Page 4 of 7

Re: Promotion and Relegation

PostPosted: Wed Sep 27, 2017 5:06 pm
by zedman
Footy Chick wrote:But are Marion an Italy Green like MP, or are they a Salisbury North Green.(or even a GG green)

Maybe they could be two shades of green.


Image

Image

Re: Promotion and Relegation

PostPosted: Wed Sep 27, 2017 5:06 pm
by The Bedge
Marion-Mitchell Park Rams proposed jumper 2018

Marion-Mitchell Park.JPG
Marion-Mitchell Park.JPG (22.43 KiB) Viewed 2347 times

Re: Promotion and Relegation

PostPosted: Wed Sep 27, 2017 5:06 pm
by Brodlach
Is this actually being discussed or a Bedge thought?

Re: Promotion and Relegation

PostPosted: Wed Sep 27, 2017 5:07 pm
by Executive Member
Brodlach wrote:Is this actually being discussed or a Bedge thought?


in his wildest dreams it is

Re: Promotion and Relegation

PostPosted: Wed Sep 27, 2017 5:07 pm
by The Bedge
Brodlach wrote:Is this actually being discussed or a Bedge thought?

Just my thought.. the egos at each club would be far too proud to explore such an idea..

Re: Promotion and Relegation

PostPosted: Wed Sep 27, 2017 5:10 pm
by Brodlach
Cheers


Is the new Sports Hub going ahead at MP?

Re: Promotion and Relegation

PostPosted: Wed Sep 27, 2017 5:15 pm
by Look Good In Leather
Footy Chick wrote:But are Marion an Italy Green like MP, or are they a Salisbury North Green.(or even a GG green)

Maybe they could be two shades of green.


The "Double Greens"

Re: Promotion and Relegation

PostPosted: Wed Sep 27, 2017 5:39 pm
by Footy Chick
Apologies if I"m asking silly Marion questions but they're literally an unknown to me (and I'm too lazy to look them up)

We're all bored Brodlach, I'm sure MP has no plans to go anywhere!

Re: Promotion and Relegation

PostPosted: Wed Sep 27, 2017 5:43 pm
by The Bedge
In all seriousness though, given how difficult it is for clubs competing for players, sponsors and juniors these days - do people think amalgamation of clubs should be explored a little more?

Re: Promotion and Relegation

PostPosted: Wed Sep 27, 2017 5:51 pm
by morell
The Bedge wrote:
morell wrote:
The Bedge wrote:
morell wrote:morell's rules for merger talks

1. We play at Mitchell Park You can have select handful of home games each year, plus your own separate jnr football entity to remain. Sacred Heart will assume Mitchell Park as the home ground during winter to ensure the ground continues to gain usage.
2. Mitchell Park is in the name Can't see why/how a hyphenated 'Marion-Mitchell Park' wouldn't work
3. We wear green Being the predominant colour of Marion, this shouldn't be a concern.

ty
pls read post above, in particular, point #1


You'll be offered up as trade bait, so your rules wont matter :D

At this rate I'll be judge, jury, executioner, the defendant and the prosecutor

Re: Promotion and Relegation

PostPosted: Wed Sep 27, 2017 5:52 pm
by morell
Brodlach wrote:Cheers


Is the new Sports Hub going ahead at MP?
I'd be very surprised. At least not the plan they consulted with.

Re: Promotion and Relegation

PostPosted: Wed Sep 27, 2017 5:57 pm
by Yank Man
The Bedge wrote:In all seriousness though, given how difficult it is for clubs competing for players, sponsors and juniors these days - do people think amalgamation of clubs should be explored a little more?



Most clubs are too proud to go down that path and mergers become about people rather taking up the fight and dying than swallowing pride. This time last year we were talking about the Pulteney/Glenunga supposed merger talks. We all know the result of that.

Re: Promotion and Relegation

PostPosted: Wed Sep 27, 2017 5:59 pm
by Dutchy
morell wrote:
Brodlach wrote:Cheers


Is the new Sports Hub going ahead at MP?
I'd be very surprised. At least not the plan they consulted with.


Marion would have some of the best facilities in the AdFL, so no need to upgrade MP.

Re: Promotion and Relegation

PostPosted: Wed Sep 27, 2017 6:05 pm
by The Bedge
Yank Man wrote:
The Bedge wrote:In all seriousness though, given how difficult it is for clubs competing for players, sponsors and juniors these days - do people think amalgamation of clubs should be explored a little more?



Most clubs are too proud to go down that path and mergers become about people rather taking up the fight and dying than swallowing pride. This time last year we were talking about the Pulteney/Glenunga supposed merger talks. We all know the result of that.

Very true, but people should but the pride and egos aside and think about longevity for the future. Players aren't loyal these days, so what value is there in members remaining loyal to a bygone era?

Pulteney and Glenunga came out pretty good this year, but Glenunga are on the rise as a club, and Pulteney despite winning the flag will continue to be a battling club with no juniors, no clubrooms, average facilities and not a great connection with the school football program.

Some clubs just seem like "right" fits for each other i.e. Mawson Lakes/Para Hills, Mitchell Park/Marion, hell even North Pines/Central United

Re: Promotion and Relegation

PostPosted: Wed Sep 27, 2017 6:18 pm
by morell
Dutchy wrote:
morell wrote:
Brodlach wrote:Cheers


Is the new Sports Hub going ahead at MP?
I'd be very surprised. At least not the plan they consulted with.


Marion would have some of the best facilities in the AdFL, so no need to upgrade MP.

It's no Moreland Ave.

Re: Promotion and Relegation

PostPosted: Wed Sep 27, 2017 6:20 pm
by Yank Man
The Bedge wrote:
Yank Man wrote:
The Bedge wrote:In all seriousness though, given how difficult it is for clubs competing for players, sponsors and juniors these days - do people think amalgamation of clubs should be explored a little more?



Most clubs are too proud to go down that path and mergers become about people rather taking up the fight and dying than swallowing pride. This time last year we were talking about the Pulteney/Glenunga supposed merger talks. We all know the result of that.

Very true, but people should but the pride and egos aside and think about longevity for the future. Players aren't loyal these days, so what value is there in members remaining loyal to a bygone era?

Pulteney and Glenunga came out pretty good this year, but Glenunga are on the rise as a club, and Pulteney despite winning the flag will continue to be a battling club with no juniors, no clubrooms, average facilities and not a great connection with the school football program.

Some clubs just seem like "right" fits for each other i.e. Mawson Lakes/Para Hills, Mitchell Park/Marion, hell even North Pines/Central United



Agree with you, frankly it's about your junior structure. Clubs that are strong in that area will remain strong and develop providing they hold on to them and get them playing up. If you don't have a junior system that has them coming through over the next 4 or 5 years consistently you will always be chasing your tail, or paying out hard earned $$$$ to stay alive.

Re: Promotion and Relegation

PostPosted: Thu Sep 28, 2017 8:42 am
by Boosh
The Bedge wrote:
Yank Man wrote:
The Bedge wrote:In all seriousness though, given how difficult it is for clubs competing for players, sponsors and juniors these days - do people think amalgamation of clubs should be explored a little more?



Most clubs are too proud to go down that path and mergers become about people rather taking up the fight and dying than swallowing pride. This time last year we were talking about the Pulteney/Glenunga supposed merger talks. We all know the result of that.

Very true, but people should but the pride and egos aside and think about longevity for the future. Players aren't loyal these days, so what value is there in members remaining loyal to a bygone era?

Pulteney and Glenunga came out pretty good this year, but Glenunga are on the rise as a club, and Pulteney despite winning the flag will continue to be a battling club with no juniors, no clubrooms, average facilities and not a great connection with the school football program.

Some clubs just seem like "right" fits for each other i.e. Mawson Lakes/Para Hills, Mitchell Park/Marion, hell even North Pines/Central United


Para Hills/ Ingle Farm

Re: Promotion and Relegation

PostPosted: Thu Sep 28, 2017 9:58 am
by The Bedge
Boosh wrote:Para Hills/ Ingle Farm

Could work, only reason i didn't suggest those two is both clubs have reasonable facilities and juniors/girls teams.

Mawson Lakes has nothing.

Re: Promotion and Relegation

PostPosted: Thu Sep 28, 2017 10:02 am
by Jimmy_041
Yank Man wrote:
The Bedge wrote:In all seriousness though, given how difficult it is for clubs competing for players, sponsors and juniors these days - do people think amalgamation of clubs should be explored a little more?



Most clubs are too proud to go down that path and mergers become about people rather taking up the fight and dying than swallowing pride. This time last year we were talking about the Pulteney/Glenunga supposed merger talks. We all know the result of that.


Two premierships?

Re: Promotion and Relegation

PostPosted: Thu Sep 28, 2017 10:03 am
by jo172
I'd be amazed if the concentration of teams around the Salisbury area remains as it is in 10 years time.

Would have thought a few of Brahma, North Pines, Salisbury North, Salisbury and Salisbury West will either merge or cease to operate.