the one I just mentioned which I witnessed from about 5 metres away

I also only mentioned it to illustrate that is unfair to mention Ricky in the same sentence as the other guy as I have never seen him Ricky do anything at all of this nature.

I'm just saying that I find it hard to beleive that Tyson would do that.

OK no worries. I won't comment on it again.

Probaly the best thing to do boosh....

[beeched iizzz]

So just sweep it under the Rug Howgdize hey! Lightning can defend him but no one can criticise him! No one would be talking about a player who didnt have the reputation. What I think best in a forum is that people are free to comment...plain and simple. not having a go bud, but I rekon all issues are up for discussion

[Footy Chick]

That's true Beached but don't forget if you're going to have a crack - back it up with proof, not heresay (and make sure you're talking about the right bloke )

It's a mistake I've made

[beeched iizzz]

completely agree with you, but as Boosh said... he was there and the incident occurred 5 metres away. hard to make a mistake if you see the player who's number matches the name on the team sheet!!! but stranger things have happened!

[Lightning McQueen]

completely agree with you, but as Boosh said... he was there and the incident occurred 5 metres away. hard to make a mistake if you see the player who's number matches the name on the team sheet!!! but stranger things have happened!

I simply said to make sure he's talking about the right person. I'm not defending anyone, I find it "out of character" for Tyson to do such a thing.
If the teamsheet says it was Tyson and it was Tyson then fair enough, there are 3 Creeks that play/ played senior footy for Salisbury West.

[beeched iizzz]

so to be fair and just.... Which Creek is the one that should be blamed for these indescresions?

[beeched iizzz]

If its out of character for Tyson, then who's it in character for?

so to be fair and just.... Which Creek is the one that should be blamed for these indescresions?

[BenchedEagle]

so to be fair and just.... Which Creek is the one that should be blamed for these indescresions?

i think just after the incident that particular Creek was the one known as 'UpShit'

[beeched iizzz]

Beauty...LOL

so to be fair and just.... Which Creek is the one that should be blamed for these indescresions?

i think just after the incident that particular Creek was the one known as 'UpShit'

[Lightning McQueen]

If its out of character for Tyson, then who's it in character for?

so to be fair and just.... Which Creek is the one that should be blamed for these indescresions?

Sorry mate, I don't post negative stuff on here about players or clubs, never have, never will. I'll keep my negative opinions to myself. I just found it to be unlike Tyson.

[beeched iizzz]

But at the cost/advantage of clearing up things for your mate?????????????

If its out of character for Tyson, then who's it in character for?

so to be fair and just.... Which Creek is the one that should be blamed for these indescresions?

Sorry mate, I don't post negative stuff on here about players or clubs, never have, never will. I'll keep my negative opinions to myself. I just found it to be unlike Tyson.

[Lightning McQueen]

But at the cost/advantage of clearing up things for your mate?????????????

I've played against Tyson and seen him play many times, if it was him, I'm surpirsed. If Boosh has factual evidence that it was him who am I to pass judgement then, I wasn't there, I just asked that he made sure he got the correct person mate.