SA Footy

Bluedemon wrote:

Jimmy_041 wrote:How did Wesley LeGrand go?

Rulebook isn't umpiring anymore so didn't poll well.

This should be sent to the "How do you know you are 50 when..." thread

Charlie30 wrote:

bloods08 wrote:Div 5

Barry (GX) from Davison (KIL) & Phipps-Parsons (CLG)

Once again it shows how incompetent umpires are. Shouldn't be allowed to do the votes. Award them on reputation not performance.

I take it that you watched every game and calculated every players champion data points to come to this conclusion?

If you think div 5 umpires base their votes on reputation then you’re sillier then you claim them to be, most wouldn’t know who the players are and wouldn’t umpire the same team more than a few times. There’s no conspiracy theory when you’re awarding the votes as an umpire, you touch base with the other ump each quarter on who’s standing out and then you both agree on a top 3 after the game.

Bluedemon wrote:

Jimmy_041 wrote:How did Wesley LeGrand go?

Rulebook isn't umpiring anymore so didn't poll well.

I may very well be wrong but.............. some others appear to have read his book

Ezyasfallingdown wrote:

Charlie30 wrote:

bloods08 wrote:Div 5

Barry (GX) from Davison (KIL) & Phipps-Parsons (CLG)

Once again it shows how incompetent umpires are. Shouldn't be allowed to do the votes. Award them on reputation not performance.

Once again it comes down to a flog picking off on the umpires with a MASSIVE overgeneralisation - maybe you should be out there and try and work it out - the hardest job to do and, unfortunately, there is no other system - it is what it is......

Haha. Good one.

Jimmy_041 wrote:

Down the Hill wrote:Div 1

Abe Davis (Glen) by several votes.

2nd and 3rd - probably two of Trengove (PAOC), Bradley (PAOC), Noble (SHOC), C.Gaffney (PD), Brown (TTG).

Not enough wins for Brighton and SPOC but still expect Osborn & Vrodos to poll well and throw in O'Leary from Broadview.

Agree on Davis but I reckon Chris Curren will score more votes than Trenny.
The three of them will probably cancel their individual chances out but Davis was a standout when I saw him

Got the PAOC votes completely wrong

Anyone got a link to all medal winners here?

amber_fluid wrote:Anyone got a link to all medal winners here?

Adelaide Footy league facebook has one

Is there a round by round link?

The presentations I looked at didn’t show the first 4 rounds

Jimmy_041 wrote:

Jimmy_041 wrote:

Down the Hill wrote:Div 1

Abe Davis (Glen) by several votes.

2nd and 3rd - probably two of Trengove (PAOC), Bradley (PAOC), Noble (SHOC), C.Gaffney (PD), Brown (TTG).

Not enough wins for Brighton and SPOC but still expect Osborn & Vrodos to poll well and throw in O'Leary from Broadview.

Agree on Davis but I reckon Chris Curren will score more votes than Trenny.
The three of them will probably cancel their individual chances out but Davis was a standout when I saw him

Got the PAOC votes completely wrong

I didn't do too bad with some of my predictions other than Bradley and Brown. Jolly just keeps churning about consistent performances game in game out, year in year out and we probably underestimate how much the umpires take note. PAOC have this precise short passing game but Jolly is the one that seems to have a licence to pull off the high risk - high reward kick that he nails most of the time so that is what may take the umpires eye more than some of the other guns in their team.

Down the Hill wrote:

Jimmy_041 wrote:

Jimmy_041 wrote:

Down the Hill wrote:Div 1

Abe Davis (Glen) by several votes.

2nd and 3rd - probably two of Trengove (PAOC), Bradley (PAOC), Noble (SHOC), C.Gaffney (PD), Brown (TTG).

Not enough wins for Brighton and SPOC but still expect Osborn & Vrodos to poll well and throw in O'Leary from Broadview.

Agree on Davis but I reckon Chris Curren will score more votes than Trenny.
The three of them will probably cancel their individual chances out but Davis was a standout when I saw him

Got the PAOC votes completely wrong

I didn't do too bad with some of my predictions other than Bradley and Brown. Jolly just keeps churning about consistent performances game in game out, year in year out and we probably underestimate how much the umpires take note. PAOC have this precise short passing game but Jolly is the one that seems to have a licence to pull off the high risk - high reward kick that he nails most of the time so that is what may take the umpires eye more than some of the other guns in their team.

Hayden stands out physically and has quite distinctive skills and zip zap moves.
A lot of people miss what Trengove does as he's doesn't have a highly visible physique.
The umpires see him up close but its difficult from the boundary as there are lots of similar size players
Last Saturday, someone said he should get an orange mohawk so we can see him.
I am surprised that Curren and Bradley didn't poll higher.

Brodlach wrote:Is there a round by round link?

The presentations I looked at didn’t show the first 4 rounds

Nah everything started at round 5 for the purposes of the presentations not going on forever.

I know the league used to hand clubs details of their votes, Im unsure as to whether they still do this.