SA Footy

LOL I see our 18's were scheduled to play Smithfield this week as well... Forfeits and weeks off all round for everyone!!

beeroclock wrote:

morell wrote:Yeah exactly Senor, what is better, the possibility of an extra 3% or a week off.

I know what I would prefer.

3% and a week off all rolled into one.
Poor form by AV.

You miss the point, do try and keep up. Its an extra 3% if they had of played and smashed them, given Senor's example.

And how is it poor form? If they can't field a side, they can't field a side!! I wouldn't rule out a Mitchell Park forfeit later in the year if we cop some more injuries. If it wasn't for Flinders Uni last week it would have been then...

The only poor form I am seeing is Ingle Farm people complaining not being told earlier and potentially losing 3% while a club is on its deathbed.

Senor Moto Gadili wrote:

morell wrote:Yeah exactly Senor, what is better, the possibility of an extra 3% or a week off.

I know what I would prefer.

Yeah, freshen up before we play Mitchell Park next week.

Ah well, I guess we'll just have to mop up our tears with the T Shirts from the 2002 Grand Final.

morell wrote:

beeroclock wrote:

morell wrote:Yeah exactly Senor, what is better, the possibility of an extra 3% or a week off.

I know what I would prefer.

3% and a week off all rolled into one.
Poor form by AV.

You miss the point, do try and keep up. Its an extra 3% if they had of played and smashed them, given Senor's example.

And how is it poor form? If they can't field a side, they can't field a side!! I wouldn't rule out a Mitchell Park forfeit later in the year if we cop some more injuries. If it wasn't for Flinders Uni last week it would have been then...

The only poor form I am seeing is Ingle Farm people complaining not being told earlier and potentially losing 3% while a club is on its deathbed.

Poor form because they fielded two sides last week.
Mate I don't care about % to tell ya the truth.
My last post was tongue in check primarily.
I think they should stand up as a club and show some knackers no matter how much they get beat by.
What would your club do OH mighty one?
Forfeit both sides or make sure you had enough to represent the face of your club?
By the way you made every endeavour to make sure your club survived.

morell wrote:

Senor Moto Gadili wrote:

morell wrote:Yeah exactly Senor, what is better, the possibility of an extra 3% or a week off.

I know what I would prefer.

Yeah, freshen up before we play Mitchell Park next week.

Ah well, I guess we'll just have to mop up our tears with the T Shirts from the 2002 Grand Final.

I will mop up your tears next week after pulling your clubs pants down and spanking you blokes in every year you blokes were in SAFA.
Grow up Morell.

beeroclock wrote:

morell wrote:

Senor Moto Gadili wrote:

morell wrote:Yeah exactly Senor, what is better, the possibility of an extra 3% or a week off.

I know what I would prefer.

Yeah, freshen up before we play Mitchell Park next week.

Ah well, I guess we'll just have to mop up our tears with the T Shirts from the 2002 Grand Final.

I will mop up your tears next week after pulling your clubs pants down and spanking you blokes in every year you blokes were in SAFA.
Grow up Morell.

1988 SAFA ladder...

Edwardstown
Flinders Park
Brighton
Henley District
Payneham
Pooraka
Mitchell Park
Walkerville
Athelstone
Norwood Districts
Elizabeth
Ingle Farm

ingle farm were always div 2 safa every other year from 1983 onwards mitchells always div 1

morell wrote:

beeroclock wrote:

morell wrote:Yeah exactly Senor, what is better, the possibility of an extra 3% or a week off.

I know what I would prefer.

3% and a week off all rolled into one.
Poor form by AV.

You miss the point, do try and keep up. Its an extra 3% if they had of played and smashed them, given Senor's example.

And how is it poor form? If they can't field a side, they can't field a side!! I wouldn't rule out a Mitchell Park forfeit later in the year if we cop some more injuries. If it wasn't for Flinders Uni last week it would have been then...

The only poor form I am seeing is Ingle Farm people complaining not being told earlier and potentially losing 3% while a club is on its deathbed.

Better not forfeit next week morell

Correct about the complaining part, although don't think it's as bad as what you make it sound - not being told earlier is an annoyance, and that has only been mentioned once. The percentage part may seem trivial to you, but in the greater scheme of things where 1-4 are so tight it could well be the difference between a week off in the finals or an elimination final straight up.

As for Angle Vale being on their deathbed, it is certainly unfortunate and I hope they can turn it around in the future, but don't expect people to treat them any different. Don't see Kilburn or Brahma Lodge or even Mitchell Park being shown any preferential treatment or niceness because of their struggles.

I played in several seasons at Ingle Farm during the dark years recently, copping 30+ goal floggings weekly and declining down the divisions, and I can assure you it didn't stop people from other clubs sticking the boots in where they could or enjoying their percentage boosting wins.

Bloody SAFA.. F**k it, this is the 2000's, stop living in the past beeroclock, you're showing your age!

beeroclock wrote:

morell wrote:

beeroclock wrote:

morell wrote:Yeah exactly Senor, what is better, the possibility of an extra 3% or a week off.

I know what I would prefer.

3% and a week off all rolled into one.
Poor form by AV.

You miss the point, do try and keep up. Its an extra 3% if they had of played and smashed them, given Senor's example.

And how is it poor form? If they can't field a side, they can't field a side!! I wouldn't rule out a Mitchell Park forfeit later in the year if we cop some more injuries. If it wasn't for Flinders Uni last week it would have been then...

The only poor form I am seeing is Ingle Farm people complaining not being told earlier and potentially losing 3% while a club is on its deathbed.

Poor form because they fielded two sides last week.
Mate I don't care about % to tell ya the truth.
My last post was tongue in check primarily.
I think they should stand up as a club and show some knackers no matter how much they get beat by.
What would your club do OH mighty one?
Forfeit both sides or make sure you had enough to represent the face of your club?
By the way you made every endeavour to make sure your club survived.

They may have played 2 games last week but they had about a dozen blokes play 2 games.

Footy Chick wrote:I was under the impression that lowest grade forfeits first and then moves up.

You can't forfeit C's and field a D grade although I seem to recall an incident with Mudbery a few years back.

Rules could've changed since then though.

I couldn't find a specific rule stating that in R & R's, but common sense would say that's how it should be......we hope....

Cohiba wrote:

Footy Chick wrote:I was under the impression that lowest grade forfeits first and then moves up.

You can't forfeit C's and field a D grade although I seem to recall an incident with Mudbery a few years back.

Rules could've changed since then though.

I couldn't find a specific rule stating that in R & R's, but common sense would say that's how it should be......we hope....

Both grades forfeited so what's it matter?

25.4
A Member Club may only forfeit their lowest Division team(s). Failure to do so shall result in the forfeiting team(s)
and any of the same Member Club teams playing in any Divisions lower in the same round losing all points for such matches and
shall be debited with 60 points “against” in the premiership table in all such applicable Divisions.

This rule was brought in after Goodwood Saints forfeited their C Grade in a match against Broadview's C Grade in 1996 after fielding & playing their D Grade in the early game. At the time no rule existed to stop this from happening, it was just expected that you would forfeit your lowest sides and not that many clubs had 4 sides back them approx 6-8 clubs had 4 or more sides then.

frikken goodwood sandbaggers!

marbles wrote:frikken goodwood sandbaggers!

Wouldn't have happened if marbles super C grade was around back then lol

Phantom Gossiper wrote:

marbles wrote:frikken goodwood sandbaggers!

Wouldn't have happened if marbles super C grade was around back then lol

FFS PG, now we have to go through another 3 weeks of irrelevant bullsh*t............

Phantom Gossiper wrote:

Cohiba wrote:

Footy Chick wrote:I was under the impression that lowest grade forfeits first and then moves up.

You can't forfeit C's and field a D grade although I seem to recall an incident with Mudbery a few years back.

Rules could've changed since then though.

I couldn't find a specific rule stating that in R & R's, but common sense would say that's how it should be......we hope....

Both grades forfeited so what's it matter?

Bickle's post.......well i heard on the grape vine that they had a B grade side but only about 8 A graders, which makes me wonder why they didnt pull the B's........strange call.
User avatar
No mention of both sides forfeiting PG..... and if doesn't matter to you ....why did you bother....

Phantom Gossiper wrote:

marbles wrote:frikken goodwood sandbaggers!

Wouldn't have happened if marbles super C grade was around back then lol

haha long live the goodwood dgrade! we miss u & are here for u to rise, thrive, strive again

Cohiba wrote:

Phantom Gossiper wrote:

Cohiba wrote:

Footy Chick wrote:I was under the impression that lowest grade forfeits first and then moves up.

You can't forfeit C's and field a D grade although I seem to recall an incident with Mudbery a few years back.

Rules could've changed since then though.

I couldn't find a specific rule stating that in R & R's, but common sense would say that's how it should be......we hope....

Both grades forfeited so what's it matter?

Bickle's post.......well i heard on the grape vine that they had a B grade side but only about 8 A graders, which makes me wonder why they didnt pull the B's........strange call.
User avatar
No mention of both sides forfeiting PG..... and if doesn't matter to you ....why did you bother....

I said at the very start both sides forfeited so pay attention.. I bothered because I was confused why such a discussion was taking place when it anyway who was paying attention knew that both sides had been canned and the relevance of which side should forfeit was irrelevant.

Marbles, Beeroclocks team is higher on that ladder than Mitchell Park(the one you posted from the SAFA) and yes they did beat them every year in SAFA, who said Beeroclock played for Ingle Farm back in the SAFA days, his tem was a beauty no Bull..

old fullback wrote:Marbles, Beeroclocks team is higher on that ladder than Mitchell Park(the one you posted from the SAFA) and yes they did beat them every year in SAFA, who said Beeroclock played for Ingle Farm back in the SAFA days, his tem was a beauty no Bull..

Gee I hope you blokes spank the living shite out of them next week.